Pegasus Pie Co.

320 S 1st St, Mount Vernon
(360) 548-9658

Recent Reviews

Sort by
jisselle romero

love and the coffee and love the pies even more !!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

John N Sherrie Green

Great hand pies and paninis! The soups are delicious as well! Very friendly service! Highly recommend!

kathie

After I read a couple reviews, I wanted to try this bakery out. So glad I did! The bakery itself is charming and the staff, friendly. I purchased a bourbon pecan pie, an oversized salted chocolate chip cookie and 2 cinnamon rolls. All were absolutely delicious! The cookie was fresh and well balanced with chocolate, butter, and a touch of salt. Cinnamon rolls were so fresh, with a perfect amount of tasty frosting on top. The pie was the best pecan pie I have ever had! Loaded with pecans, it was so smooth and silky inside. You can taste the freshness of all the ingredients. A little far for me, but definitely my new 'go to' bakery. There are tables inside so you don't have to order to go. Located on a cute little street with lots of other little shops. Plenty of free public parking.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Vince Manduchi

these guys would be 5 of 5 but the cost is very steep, albeit worth the money dang the crusts are awesome, the berries sweetened not sugary, the cinnamon rolls are super tasty and melt in your mouth so glad you opened in Mt

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Lisa Taggart

I walked into the establishment mistakenly at closing time but was greeted with warmth and a smile. After chatting for a few minutes, I chose a strawberry rhubarb hand pie and a couple of raspberry lemon scones, and I can not express enough the superb quality of these baked goods a literal melt in your mouth with deliciousness experience. The truth is I had the pie and scone with tea rather than a proper dinner because I simply couldn't resist, haha. I will be back as soon as I'm able (tomorrow-wink, wink). I'm not kidding. If you haven't been here, run, don't walk.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cherry Hand Pie

Kyle

Initially discovered them at the weekend Markets. But now I come here at least once every few weeks. Great with everything they do. Definitely recommend the Maple Burboun Pecan pie!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Brownies, Pecan Pie

jessica london

Went in for a working interview. Reported to health department within first 2 hours. Crew was washing hands in shared buckets because of no running water while prepping those pies. I repeat. NO RUNNING WATER. no restroom or hand washing sinks were running the whole entirety of my working interview.
Hard working crew but absolutely disgusting and wouldn’t recommend to anybody.
Owner is 1 year into her business and has no idea what food safety standards are.

Report has been made to appropriate food and safety. Please report as well if anything doesn’t meet standards. Multiple reports have gone in.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

M

Amazing fruit hand pies here! The crust is so flaky and buttery and delicious, and the fruit is great too. Fav hand pie in the area, my fav flavor is the cherry. Kinda expensive but still highly recommend! Nice friendly staff too!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ricardo Hirata-Okamoto

First time after a walk. Had coffee and pies. Very good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Adam Jensen

The most delicious pastries and pies in the Northwest! The pasties have the exact balance between sweet and tartness and not an excessive amount of sugar. The filling gets to speak very loudly for itself. Great spot to have lunch and desserts. I also hear they serve espresso now!

Kayti Clayton

Unfortunately this pie company doesn't actually carry pie ?. Hoping if you're looking for a pie you see this and save yourself the drive. If you want an actual pie you have to special order or 'get lucky'. The staff was super nice but I can't get over how weird it is that a pie company wouldn't have pies as part of their regular inventory.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

Cassandra Rossi

Love this place!

I stop here when I'm in town for hand pies and paninis. So good! If you have a large number of sandwiches, they might come out one at a time due to only having one press.

Recently, we ordered pies for our wedding. We ordered an assortment (marionberry, blueberry-peach, and cherry). We even got a vegan crust on one pie for our vegan guests!
The pies were delicious and ready early on the day of the wedding! Our guests loved them, totally worth the splurge!

Vegetarian options: Many vegetarian sandwiches (grilled cheese, caprese, mushroom melt)

Dietary restrictions: Vegan options available

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Todd Lee

We got there two hours before closing and there were no pies. I settled for a "hand pie" (a turnover the size of a Hostess fruit pie) that was $9. It wasn't any better than any turnover I've had anywhere else. Just what Mt Vernon needs, another over-priced boutique.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

Emma Holbrook

Bought a pie from the Ballard market- lovely raspberry rhubarb. Put on some whipped cream, highly recommend. Thank you!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alexander Erchenkov

Store was closed "for a team building". Google maps listing wasn't updated, we lost valuable our time of our trip

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Loading...