Alfy's Pizza at Water's Edge

Fantastic pizza shop for families! My kids love the game room, and the view isn’t bad either. :) We appreciated the military discount and love the chicken Alfredo pizza and the garlic breadsticks!!

Decent original pizzas. They discontinued the one I liked :( I've been here a few times and though there's hardly anyone there, they didn't seem eager to make a good impression on my visit. They seemed bothered by having to do something. Maybe just the help they had at the time. Maybe it's changed for the better. Good location.

I tried calling to order a pizza for pickup 45 minutes before they closed. They answered the phone "Thank you for calling Alfy's we're currently closed what else can I help you with?". About a week later I thought I would give them another shot. I tried ordering online (hours before their listed close time), and it wouldn't let me. I tried calling 4 or 5 times.. it just rang and rang. I drove down to the restaurant and they were closed at 4pm??? I WAS trying to give them a fair shot, but I will now never eat a slice of Alfy's pizza. This level of "customer service" is worst in class. Oak Harbor location.

So great place. Salad bar with many options and the calzones are delicious! Try sitting upstairs and enjoy the view.

Wasn't impressed, won't go back. I've had good pizza,it wasn't here.Overpriced. Little. Caesar's. Is the best and should be #1.

Reasonable price for yummy pizza and friendly stuff, nice place for family pizza night!

Visited for the first time last week. The staff seemed annoyed that we were there, the pizza was decent, the salad bar was great and so was the scenery. The nostalgic video games were a fun touch!

While the dough itself was fine, the hand rolled pizza was far from hand rolled, and the thin crust was thicker than the regular. Maybe an off night, but I think a frozen pizza from Safeway might have been a better choice. Have no idea how this has ever been rated the best pizza on the Island. So far it's been our worst pizza experience.

This place has the best view ! The pizza is good and the salad bar is a throw back don't see that much anymore. My wife ordered a pepperoni and mushroom and I had a cowboy both personal size and we wanted to try the salad bar too ! They have a one time through or you can get all you can eat salad bar. They also have a couple video games for the kids ! Of I had to gripe about something is the lettuce was a bit wilted or dry but we still ate and it was decent. The lady that took our order and greeted us was super nice and patient. I would really recommend trying this place for yourself if your ever in Oak harbor.

We decided to try delivery (door dash) and got the Calzones. AMAZING!! Definitely the best calzone I've ever had.

I love the all you can eat salad bar! Yes, the pizza is awesome. Yes, the ranch dressing is made from scratch. The grinders are hot and perfect for when you don't need a whole pizza. But my favorite part is the salad bar with garlic bread on the side. Score! The photo is the view at sunset from the front door of Alfys.

Saturday, Feb, 19. around 3:00 pmThe female that attended me was rude. I ordered boneless wings and seemed that she didn’t pay attention, didn’t listen,or didn’t want to listen, I don’t know. But I told her two times very clear Boneless. The point is that the waiter or cook gave me the wings with bones and I told him “I ordered boneless “ and he replied very rudely “We don’t have boneless wings”I ask myself why is it on the menu if you don’t have it? And those employees need to learn costumer service and attention to details….Not going back ?

This was the most delicious pizza! We ordered 2 pies for a picnic and couldn’t have enjoyed it more! Friendly staff and fast service! Will definitely be back!

They have a salad bar!!! Yummy! AYCE for $9.99 at dinner. I helped myself to two big plates of greens, crispy garlic breadsticks and all the fixings (yes, they have baby corn).The pizza is fresh & delicious too!

The food was good. They don't tell you they put a 8% tip added on already..If you pay with a card. It props you to tip. Not realizing one was already added.. They need to tell you. Once you get your receipt you'll see it on there. 8% plus, what ever you added on. Makes me not want to tip at all. It's a scam!!