Damn Fine Pizza

1307 Bay St, Port Orchard
(360) 443-6116

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Tisha Jolene Eby

This place is it for dine in pizza. Loved the pizza, loved the desserts, loved the room full of pinball machines + board games in the back to play at your table while you wait :)

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Facetious76

I was feeling lazy and didn't want to search out anything special. This place offers vegan cheese, as well as, a vegan pepperoni. The pepperoni wasn't bad, and they did not skimp on the cheese (which a lot of places treat like it's gold). I did feel like they were a little light handed with the veggies, but that is always hit or miss in my experience. The service was friendly and I would go back.

StayC One111

Nice unique pizza place. Though a little overpriced. We got a 16" pizza marg (to go) and a beer and one cocktail and it was over $50. Not including a tip. I guess it's sign of the times. However, it's gonna hit restaurants like these hard. Less people eating out.. just saying. But pretty cool place and nice staff. Just a little pricey for pizza and beer.

Vegetarian options: Typical options for vegetarian and pizza . And vegan option.

Kid-friendliness: Somewhat kid friendly. Have old school pinball machines that are neat.

Wheelchair accessibility: Except for the curb outside the restaurant, there are tables that have room for wheelchairs.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Courtney Curtis

I know the food is good because I've had it before, but whoever was on the phone tonight sounded super immature. They answered and said "hellooooo?" In a fake voice and then started laughing and hung up. I tried to call again and they've ignored my calls. Who does that 🤣

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

Scott Jordan

Pretty cool pizza joint at the former Slaughter County Brewing location. The views are amazing; and the atmosphere, character, and service are terrific. The pizza has its pros and cons. The crust is fantastic! But the sauce, cheese, and toppings were reminiscent of DiGiorno's frozen pizzas. But maybe that aspect will improve as time goes on.
Regardless, this spot is worth a visit. Grab a beer, play some pinball, and enjoy the view!

Kid-friendliness: Kid-friendly; no minors allowed in bar area.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: The Bomb

Michael S

Good pizza but don't waste your time paying and ordering ahead. Very chaotic experience. No information on where to go when you walk in. Cashier is all the way in the back.

Had to wait for the cashier to finish with everyone in line instead of picking up and going. Bonus points because she tried give my pizza to everyone but me (after the only helpful person already pointed me out) and ignoring me standing in front of her.

Food: 4

Service: 1

Jasper Hill

Love the outside area. Everything else was just me. Kinda pricey too

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 2

M KS

Food is great but just wish they had more options for appetizers. Like that they have GF and dairy free options. Desserts were great! I’d give service five stars if it wasn’t only self serve. Great atmosphere - comfy, casual, beautiful views. Staff are always super nice!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Austin Page

Very underwhelming, very pricy for portion sizes. Sandwiches don't come with a side but are more expensive than a whole meal elsewhere, not to mention the sandwich was pretty darn small for 14 dollars. Too much going on with ingredients and fairly hipster selection of ingredients on all menu items. Might work for some, not for me. With 13 years of restaurant experience with cooking and managing I'd say I'm pretty qualified to criticize when it is due. I'd like to see less À la carte and more meal driven items as a customer.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 4

Matthew Hoskinson

Pizza made me throw up

Food: 1

Luke

I don't give too many negative reviews but this place just did not have good service.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

KristinSteele

Great local pub that serves food. We came here for the vegan pizza and beer. It didn’t disappoint! The crust is nice and crispy and the cheese melted. The vegan pepperoni was a little hard but that happens sometimes. Overall, I enjoyed the food!

Un Tucked Tee

I love how they do the ordering and seating. The way it’s structured keeps everything moving so well. Everyone was friendly. The people who were food runners are super friendly and helpful. We ordered the bomb pizza. It was delish! And let’s not forget to mention that killer music they play! The kitchen was proficient with the food Timing. All around it was a good first experience.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: The Bomb

Mark S.

Been here twice. Both times were Sunday lunch. Pizza has been consistently good. Not surprisingly, made-to-order whole pizzas were of better quality than buying by the slice. Service was good the first visit, but lacking on the second. Took longer for the single slice we ordered to come out than the whole pizza. Saw staff standing in the corner chatting rather than focusing on customer service...
Waterfront view from the outdoor seating is very nice. Indoor seating is plentiful, but it is a loud environment with the music always playing. Overall, I would return for the pizza, and definitely try to find an outdoor seat on a nice day.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Reg Cannoli, Henny Plz

Wade Ayers

Ambiance food way better than slaughter County ever was

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...