Sweet pies have always been great but twice i have bought a chicken pot pie that was supposed to be already cooked just needed to reheat it at home, and the crust was not cooked. It had a nice golden layer on the very top but right under that everything else was uncooked dough. The insides taste good but the crust is half the meal.
Monali Agarwal
Best ever pie shopping experience with a guy who works there. Never got your name but you’re from the south—your fun commentary, your recs, made pie shopping a super fun experience, thank you!!
We loved peach pie the most, then strawberry rhubarb, then cherry
G J
We had a super pleasant interaction with Mina- she is awesome! My brother Jack and I will certainly be back!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Paul Curry
The cream pies were amazing. There was a bit of trouble getting the savory pies to warm up in the oven. Will for sure be going back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Catherine Rosado
This place has excellent services I love ❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Enrico or Eric
New to the area but have come a few times on weekdays and weekends for both savory (chicken pot pie) and sweet pies (key lime, Mexican chocolate). It’s perfectly good pie and everyone has been super friendly to me and my dog. Good hours means I can stop in for lunch or for dessert. Glad it’s in the neighborhood!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joseph Banks
A feeind went in an bought a french apple pie it has no flavor like they didn't use any sugar it was very tart not even fully done on the top I will never buy their nasty pies again so disappointing
Food: 1
Amanda Guerrero
Best cherry pie I have ever had! My husband doesn't even like pies and when I brought home a piece of the cherry pie for him to taste, he ate the whole thing. And requested we get some more :) Great service, great people!
Sal P.
It was a little hard to find, at first. It’s set back from the street next to a burger place that blocked my initial view, going west on NW 56th St. Went just for the Cheese cake (Crème Brûlée topping). It was worth the find. Very tasty. I like to savor every bite to get the full flavor.
If you need to take dessert to a function this is the place to pick up a pie that everyone will love!! You can call ahead to reserve and pick up at your leisure. My favorite is the Mexican Chocolate Pie!
Aryaun
The Crème Brûlée Cheesecake should be a permanent menu item! So decedent and succulent I also loved the Cherry Almond Cheesecake👌 The Seasonal items are the best.
Brooke Nyman
Great all around! Highly recommend!
Emily Bernhardt
Did a tasting to have the pies at my wedding. Chris is absolutely wonderful and the pies are amazing. Great pricing, the pies are made with skill and love. 12/10!
Paul
It seems shrinkflation has hit my favorite pie store. Bought a slice the other day and it's clear they have reduced the size of slices significantly (and packaging to match so you don't notice). Unfortunately not worth the high price anymore. 2 stars instead of 1 because I still like the pies, but I won't pay more for less and won't be back.
Sweet pies have always been great but twice i have bought a chicken pot pie that was supposed to be already cooked just needed to reheat it at home, and the crust was not cooked. It had a nice golden layer on the very top but right under that everything else was uncooked dough. The insides taste good but the crust is half the meal.
Best ever pie shopping experience with a guy who works there. Never got your name but you’re from the south—your fun commentary, your recs, made pie shopping a super fun experience, thank you!!
We loved peach pie the most, then strawberry rhubarb, then cherry
We had a super pleasant interaction with Mina- she is awesome! My brother Jack and I will certainly be back!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The cream pies were amazing. There was a bit of trouble getting the savory pies to warm up in the oven. Will for sure be going back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
This place has excellent services I love ❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
New to the area but have come a few times on weekdays and weekends for both savory (chicken pot pie) and sweet pies (key lime, Mexican chocolate). It’s perfectly good pie and everyone has been super friendly to me and my dog. Good hours means I can stop in for lunch or for dessert. Glad it’s in the neighborhood!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
A feeind went in an bought a french apple pie it has no flavor like they didn't use any sugar it was very tart not even fully done on the top I will never buy their nasty pies again so disappointing
Food: 1
Best cherry pie I have ever had! My husband doesn't even like pies and when I brought home a piece of the cherry pie for him to taste, he ate the whole thing. And requested we get some more :) Great service, great people!
It was a little hard to find, at first. It’s set back from the street next to a burger place that blocked my initial view, going west on NW 56th St. Went just for the Cheese cake (Crème Brûlée topping). It was worth the find. Very tasty. I like to savor every bite to get the full flavor.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Worth a trip.
Restaurantji Recommends
If you need to take dessert to a function this is the place to pick up a pie that everyone will love!! You can call ahead to reserve and pick up at your leisure. My favorite is the Mexican Chocolate Pie!
The Crème Brûlée Cheesecake should be a permanent menu item!
So decedent and succulent
I also loved the Cherry Almond Cheesecake👌
The Seasonal items are the best.
Great all around! Highly recommend!
Did a tasting to have the pies at my wedding. Chris is absolutely wonderful and the pies are amazing. Great pricing, the pies are made with skill and love. 12/10!
It seems shrinkflation has hit my favorite pie store. Bought a slice the other day and it's clear they have reduced the size of slices significantly (and packaging to match so you don't notice). Unfortunately not worth the high price anymore. 2 stars instead of 1 because I still like the pies, but I won't pay more for less and won't be back.
Loading...