Lots of reviews and now for my first negative one. Big Mario manager, let your employees know feedback is a positive thing. That’s how you get better. One star for being open “late” on Wednesday. One star for friendly cashier. I Agree with others reviews here, no salt on the crust and sauce was flavor free. Crust was also burnt on one of our pieces but we let that slide. Because of our love for BM initially wasn’t going to say anything. But as I continued eating this flavor free pizza, I thought, I should tell this place, a place we have liked for years - this particular slice doesn’t have any flavor outside of the pepperoni. It tasted like cooked flour, with unsalted tomato product on top. My expectation was a light apology. Maybe an offer for another piece or simply an apology. I understand kitchens aren’t perfect. Instead I received some gruff angry response about “salt in pizza crust?” And some other under breath remark from the pizza cook. I guess that’s how Mario”s rolls these days. The hostess tried to be nice but the big Mario looking chef was not ready for any feedback. They simple walked off and the cashier moved on. Well, here’s your star. I now join the crowd calling Mario’s overpriced pizza, overpriced beer, and slices served with burned crust with NO flavor. I suppose it maybe better drunk, and/or, after smoking. Or more stars if you need to watch sodium intake. Whatever you do, do not let the kitchen know, they don’t take any form of feedback or criticism. Should have waited in line at the other place 3 blocks west. I will make sure to let people know that the kitchen crew is very sensitive, does not take feedback, and sells salt free overpriced pizza.
Nicholas Hoag
Iconic. Classic. Crust is to die for still to this day.
Christine Torres Hicks
THIS is pizza. When that smell hits...you know this is going to be good. Absolutely fantastic crust to toppings ratio. Each bite gives you all the flavor. Great portions. The staff are so awesome. Genuinely friendly and helpful. Definitely get the Seattle cola to wash it down. Yummmmm!!
Kevin Kangara
Savor the mouthwatering delight of pizza, bursting with a symphony of bold flavors that dance on your palate. Each slice is a warm embrace of melted cheese, rich tomato sauce, and a medley of fresh toppings, all harmoniously mingling to create an unforgettable culinary experience.
Rashell Gerber
This is probably the worst pizza I have ever had. The sauce has no flavor, the crust has no flavor, and there is hardly any cheese on it. Also, it’s soggy and floppy. It is really a disappointment to pizza. Like would it kill you to put a little garlic or salt in your sauce? 🤮
Blake Hamilton
I hate leaving bad reviews but something needs to change, the slices I got were so expensive, crunchy, barely any cheese or flavor & hardly even warm.
I was hoping for a slice like the ones they have at Rocco’s.
Sorry for the bad review guys, it was just a bummer.
Food: 1
Jordan Barnes
Great pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A
Legitimate New York Pizza in Seattle. The pizza man (chef) and everyone else were so sweet. There's a secret bar in the back that is fun with bodhi on draft!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Slice
Betz
The workers are super nice the pizza in fine, not anything to write home about but god forbid if you want to eat at the place you just bought food at if your under 21. You can't even sit in the booths, that's wack. I like that they serve slices all day that's really the only thing they have going for them besides being close to Neumos.
the pizza is a 6.5 max. too floppy and the sauce is not right. the crisp is crazy though. the beer tastes diluted. honestly no thoughts other than its a very average/below average spot in a great location.
service was decent, atmosphere is just like any other dive bar around
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Slice, Cheese Pizza
Rowan B
This place sucks guys
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
ryan toupin
Awesome pizza spot! Great pizza and super friendly staff. Seriously so nice. Good music and atmosphere. Stop in for a slice!
Vegetarian options: Vegan and veggie pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza
Petra Biglow
great pizza served up by friendly people at a reasonable price.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Elwin Martin
By the slice, barely room temperature since it was heated so little. If I hadn't eaten it right outside it would've been straight back to cold by the time I'd walked to my car.
Not good enough for me to recommend or come back to next time I'm in Seattle but my standards for pizza are relatively high. Cost of living is high here but wow does it hurt to spend $7 on a slice of pizza before tax and have it not be great.
Lots of reviews and now for my first negative one. Big Mario manager, let your employees know feedback is a positive thing. That’s how you get better.
One star for being open “late” on Wednesday. One star for friendly cashier.
I Agree with others reviews here, no salt on the crust and sauce was flavor free. Crust was also burnt on one of our pieces but we let that slide. Because of our love for BM initially wasn’t going to say anything.
But as I continued eating this flavor free pizza, I thought, I should tell this place, a place we have liked for years - this particular slice doesn’t have any flavor outside of the pepperoni. It tasted like cooked flour, with unsalted tomato product on top.
My expectation was a light apology. Maybe an offer for another piece or simply an apology. I understand kitchens aren’t perfect.
Instead I received some gruff angry response about “salt in pizza crust?” And some other under breath remark from the pizza cook.
I guess that’s how Mario”s rolls these days.
The hostess tried to be nice but the big Mario looking chef was not ready for any feedback. They simple walked off and the cashier moved on.
Well, here’s your star.
I now join the crowd calling Mario’s overpriced pizza, overpriced beer, and slices served with burned crust with NO flavor.
I suppose it maybe better drunk, and/or, after smoking. Or more stars if you need to watch sodium intake.
Whatever you do, do not let the kitchen know, they don’t take any form of feedback or criticism.
Should have waited in line at the other place 3 blocks west.
I will make sure to let people know that the kitchen crew is very sensitive, does not take feedback, and sells salt free overpriced pizza.
Iconic. Classic. Crust is to die for still to this day.
THIS is pizza. When that smell hits...you know this is going to be good. Absolutely fantastic crust to toppings ratio. Each bite gives you all the flavor. Great portions. The staff are so awesome. Genuinely friendly and helpful. Definitely get the Seattle cola to wash it down. Yummmmm!!
Savor the mouthwatering delight of pizza, bursting with a symphony of bold flavors that dance on your palate. Each slice is a warm embrace of melted cheese, rich tomato sauce, and a medley of fresh toppings, all harmoniously mingling to create an unforgettable culinary experience.
This is probably the worst pizza I have ever had. The sauce has no flavor, the crust has no flavor, and there is hardly any cheese on it. Also, it’s soggy and floppy. It is really a disappointment to pizza. Like would it kill you to put a little garlic or salt in your sauce? 🤮
I hate leaving bad reviews but something needs to change, the slices I got were so expensive, crunchy, barely any cheese or flavor & hardly even warm.
I was hoping for a slice like the ones they have at Rocco’s.
Sorry for the bad review guys, it was just a bummer.
Food: 1
Great pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Legitimate New York Pizza in Seattle. The pizza man (chef) and everyone else were so sweet. There's a secret bar in the back that is fun with bodhi on draft!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Slice
The workers are super nice the pizza in fine, not anything to write home about but god forbid if you want to eat at the place you just bought food at if your under 21. You can't even sit in the booths, that's wack. I like that they serve slices all day that's really the only thing they have going for them besides being close to Neumos.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 4
The bartender was totally hot
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
the pizza is a 6.5 max. too floppy and the sauce is not right. the crisp is crazy though. the beer tastes diluted. honestly no thoughts other than its a very average/below average spot in a great location.
service was decent, atmosphere is just like any other dive bar around
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Slice, Cheese Pizza
This place sucks guys
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Awesome pizza spot! Great pizza and super friendly staff. Seriously so nice. Good music and atmosphere. Stop in for a slice!
Vegetarian options: Vegan and veggie pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza
great pizza served up by friendly people at a reasonable price.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
By the slice, barely room temperature since it was heated so little. If I hadn't eaten it right outside it would've been straight back to cold by the time I'd walked to my car.
Not good enough for me to recommend or come back to next time I'm in Seattle but my standards for pizza are relatively high. Cost of living is high here but wow does it hurt to spend $7 on a slice of pizza before tax and have it not be great.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Loading...