Rose is our family's favorite flavor. The lemon cookie flavor is great too but I rarely see it. The quality of the gelato is really good at Fainting Goat. It is by far our favorite gelato shop.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Katie Sarno
Love the gelato here. Glad they’re reopening in a space in the same
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mint Gelato, Homemade Waffle Cone, Pistachio Gelato
Victoria Ecker
This location is closed, and will soon be opening again just down the street. I love fainting goat, and will update with 5 stars once they’re open again, but wanted to give a psa! We were so excited for a lil treat after getting boosted, and then were super bummed since google maps showed they were open.
Anmol Grewal
Unfortunately didn’t get to try the place. They close an hour earlier than their posted closing time on google maps. I recommend calling ahead, happened with 2 different locations…
Anna C.
This place's gelato is so good, I mean seriously. Lots of ice cream choices in Wallingford after dinner and I almost always spring for fainting goat . i mean, you really just cannot beat the thick texture and deeep flavor. I'm a huge fan and have been for years. I also recently tried their molten cake and it was DELIGHTFUL. You can definitely tell it was homemade that day- really rich and deeply chocolatey. exactly what I was hoping for. Will be back the next time I need dessert in Wallingford. And the next time after that, too.**would def be interested in some more flavors being added to their roster... but that in no way detracts from their hard earned five stars
tt p.
The best! I had oral surgery and could only eat ice cream for 5 days. I tried every ice cream place in the area, Fainting goat was the best by a long shot. If you want a scoop or can only eat ice cream - highly recommend.
peedublyou
Gelato was icy and the earl grey flavor was not strong enough.
B Johnson
Great gelato in a laid-back shop. We routinely get pints to take home in addition to the inevitable in-house scoops. Plus, how can you resist a fainting goat?
Alyssa Johnson
Amazing Gelato Flavors and bright and lively unique artwork for sale too!
boutzie
We enjoyed the variety of flavors this place offers as well as reasonable prices for Seattle. We had a large cone with sour cherry and double expresso. Both flavors were delicious. Highly recommend!
Great, diverse options, and reasonable prices. They have a nice variety of eclectic/creative and conventional flavors, so there's something for everyone.Gelato is generally a little lighter and less sweet than ice cream, which I prefer. I recently had toasted almond, which is a nice balance of sweet and a little savory (for ice cream).
Becky P.
It punched me in the face with chocolate, and I deeply respect that.The espresso flavor is also very good
Kathy N.
My friends and I tried the chocolate fondante, Mexican vanilla bean, and pistachio, and tiramisu in a pint. The medium size, which allows 3 flavors, was pretty hefty and definitely for sharing with friends. The gelatos were all smooth and creamy. The chocolate had a fairly bitter taste to it and I thought it tasted like cocoa powder. I'd categorize it as an adult chocolate rather than one you'd want to give kids. I've never had Mexican vanilla bean before but the flavor itself was so pronounced and strong in the gelato, which I appreciated. The pistachio and tiramisu ones had more subtle flavorsThe medium was $7.50
Emma T.
I just love the name and the gelato was pretty good. It was a bit expensive but would go again to try out the different flavors. The service was quick, especially since I went during December and it was snowing in Seattle. lol Would love to try it again during a warmer season It's a cute store and had some seating. We parked on the street when we visited.
Shantala A.
Stopped by for a quick gelato craving after dinner. The chocolate flavor was ummmmmmmm sooooooooooo goooooood. So fudgy, gooey and oh so delicious. I could eat it all day. Hubby got the lemon olive oil and rose flavors and loved it. Lemon was tart, just how he likes. And rose was very refreshing. Great dessert option if you are in the hood!
Rose is our family's favorite flavor. The lemon cookie flavor is great too but I rarely see it. The quality of the gelato is really good at Fainting Goat. It is by far our favorite gelato shop.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love the gelato here. Glad they’re reopening in a space in the same
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mint Gelato, Homemade Waffle Cone, Pistachio Gelato
This location is closed, and will soon be opening again just down the street. I love fainting goat, and will update with 5 stars once they’re open again, but wanted to give a psa! We were so excited for a lil treat after getting boosted, and then were super bummed since google maps showed they were open.
Unfortunately didn’t get to try the place. They close an hour earlier than their posted closing time on google maps. I recommend calling ahead, happened with 2 different locations…
This place's gelato is so good, I mean seriously. Lots of ice cream choices in Wallingford after dinner and I almost always spring for fainting goat . i mean, you really just cannot beat the thick texture and deeep flavor. I'm a huge fan and have been for years. I also recently tried their molten cake and it was DELIGHTFUL. You can definitely tell it was homemade that day- really rich and deeply chocolatey. exactly what I was hoping for. Will be back the next time I need dessert in Wallingford. And the next time after that, too.**would def be interested in some more flavors being added to their roster... but that in no way detracts from their hard earned five stars
The best! I had oral surgery and could only eat ice cream for 5 days. I tried every ice cream place in the area, Fainting goat was the best by a long shot. If you want a scoop or can only eat ice cream - highly recommend.
Gelato was icy and the earl grey flavor was not strong enough.
Great gelato in a laid-back shop. We routinely get pints to take home in addition to the inevitable in-house scoops. Plus, how can you resist a fainting goat?
Amazing Gelato Flavors and bright and lively unique artwork for sale too!
We enjoyed the variety of flavors this place offers as well as reasonable prices for Seattle. We had a large cone with sour cherry and double expresso. Both flavors were delicious. Highly recommend!
Restaurantji Recommends
Great, diverse options, and reasonable prices. They have a nice variety of eclectic/creative and conventional flavors, so there's something for everyone.Gelato is generally a little lighter and less sweet than ice cream, which I prefer. I recently had toasted almond, which is a nice balance of sweet and a little savory (for ice cream).
It punched me in the face with chocolate, and I deeply respect that.The espresso flavor is also very good
My friends and I tried the chocolate fondante, Mexican vanilla bean, and pistachio, and tiramisu in a pint. The medium size, which allows 3 flavors, was pretty hefty and definitely for sharing with friends. The gelatos were all smooth and creamy. The chocolate had a fairly bitter taste to it and I thought it tasted like cocoa powder. I'd categorize it as an adult chocolate rather than one you'd want to give kids. I've never had Mexican vanilla bean before but the flavor itself was so pronounced and strong in the gelato, which I appreciated. The pistachio and tiramisu ones had more subtle flavorsThe medium was $7.50
I just love the name and the gelato was pretty good. It was a bit expensive but would go again to try out the different flavors. The service was quick, especially since I went during December and it was snowing in Seattle. lol Would love to try it again during a warmer season It's a cute store and had some seating. We parked on the street when we visited.
Stopped by for a quick gelato craving after dinner. The chocolate flavor was ummmmmmmm sooooooooooo goooooood. So fudgy, gooey and oh so delicious. I could eat it all day. Hubby got the lemon olive oil and rose flavors and loved it. Lemon was tart, just how he likes. And rose was very refreshing. Great dessert option if you are in the hood!