Midnight Cookie Co.

1058 N 39th St, Seattle
(206) 895-9358

Recent Reviews

Sort by
karism576

When I visited their vegan flavors were chocolate chip and apple cinnamon. They tasted really good (esp. the apple cinnamon) and were nice and thick, but a couple seemed underbaked.

Keivan Ronasi

No place for sitting. The pictures are apparently old

Kyle Cooley

Solid cookies and a sweet loyalty program. They always have a huge selection. They have a couple gluten-free options and a couple vegan options, though none that are both.

SASHA LOVE

Let me go ahead and post my review for me and my kids who made these cookies. that’s the first question?? you know disappointment at it’s finest honey. These cookies have no flavor at all horrible throw the whole company away. I mean, it’s the truth who made the cookies they ain’t got no flavor, but the one with the sprinkles taste like nothing.idk what’s this place is trying to do but don’t do it there not even cooked all the way made my oldest daughter sick the cookies were a gift and we definitely appreciate the gesture and the gift as well. We just have to give our honest review and this is the honest truth. I wouldn’t recommend anyone to go to them.

treetopvegan

When I went there, they had 2 cookie options, apple and cinnamon, and cookies and cream. The cookies were okay, I found them kinda chalky. They didn’t have any vegan ice cream options.

David Gold

Tasty cookies

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Edward Caban

Sorry, these cookies aren’t good enough for the almost $20 it costs for 6. They used to be great before they raised their prices, the best part of a late night out downtown, cheap, yummy cookies to eat in bed on a Saturday. These are approaching gourmet cookie prices, which they are not. Disappointed in MCC. Lower your prices, or make your cookies better.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

A Chrome Bird

All the flavors taste the same to me. The flavoring is extremely minimal to the point of non-existence. Have tried 4 flavors. They have a kind of sandy, crumbly texture that reminds me of gluten free baked goods. I did try one gluten free and it was fine, non-descript and kind of...vanilla play dough reminiscent in overall flavor. $3 is also too much for a not-even-very-big cookie. All three stars are for the Lopez Island ice cream they sell in pints/half pints- truly excellent ice cream and worth the visit alone.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

justin chamblin

Ordered a variety of cookies for delivery on my birthday. Treat yourself right. Tried a couple different favors/types. Honest review, they all tasted the same. Hard to tell the difference between each cookie except minor toppings. The chocolate chip was my least favorite and had maybe 5 chocolate chips in it. Tasted and felt dry and old not fresh baked. Maybe a couple days old I imagine. Reminded me of Safeway or qfc cookies from the deli which are ok but nothing great. I think they could try using a different recipe for each flavor instead of the exact same exact batter. Also
Maybe more real butter and less flour. Just not worth it with so many other cookie companies around. Pretty disappointed overall. And I love cookies!

Food: 2

Michael Paczesny

Cookies are so good. Go for the happy hour and get 2 for 1

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Chip

Christian Vasquez

Stopped in for a late night cookie craving with the family - very good after you warm up for a few seconds.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Double Chocolate Chip Cookie, Chocolate Chip

shapat

Got both favours and they were good. They were on the chew side, but over a good snack.

Hannah B

Delicious cookies, great service, and even got a free cookie for answering the trivia question of the day!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Double Chocolate Chip Cookie, Baker's Monthly Special Cookie, Snickerdoodle, Chip, Chocolate Chip, 6 Cookies

Guy Tokihiro

Small cozy place to get a sweet snack! Drinks was amazing, I ordered the coconut with cream fizzy drink!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Double Chocolate Chip Cookie, Snickerdoodle, Birthday Cake, Oatmeal Craisin

Christina N.

The best cookies and they have a happy hour from 12-3pm. I’m a regular here haha. My favorite is the sweet and salty cookie

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...