Molly Moon's Homemade Ice Cream

10/10 ice cream experience when I was feeling a little sad. Lived up to the hype. One scoop of Moonbutter Cup with hot fudge. My sister had Milky Moon Bar with hot fudge and toasted marshmallow topping. Both delicious! And the customer service was very kind, friendly atmosphere. Thank you 🫶🏼

Just left the store with 2 friends who had never been before, and what was supposed to be a treat turned into a very awkward and uncomfortable experience.

On Halloween day, we walked in - the only 3 customers in the store, excited for ice cream but overwhelmed by decision. The only girl working the counter seemed less than enthused to be there at all, but the real giveaway was when we asked about her favourite flavour and her response was “I don’t really like ice cream” (or something to that effect).

She did, however, offer us a taste of flavours we were deciding between.
I asked for a kiddie scoop of ice cream, knowing that I would never finish it, while my friends ordered a single scoop each.
As she was scooping mine, I looked at the size of the scoop and, in surprise, simply exclaimed “oh wow, that’s a kiddie scoop?!” to which she then said something about being micromanaged.

Unsure about what just happened, I clarified that I just wasn’t sure about the sizing and I wasn’t sure I’d be able to finish that much. She replied “well you don’t have to, just throw it out” but with a tone that made it clear she was over it.
My 2 friends, now feeling like they had to walk on eggshells, paid in silence.
I really enjoyed the ice cream, but the experience left me feeling really taken aback… I don’t know that I would come back, nor would I recommend it to anyone else.

Oh boy!!! the vegan apple cider donut ice cream + apple pie filling as a topping... TO DIE FOR!!

Delicate, perfectly balanced honey lavender ice cream and truly decadent milky moon sundae. 100% recommend stopping in

What an amazing lil ice cream place. Soooo sooo bomb. make your way up here and get yourself the sweetest treat in Seattle

Good ice cream. A little too sweet for me but it's good.

There was someone assaulted in here and the staff didn’t do anything about it

Oh my this was some of the best ice cream we’ve ever had. I can see why there’s always a line. We had to come back a second time since we were only here a few days and it was so good. We absolutely loved the honey lavender and salted toffee. We also had the blueberry (?) cobbler and sweet cream and they were pretty good as well. We didn’t try the cones or sundae toppings. If I lived in Seattle I’d definitely be getting pints to take home…

I love that they sell single doses of Lactaid for us sensitive folks. The interior is a bit small so you may or may not be able to find a seat but people filter in and out pretty quickly. Everything is apparently compostable which is an awesome bonus.

I've been stopping here for ice cream during visits to Seattle for 10+ years and it's always delicious. Great taste and texture for nearly everything I've had here. Almost always an interesting array of flavors and often something new since my last visit. Very recommended.

Angelina today was kind and very knowledgeable of the menu, she helped me pick yummy ice cream!

Rude customer service when I went in there. Makes sense from there brainless owner. Hope they go out of business soon!

Trash Ice cream, rude staff. Unpatriotic and disrespectful to the men who risk their lives to keep our communities safe. Anyone with common sense should avoid this dumb, also complete side note the cleanliness standards especially behind the counter where they keep the scoopers is absolutely disgusting. Literally was dropping by to grab an ice cream as I travel the state visiting my sister and they have a sign that says no guns, I ask the clearl why it says that and they go on an ignorant political explaination on why we need police reform. I want ice cream I come in to an establishment who wants to serve anything but that. Shame on you and your organization.

Salted toffee was delicious. Superb texture, a little welcome graininess, nicely sized chunks of chocolate scattered amidst a luscious sea of salty toffee.

I was in Seattle for business and kept seeing that Molly Moon’s was a must-visit – and it definitely lived up to the hype.

Menu full of creative seasonal flavors that feel both fun and high-quality (I tried the blueberry cobbler and it was amazing).

Be ready for a line – it seems to be part of the Molly Moon’s experience – but the staff moves things along and it’s worth the wait once you get your scoop. One detail I really appreciated as a visitor is that they don’t do tipping here. Instead, they pay their employees a fair wage, which made the experience feel more thoughtful and rewarding.

Even though I’m not a local, this was one of the highlights of my trip. If you’re in Seattle and want ice cream that feels special to the city, Molly Moon’s is a perfect stop.

Must try if you are in Seattle downtown. Their season flavours are highly recommended.