Come here all the time for brunch but also joined them for Thanksgiving this year! My partner and I each ordered the Thanksgiving plate. Everything on our plate had great flavor and we thought the price was fair for the portions. A couple of our items were not as hot as we'd like but full-on Thanksgiving meals can be tricky and it didn't stop us from licking the plate clean. We'd absolutely recommend for another holiday!
William B
Stellar food and service. Highly recommend the avocado toast!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rene
From start to finish, my visit was wonderful. The food was perfectly cooked, flavorful, and beautifully plated. The staff were welcoming and provided excellent service throughout the meal. The atmosphere was relaxed and inviting, making it a great place to enjoy good food and good company. I'll definitely be returning soon!
Savya Thay
Came here for lunch, I think their breakfast items are more popular here. I had fish and chips and a friend of mine had the Mac and Cheese. Not the best, but B-. It’s not bad though!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Rose
Always good food, a little bit loud. Convivial atmosphere. I've come here for years and will be back again.
Marcia
Cute spot for brunch/lunch vibes. We ordered from both menus mussels, spaghetti & meatballs, and shakshuka. Everything was okay, nothing crazy but still enjoyable. Service was solid. They fixed my latte without hesitation and even adjusted our wobbly table which was appreciated. The space has that cozy, vintage-Capitol Hill feels definitely cute for a casual meal or coffee catch-up. I'd come back for the ambiance and to try something different next time.
Ruth
Very loud. Average food: at 5:45 pm, they were out of everything each of us wanted to initially order. There is a 5% house service charge we weren't aware of until the end. Very noisy, making casual conversation with 3 people a challenge.
Stacey
Oddfellows is known in Seattle for its formidable brunch offerings, but we wanted to see what dinner would be like as well. We started with the hard boiled eggs and anchovies, which were divine, but requires you actually love these two offerings together, as well as seperately. They were soft and cooked beautifully and the combination of creamy and salty paired beautifully. My main was the Niçoise Salad, a standard I enjoy seeing how different restaurants serve up. It was fresh, plated well and robust- the notable standout being the shredded fresh pea pods - such a flavor shout out! My dining partner had the steak poivre - prepared as he requested - med rare but more rare than med. the fried were crisp and served with a lovely aioli. My one critique of the meal was not about the food - it was the temperature. A gust of hot air greeted you upon entry and I guessed it was a good 80 degrees in the dining room - much too warm for my liking. Otherwise the service was warm and prompt and I would still recommend it as a great Capitol Hill staple for brunch and dinner!!
Keira
Came to celebrate my birthday with some friends for dinner! Our server was great and the wait was super quick. Food portions were perfect and the overall vibes were super nice. Another waiter came by to replace our water jug but accidentally dropped the vase and the water splashed into my eyes, the table, and our stuff on the booth which was a bummer, but luckily it was just water. They briefly apologized and continued their work, but it would've been nice to be compensated in some way as I was damp the rest of the time there. Human errors happen; I would still visit Oddfellows again regardless!
Mari Johnson
The brunch was lovely however the Mac and cheese pasta was really overcooked. Hopefully just an off batch because the place is really lovely inside and would love to try more of their menu.
Wonderful brunch menu on Sunday. Friendly staff, and great service. Looking forward to retuning! Great Cap Hill spot. And, fun to walk around Elliott Bay Book Co. next door while waiting for a table.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alex Gurinovich
Good breakfast and tasty shakshuka!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
riva poudel
The food and restaurant was so so so nice! My partner and I got the spicy shakshouka, coffee and the cinnamon roll. Everything was amazing until our server came and took our plate without asking, when we had half our food still on our serving plate. She dropped off the check too. I was so confused I thought maybe my partner said we were leaving but he was confused too. I’ve never been to a restaurant where they drop off the check mid meal and then take your plate lol. We got the hint. We went (today) Friday around 11:10am, it was busy and they were able to seat us for brunch and as we were eating more and more people were leaving. I don’t know if they were closing soon, but we left at 11:45am. Other than that everything was great and our server was really nice too. It was just so damn weird??? Who does that?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Parnisia
I love this Seattle classic! ☕ Oddfellows Café + Bar is my go-to when I want variety and vibe in one space. The welcome isn’t always warm, but the service is decent and the staff keep things moving. The real win? The food. 🥑 My favorite is the Avocado Toast for breakfast—simple, fresh, and always satisfying.
Even though I’m not a coffee drinker, their baristas make excellent coffees, teas, and craft cocktails that hit every mood. 🌿 It’s well-lit, modern, and spacious—perfect for brunch, laptop workdays, or relaxed catch-ups. A solid Capitol Hill favorite that never feels too crowded to enjoy.
It’s a lovely place- massive place- but for what they offer it’s ridiculously expensive. You can find more in that price point or the same for less within walking distance. Also a weird history that is worth looking up- might not jive with your values. Super nice service, though.
Come here all the time for brunch but also joined them for Thanksgiving this year! My partner and I each ordered the Thanksgiving plate. Everything on our plate had great flavor and we thought the price was fair for the portions. A couple of our items were not as hot as we'd like but full-on Thanksgiving meals can be tricky and it didn't stop us from licking the plate clean. We'd absolutely recommend for another holiday!
Stellar food and service. Highly recommend the avocado toast!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
From start to finish, my visit was wonderful. The food was perfectly cooked, flavorful, and beautifully plated. The staff were welcoming and provided excellent service throughout the meal. The atmosphere was relaxed and inviting, making it a great place to enjoy good food and good company. I'll definitely be returning soon!
Came here for lunch, I think their breakfast items are more popular here. I had fish and chips and a friend of mine had the Mac and Cheese. Not the best, but B-. It’s not bad though!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Always good food, a little bit loud. Convivial atmosphere. I've come here for years and will be back again.
Cute spot for brunch/lunch vibes. We ordered from both menus mussels, spaghetti & meatballs, and shakshuka. Everything was okay, nothing crazy but still enjoyable. Service was solid. They fixed my latte without hesitation and even adjusted our wobbly table which was appreciated. The space has that cozy, vintage-Capitol Hill feels definitely cute for a casual meal or coffee catch-up. I'd come back for the ambiance and to try something different next time.
Very loud. Average food: at 5:45 pm, they were out of everything each of us wanted to initially order. There is a 5% house service charge we weren't aware of until the end. Very noisy, making casual conversation with 3 people a challenge.
Oddfellows is known in Seattle for its formidable brunch offerings, but we wanted to see what dinner would be like as well. We started with the hard boiled eggs and anchovies, which were divine, but requires you actually love these two offerings together, as well as seperately. They were soft and cooked beautifully and the combination of creamy and salty paired beautifully. My main was the Niçoise Salad, a standard I enjoy seeing how different restaurants serve up. It was fresh, plated well and robust- the notable standout being the shredded fresh pea pods - such a flavor shout out! My dining partner had the steak poivre - prepared as he requested - med rare but more rare than med. the fried were crisp and served with a lovely aioli. My one critique of the meal was not about the food - it was the temperature. A gust of hot air greeted you upon entry and I guessed it was a good 80 degrees in the dining room - much too warm for my liking. Otherwise the service was warm and prompt and I would still recommend it as a great Capitol Hill staple for brunch and dinner!!
Came to celebrate my birthday with some friends for dinner! Our server was great and the wait was super quick. Food portions were perfect and the overall vibes were super nice. Another waiter came by to replace our water jug but accidentally dropped the vase and the water splashed into my eyes, the table, and our stuff on the booth which was a bummer, but luckily it was just water. They briefly apologized and continued their work, but it would've been nice to be compensated in some way as I was damp the rest of the time there. Human errors happen; I would still visit Oddfellows again regardless!
The brunch was lovely however the Mac and cheese pasta was really overcooked. Hopefully just an off batch because the place is really lovely inside and would love to try more of their menu.
Restaurantji Recommends
Wonderful brunch menu on Sunday. Friendly staff, and great service. Looking forward to retuning! Great Cap Hill spot. And, fun to walk around Elliott Bay Book Co. next door while waiting for a table.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good breakfast and tasty shakshuka!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food and restaurant was so so so nice! My partner and I got the spicy shakshouka, coffee and the cinnamon roll. Everything was amazing until our server came and took our plate without asking, when we had half our food still on our serving plate. She dropped off the check too. I was so confused I thought maybe my partner said we were leaving but he was confused too. I’ve never been to a restaurant where they drop off the check mid meal and then take your plate lol. We got the hint. We went (today) Friday around 11:10am, it was busy and they were able to seat us for brunch and as we were eating more and more people were leaving. I don’t know if they were closing soon, but we left at 11:45am. Other than that everything was great and our server was really nice too. It was just so damn weird??? Who does that?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
I love this Seattle classic! ☕ Oddfellows Café + Bar is my go-to when I want variety and vibe in one space. The welcome isn’t always warm, but the service is decent and the staff keep things moving. The real win? The food. 🥑 My favorite is the Avocado Toast for breakfast—simple, fresh, and always satisfying.
Even though I’m not a coffee drinker, their baristas make excellent coffees, teas, and craft cocktails that hit every mood. 🌿 It’s well-lit, modern, and spacious—perfect for brunch, laptop workdays, or relaxed catch-ups. A solid Capitol Hill favorite that never feels too crowded to enjoy.
📍 Oddfellows Café + Bar — Capitol Hill, Seattle
#OddfellowsCafe #SeattleEats #CapitolHillSeattle #SeattleBrunch #SeattleCoffee #SeattleRestaurants #BrunchVibes #FoodieSeattle #CafeCulture #BreakfastGoals #AmadoToast #SeattleInfluencer #EatLocalSeattle #PNWFoodies #CoffeeAndCocktails #FoodLoversSeattle
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
It’s a lovely place- massive place- but for what they offer it’s ridiculously expensive. You can find more in that price point or the same for less within walking distance. Also a weird history that is worth looking up- might not jive with your values. Super nice service, though.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 3
Loading...