Some of the best pizza in the PNW. I lived near here about 10 years ago and my wife craved this place when she was pregnant with our first child. Stopped by with the same child 10 years later on our way to a hockey tournament in Canada and the place was even better than before. Wish we had one down in Oregon!!!
Aza S (Zeze)
I LOVE all the employees at this location. Everyone is great! But Rowan, who was the cashier today, I have to single her out. She is a class act, and so sweet. I came in today, was having a bad day due to my health problems, and Rowan was a bright light to my dark day!! Thank you so much.
Wally Pettengill
This little Pagliacci Pizza has a small parking lot, tiny dining area, and huge prices. If you're a Seattle native, you know Pagliacci. It is the local pizza chain with better quality than the national franchises, but at exorbitant prices. They have some fancy toppings and seasonal varieties, but their quality (topping quantity, topping quality, dough quality) is so inconsistent that it's hard to justify the cost. This store is nice if you're looking to grab a quick slice and go, but I believe it is mostly a delivery kitchen.
Adrienne
Pagliacci - you know if you've been there.
We visited during one of the busier dining room experiences I've had, and Friday nights seem popular with families.
The pizza is good, as always. My pizza could have been warmed a little more, and I would have enjoyed a quieter dinner - however, at $5/slice I think I got a bargain for my experience. Also, the place was clean and people were moving in and out of the dining room so there was always enough room for folks to sit.
Appreciate that there's always 2 veggie pizzas to choose from.
Mari Kim
First time eating in after years of taking out. Service was excellent, server was young woman who was very quick and detailed and friendly.
Ordered a large vegetarian AGOG: which is marinated artichokes, roasted garlic, black olives, feta cheese, cherry tomatoes.
While we waited ordered the large Sicilian salad which has an arugula base with chicken and sun-dried tomatoes and I think they were dried blueberries or currents but something kind of delicious that added a nice berry twist. The salad was absolutely delicious. The vinaigrette was not too heavy and it made for the perfect appetizer. The large size was great for sharing between the two of us but I think it could be shared with one or two more guests as well. Great size to order in.
The pizza came piping hot and what we realized was the toppings were generous which made the very satisfying. They didn't scrimp on the feta so the overall effect was an incredibly delicious and filling Mediterranean type experience. Will order again, exactly the same items.
Brianna Slone
Best pizza in Seattle! I especially like this location. Friendly, clean and fast service.
Sam Rutter
Look I love pagliaccis, they make great pizza. But some of the people working behind the front counter are very… challenged. Always check to make sure they handed you the right box for your order. I ordered 2 pepperoni slices and 1 cheese, they gave me my order, I drove home and opened the boxes and realized they had given me 2 broccoli slices in addition to my order. Hurray free pizza right? Well turns out they charged me 10 bucks extra for the shitty broccoli pizza. Like it’s not that big of a deal but how hard is it to put the right slices in a box???? I really need to verify that??? 2 pepperoni slices and 1 cheese = broccoli pizza. Some people just need a babysitter I swear to god
Food: 5
Service: 1
Chris LeBeau
I was on Sunday, Sept 1st, at approx 9 pm, and the people working there could not have been nicer. The pizza was delicious, too, of course.
This is my first order with this Pizza Place. Trying to do it online is annoying and I dont need another app on my phone so I recommend calling. The Pizza....Sadly not NY style and this coming from a NY Sicilian! NY pizza has almost a chewy crust that allows you to fold the pizza and walk down the street if you so desire. Try it with what I recieved, impossible. I couldn't pick it up without it flopping around and all the toppings falling off. I ordered a Brooklyn Bridge. The topping were fresh though under cooked like the rest of my pizza. I'm writing this as I finish cooking it in my oven. The price for a 13inch delivered with $5 tip and a coke $50. I'm sorry for that price I'm severely underwhelmed! I will say the one bite I did take tasted good but it's not a $50 dollar pizza even on a good day. If you want to experience it buy it buy the slice. Perhaps they spend more time making it and maybe it's a better representation of what they make. They delivery person was excellent and the person who took my order did his job well. Unfortunately I will not order another delivery pizza from them. Those who like undercooked pizza you can eat with a fork might enjoy.
Food: 4
Service: 5
slimey .13
I recommend this place for those wanting dietary restrictions! I had a pizza party and all the pizzas were gone! If you’re looking to get a pizza with no dairy, no nuts, or no eggs, this is the place for you!
Dietary restrictions: I had a pizza delivery for a party, with dietary restrictions for one kid. The cheese on the pizza was good!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Mike Merola
The same pizza I ordered last year went from $30 to $39. That’s over a 23% increase from one month to the next. They have good pizza but I will start looking elsewhere, they are pricing themselves out of my market.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tanya M
This is the place to go for the best pizza. You simply can't go wrong with their seasonal specials.
Food: 5
Will Chabot
What a hidden gem I would tell them to advertise more but while I dined in they were sending pizzas out the door faster than I've ever seen. A pizza parlor so pizza some of the best pizza I've ever had. I would give this definitely a five star ⭐
Some of the best pizza in the PNW. I lived near here about 10 years ago and my wife craved this place when she was pregnant with our first child. Stopped by with the same child 10 years later on our way to a hockey tournament in Canada and the place was even better than before. Wish we had one down in Oregon!!!
I LOVE all the employees at this location. Everyone is great! But Rowan, who was the cashier today, I have to single her out. She is a class act, and so sweet. I came in today, was having a bad day due to my health problems, and Rowan was a bright light to my dark day!! Thank you so much.
This little Pagliacci Pizza has a small parking lot, tiny dining area, and huge prices. If you're a Seattle native, you know Pagliacci. It is the local pizza chain with better quality than the national franchises, but at exorbitant prices. They have some fancy toppings and seasonal varieties, but their quality (topping quantity, topping quality, dough quality) is so inconsistent that it's hard to justify the cost. This store is nice if you're looking to grab a quick slice and go, but I believe it is mostly a delivery kitchen.
Pagliacci - you know if you've been there.
We visited during one of the busier dining room experiences I've had, and Friday nights seem popular with families.
The pizza is good, as always. My pizza could have been warmed a little more, and I would have enjoyed a quieter dinner - however, at $5/slice I think I got a bargain for my experience. Also, the place was clean and people were moving in and out of the dining room so there was always enough room for folks to sit.
Appreciate that there's always 2 veggie pizzas to choose from.
First time eating in after years of taking out. Service was excellent, server was young woman who was very quick and detailed and friendly.
Ordered a large vegetarian AGOG: which is marinated artichokes, roasted garlic, black olives, feta cheese, cherry tomatoes.
While we waited ordered the large Sicilian salad which has an arugula base with chicken and sun-dried tomatoes and I think they were dried blueberries or currents but something kind of delicious that added a nice berry twist. The salad was absolutely delicious. The vinaigrette was not too heavy and it made for the perfect appetizer. The large size was great for sharing between the two of us but I think it could be shared with one or two more guests as well. Great size to order in.
The pizza came piping hot and what we realized was the toppings were generous which made the very satisfying. They didn't scrimp on the feta so the overall effect was an incredibly delicious and filling Mediterranean type experience. Will order again, exactly the same items.
Best pizza in Seattle! I especially like this location. Friendly, clean and fast service.
Look I love pagliaccis, they make great pizza. But some of the people working behind the front counter are very… challenged. Always check to make sure they handed you the right box for your order. I ordered 2 pepperoni slices and 1 cheese, they gave me my order, I drove home and opened the boxes and realized they had given me 2 broccoli slices in addition to my order. Hurray free pizza right? Well turns out they charged me 10 bucks extra for the shitty broccoli pizza. Like it’s not that big of a deal but how hard is it to put the right slices in a box???? I really need to verify that??? 2 pepperoni slices and 1 cheese = broccoli pizza. Some people just need a babysitter I swear to god
Food: 5
Service: 1
I was on Sunday, Sept 1st, at approx 9 pm, and the people working there could not have been nicer. The pizza was delicious, too, of course.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food amazing customer service
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Hawaiian Pizza
Incredible pizza and the best crust I have had in a century.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
This is my first order with this Pizza Place. Trying to do it online is annoying and I dont need another app on my phone so I recommend calling. The Pizza....Sadly not NY style and this coming from a NY Sicilian! NY pizza has almost a chewy crust that allows you to fold the pizza and walk down the street if you so desire. Try it with what I recieved, impossible. I couldn't pick it up without it flopping around and all the toppings falling off. I ordered a Brooklyn Bridge. The topping were fresh though under cooked like the rest of my pizza. I'm writing this as I finish cooking it in my oven. The price for a 13inch delivered with $5 tip and a coke $50. I'm sorry for that price I'm severely underwhelmed! I will say the one bite I did take tasted good but it's not a $50 dollar pizza even on a good day. If you want to experience it buy it buy the slice. Perhaps they spend more time making it and maybe it's a better representation of what they make. They delivery person was excellent and the person who took my order did his job well. Unfortunately I will not order another delivery pizza from them. Those who like undercooked pizza you can eat with a fork might enjoy.
Food: 4
Service: 5
I recommend this place for those wanting dietary restrictions! I had a pizza party and all the pizzas were gone! If you’re looking to get a pizza with no dairy, no nuts, or no eggs, this is the place for you!
Dietary restrictions: I had a pizza delivery for a party, with dietary restrictions for one kid. The cheese on the pizza was good!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
The same pizza I ordered last year went from $30 to $39. That’s over a 23% increase from one month to the next. They have good pizza but I will start looking elsewhere, they are pricing themselves out of my market.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is the place to go for the best pizza. You simply can't go wrong with their seasonal specials.
Food: 5
What a hidden gem I would tell them to advertise more but while I dined in they were sending pizzas out the door faster than I've ever seen. A pizza parlor so pizza some of the best pizza I've ever had. I would give this definitely a five star ⭐
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Loading...