Pegasus Pizza West Seattle

Delicious pizza and Greek Salad. Friendly service.

I truly enjoy Pegasus Pizza. The location across from beautiful Alki Beach is rivaled by few in West Seattle. The upscale feel is far more than just candles and dimmed lighting. It's the consistency of food from day to day. It's the mastery of service by every part of the waitstaff. Food is served promptly and with portion sizes that you absolutely can share.I absolutely recommend Pegasus to all that are looking for a great Pizza or to those that are seeking comfort food like pastas and Mestballs with Marinara. Delicious!

Went to this restaurant for dinner with friends. Great ambience with a great view of the Alki beach. The service was decent - given they were super busy. We ordered for pizzas (veg and non-veg)- both of which was alright.. The cheese pesto bread was delicious - would recommend having. Overall decent experience.

First time to this restaurant. They had some cocktails on special called their Tropical Sunday Funday- we thought these cocktails would on discount- when we asked their price the waiter didn’t even know quoting us around $10.50- they were $12 each- I ordered the blue Hawaiian- my partner had the mango margarita- both tasted so sickly sweet it was gross and I usually love the Blue Hawaiian. We ordered the two pieces of pizza lunch option- cheese only- the cheese was seriously so thick on the pizza that it dwarfed the crust. The crust was tasty and reminded me of Pizza Hut but the cheese to crust ratio was too much for me. I had a huge pile of cheese on my plate that I had to scrape off.My partner also found a hair in her salad. The salads were a strange combo- we asked for Caesar and they brought us letter- two huge tomato slices- a bunch of mozzarella cheese- 3 olives and some cucumbers. The dressing was on the side and tasted nothing like Caesar dressing. Weird combo for a salad. Overall the food is so-so- I’ve had way better pizza ordering from Little Cesars to be honest - and it cost way less than What we paid here. Overpriced drinks and food for subpar quality. The waiter was slow and we had to ask other waiters to get us a box and get our check.Wouldn’t come back.

This was one of the best pizza you can get the pizza itself is expensive but it was worth as it literally stuffed me after 3 slices there where so generous with the toppings and the chess was godly. Even more it those pizza where the pepperoni and ham in under the chess whoch made the pizza slip but still was great. The Buffalo wing was very good too it was the best.

The pasta was super delicious ?The service was nice and polite. Compared to the quality of food, the price was very good.

The pizza was good. The artichoke dip was okay. The atmosphere was lively & full of laughter. This business is popular. The decor and interior design was gorgeous.I wish I captured more pictures. A lot of people dining inside so I refrained from taking pictures in certain directions. The waiter was attentive and friendly. I will visit again!

Awesome food hands down. Not just the pizza, but all of the menu items have been perfect to feed your need for Greek food. They also have the best drink selection to match your dinner. They are the best in service as the people that work there help in describing what's in and how it's prepared. You can add or take off what you like. Nice outside seating when it's warm. Great place to visit passing thru or a twice a month place to bring friends. To tell the truth, it's a 10 star place.

We shared a yummy shrimp salad and a Medium "Pegasus" pizza loads of veggies and a few meats in it.. we got full on the salad and took most the pizza home for tomorrow's lunch. So good and the view of Alki peach is wonderful. The have excellent lasagna and other yummy choices. They have a fully stocked bar of wine and liquors for those who'd like a drink. Also on nice days seating outside. Parking also handicapped nearby. It's right across the street from Alki Beach and the sunfish restaurant.

Ambience - 5 stars for roadside eating on a sunny day with good views.Food price- on the expensive side.Taste- good. Not many vegetarian options, but you can ask server to make substitution for extra charge.but pastas are very oily or extra buttery.Beer- affordable & good but need to be served colder.Service- poor. Took a lot of time for server to come to us, & bring our food out & then bring our cheque & then cheque had a mistake & then I had to go to billing table to pay bill in person !!Last verdict - do come here if you can afford $40 per person with food+beer.

I enjoy so much their pizza and salad. It was delicious and the gentleman in charge was great with the food and wine suggestions, he was very knowledgeable and attentive. I highly recommend everyone to visit this place, it is an awesome place !

We have always enjoyed coming here until our last visit. We have a small well behaved service dog with vest and cards. He acted as if she was a problem and put us at table way in the back. The rest of the staff has always been wonderful with her. I hope some day we can feel comfortable enough to come back. The one star is for the manager Devon .

Bullet point version:*I paid $25 for a Small pizza to bring home*It was disgusting, had to throw it all away*Called the restaurant hoping they would correct it or offer a solution*They barely gave me an “I’m sorry”*Wont be going back - DisappointedDetailed version:My daughter and I ordered two small pizzas online last night, for a pick-up order. My daughter drove to the restaurant to get it and came straight home. Her pizza was okay, basic pepperoni pizza, hard to mess that up. Well it’s hard to mess up any pizza, or so I thought. I always get the Tom’s House Special, my favorite pizza. But last night I could barely eat one piece. They went a little feta cheese crazy…an entire layer of thick feta cheese covered the entire pizza, under all of the toppings so I could not scrape it off. I love feta cheese but this was overkill. Usually it’s just a few crumbles. So tonight I tried to scrape off the cold feta and heat up a piece…no luck. There was just so much covering the entire pizza. I had to throw it away, which after paying $25 for a small pizza, was disappointing to say the least!Upset that I could not even enjoy my expensive treat, I decided to call the restaurant and let them know my experience. Thinking maybe they would offer to remake it or give a coupon for my next order. If they wanted to see the disgusting food they served first I would understand and would have been more than happy to bring it back, possibly a teaching moment of what not to do. But again, no luck. They barely seemed interested and only told me ‘sorry’.I’ve had better pizza from Little Caesar’s for only $5 , but the lack of concern or offer to fix the problem is what will turn me away for good. I’ve had friends tell me they don’t go to Pegasus Pizza anymore…I guess I will be joining them now too.

Great local pizza and pasta spot. GLUTEN FREE pizza is bomb. Look at the picture I've included of the Alki Pizza on Gluten Free.Friendly staff. Cute and clean restaurant space. Great views of the beach and bay.Big projector screen for live sports.Highly recommend. Will be coming back.

Pegasus can always be counted on for a good meal at a reasonable price. The food is tasty, the portions are generous, and the bar is varied. Good neighborhood spot and one our family's go-to places.