Accidentally left a bad review on too good to go and the app isn't letting me change it. This location has always been excellent! So sorry!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hillary M
How did I not know about this little cocktail bar?! I paid too much attention to the pie part (which are delicious btw) but tonight we popped in just for cocktails and it was terrific- cute decor and great service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tyler Knight
Pie Bar will be seeing me very often!Love that the menu was small but full of variety, I ordered the cookies and cream pie and it did not disappoint, the slices are HUGE and served with ice cream, totally shareable but I couldn’t stop myself from eating it all by myself. My friend ordered a coffee martini and raved about it! The price is well worth every bite.The atmosphere is small but I enjoyed how quant and intimate it was, it allowed us to socialize with others around us and the costumer service was top tier, extremely friendly and welcoming.This place would be perfect for a date night cap or even an entire date itself because they have savory options in pie form haha.I can’t wait to go back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
relic galaxy
Great place to warm up or chill out with its cozy bar and booth seating indoors, street side deck outdoors.Far out PNW atmosphere.And of course, PIE. Really good pie. Savory or sweet. Oh! And pie inspired cocktails.Most of all, very friendly service!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Pot Pie
Skye P.
I only knew about the pie window, and have been missing out on the inside experience! Solid lateish night food spot (food till 1030, closes at 11, but don't be a and show up at close)This and the Ballard location are both the OG pie bar in terms of recipes and whatnot. Pies are so fkn classic and perfect. The prices seem off putting at first, but slices are large and come with a thicc side salad, pies come with ice cream. We weren't drinking, but great cocktail options and ppl in there clearly just there for the cocktails so that's promising.21+, enter through the back in the winter while the garage door is closed. Can't believe I've lived in the neighborhood almost 4 years and never knew how pleasant the inside is. Warm vibes and personable service. Will be back for sure
Gina Miller
The peanut butter pie presentation was gorgeous and the taste - OFF THE CHAIN GOOD. Plus, Rain and Jeff were SO fun to talk with, SO welcoming, I’d go back just to hang with them and the pie would be the PLUS ❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Yash K.
I got a slice of their Sweet, Sugar, Candyman Pie (monthly special from October) to go. It also came with a side of ice cream. They offered vegan options as well. The staff were very friendly and helpful. The service was pretty quick, there was only one other group ahead of me. Definitely want to come back and try other pies.
Mark Wagner
Best pie bar in Seattle.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amy V.
Taste like there was too much (one tablespoon ) too much cinnamon in the apple crumble pie.
Michael W.
I need to know if a pint of beer here is always $10 a pint or what. Pretty unacceptable in my opinion, especially when there's no tap list or price menu. Hopefully, someone just fat fingered the price of the beer in their POS system and it gets fixed. I do consider the standard $7 pint to be a pricey beer, but that just seems to be the market rate for whatever reason. In no way shape or form is a Stoup Pale Ale that isn't icy cold worth anywhere near $10. Just a heads up for all those on a date night not expecting to cough up all their pretty penny's.Food is 5 star, service is solid, people are great. Lovely ambiance. I will go back, and drink their water.
Very good food. Both the chicken pot pie and the stuck pig were really good. Great crust, really tasty. The dessert pies we had (Bumble Berry Crumble and Sour Cherry) were good as well. Great service, great atmosphere. Great cocktails as well.Parking: It's Phinney, what are you gonna do? Parking is so so.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Vegan Sour Cherry, Chicken Pot Pie
Liz Clemons
I called today to ask about flavors of their summer seasonal pies. The guy on the phone asked flavors of pies? Which I thought was interesting and then told me I could find them online.
Service: 1
Elizabeth Clemons
I called today to ask about flavors of their summer seasonal pies. The guy on the phone asked flavors of pies? Which I thought was interesting and then told me I could find them online.
Service: 1
Cheri Wright
The Espresso Martini was great! Service was a bit slow but staff was very friendly.
Atmosphere: 4
Service: 4
Miss Phillips (Miss Dictator)
The guy rubbed his hands all over my bag for no reason while wearing gloves and he had great customer service. The pie and ice cream were good.
Accidentally left a bad review on too good to go and the app isn't letting me change it. This location has always been excellent! So sorry!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
How did I not know about this little cocktail bar?! I paid too much attention to the pie part (which are delicious btw) but tonight we popped in just for cocktails and it was terrific- cute decor and great service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pie Bar will be seeing me very often!Love that the menu was small but full of variety, I ordered the cookies and cream pie and it did not disappoint, the slices are HUGE and served with ice cream, totally shareable but I couldn’t stop myself from eating it all by myself. My friend ordered a coffee martini and raved about it! The price is well worth every bite.The atmosphere is small but I enjoyed how quant and intimate it was, it allowed us to socialize with others around us and the costumer service was top tier, extremely friendly and welcoming.This place would be perfect for a date night cap or even an entire date itself because they have savory options in pie form haha.I can’t wait to go back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great place to warm up or chill out with its cozy bar and booth seating indoors, street side deck outdoors.Far out PNW atmosphere.And of course, PIE. Really good pie. Savory or sweet. Oh! And pie inspired cocktails.Most of all, very friendly service!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Pot Pie
I only knew about the pie window, and have been missing out on the inside experience! Solid lateish night food spot (food till 1030, closes at 11, but don't be a and show up at close)This and the Ballard location are both the OG pie bar in terms of recipes and whatnot. Pies are so fkn classic and perfect. The prices seem off putting at first, but slices are large and come with a thicc side salad, pies come with ice cream. We weren't drinking, but great cocktail options and ppl in there clearly just there for the cocktails so that's promising.21+, enter through the back in the winter while the garage door is closed. Can't believe I've lived in the neighborhood almost 4 years and never knew how pleasant the inside is. Warm vibes and personable service. Will be back for sure
The peanut butter pie presentation was gorgeous and the taste - OFF THE CHAIN GOOD. Plus, Rain and Jeff were SO fun to talk with, SO welcoming, I’d go back just to hang with them and the pie would be the PLUS ❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I got a slice of their Sweet, Sugar, Candyman Pie (monthly special from October) to go. It also came with a side of ice cream. They offered vegan options as well. The staff were very friendly and helpful. The service was pretty quick, there was only one other group ahead of me. Definitely want to come back and try other pies.
Best pie bar in Seattle.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Taste like there was too much (one tablespoon ) too much cinnamon in the apple crumble pie.
I need to know if a pint of beer here is always $10 a pint or what. Pretty unacceptable in my opinion, especially when there's no tap list or price menu. Hopefully, someone just fat fingered the price of the beer in their POS system and it gets fixed. I do consider the standard $7 pint to be a pricey beer, but that just seems to be the market rate for whatever reason. In no way shape or form is a Stoup Pale Ale that isn't icy cold worth anywhere near $10. Just a heads up for all those on a date night not expecting to cough up all their pretty penny's.Food is 5 star, service is solid, people are great. Lovely ambiance. I will go back, and drink their water.
Restaurantji Recommends
Very good food. Both the chicken pot pie and the stuck pig were really good. Great crust, really tasty. The dessert pies we had (Bumble Berry Crumble and Sour Cherry) were good as well. Great service, great atmosphere. Great cocktails as well.Parking: It's Phinney, what are you gonna do? Parking is so so.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Vegan Sour Cherry, Chicken Pot Pie
I called today to ask about flavors of their summer seasonal pies. The guy on the phone asked flavors of pies? Which I thought was interesting and then told me I could find them online.
Service: 1
I called today to ask about flavors of their summer seasonal pies. The guy on the phone asked flavors of pies? Which I thought was interesting and then told me I could find them online.
Service: 1
The Espresso Martini was great! Service was a bit slow but staff was very friendly.
Atmosphere: 4
Service: 4
The guy rubbed his hands all over my bag for no reason while wearing gloves and he had great customer service. The pie and ice cream were good.