I hate to say, but the quality of the pizza has gone seriously downhill in the last year. Slices are smaller, overcooked to the point of shattering. I hope they can restore the quality because they used to be 5 stars!!
Joe Santavicca
The pizza is good but the hoagie is the choice. Gooood damn.
There’s no seating inside but steps close and a quick walk to the waterfront.
A+++++++
The last take heart
horrible pizza closed all the time dough tasted like cardboard never coming here for pizza ever again
Dominic Conricode
Mediocre hoagie for $21.79.
Andrew Bryant
This is actual good pizza in seattle..Just go
Jimmie Galaites (Jimmie G)
There is enough room for 3-5 people to queue up inside. But the pizza is worth it. Not as big a slice as I would prefer, but a great crust and nice pepperoni. Thin and juicy in the middle, curled up and blackened on the sides. Very good.
Zoe Ngo
this place actually deserves a 1 star because the pizza was so dry, but my boyfriend told me to give it 3 stars since he values small business (and so do i). i got their veggie daily special which had mozzarella and basil (and jalapeños? i think). the sauce to crust ratio left more to be desired and the crust was very dry and burnt kinda like a cracker. go try frank pepe’s for good pizza.
F A
Good N.Y slice pizza and nicely charred crust
M Felt
I didn't try the pizza, got the Italian hoagie. It was pricey at $18 but was a ton of food. I tried the jazz spread, glad I got it on the side because it was super spicy. I think there were two stools at a table but otherwise it's fully takeout. Order inside, pick up outside. Really good sandwich and the pizza looked good but not sure I'd go there again as it was a pretty good walk from my mtg location in the city
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Italian Hoagie
Heidi Williams
Pepperoni pizza is amazing. Crispy on the top and bottom. Also tried Italian hoagie.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Italian Hoagie, Pepperoni Pizza Slice
The best pizza in Seattle, thin and crisp base, delicious toppings and totally fresh. A must visit!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Caitlin Christian
Came here due to the buzz lately about this place on social media. The food was decent, I wasn’t wowed by any of it. You should expect to wait in line about 20 minutes, you first wait in line to order and then again to get your slices. I went on a weekday around 1pm. You should also expect to spend around $20 for lunch even if you’re just getting slices. There is a spot inside for about 2 people to eat but with the line moving past, I don’t think it would be a relaxing spot to eat pizza. It’s mostly a walk-up window style place. These are not complaints just some notable points in order to know what to expect.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Italian Hoagie
Isis Chapman
As a new englander living in Seattle, pizza and subs haven’t been the same since we moved here. Post alley pizza is the perfect substitute. Tucked back in an alleyway, the scene is set as you wait patiently in the growing line before they open. The pizza and Italian sub still aren’t the most classic NYC slice and sub, but ever so slightly one notch above, in the most perfect way. Slight improvements made, but nothing that strays too far from the original. Unfortunately I don’t think we’ll be trying any other food downtown, we’ll wait in that line anytime we’re in the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Hoagie, Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Kris Homan
Friendliest people, Amazing A+++++ pizza, and love the fun vibes!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Rebecca DeLima
Post Alley continues to be an absolutely wonderful business. I ordered a small stack of whole pies for my bookclub tonight and they were kind enough to leave it unsliced for me and give me very easy reheating instructions. Got a large Italian salad and hot honey which my book club loved. They all said they can’t wait to go there themselves. If you have an event that you want to host and you want to make it easy for yourself, I highly recommend picking up a stack of pizzas from here. You can order ahead of time. Thank you to the Post Alley Crew! Seattle loves you.
I hate to say, but the quality of the pizza has gone seriously downhill in the last year. Slices are smaller, overcooked to the point of shattering. I hope they can restore the quality because they used to be 5 stars!!
The pizza is good but the hoagie is the choice. Gooood damn.
There’s no seating inside but steps close and a quick walk to the waterfront.
A+++++++
horrible pizza closed all the time dough tasted like cardboard never coming here for pizza ever again
Mediocre hoagie for $21.79.
This is actual good pizza in seattle..Just go
There is enough room for 3-5 people to queue up inside. But the pizza is worth it. Not as big a slice as I would prefer, but a great crust and nice pepperoni. Thin and juicy in the middle, curled up and blackened on the sides. Very good.
this place actually deserves a 1 star because the pizza was so dry, but my boyfriend told me to give it 3 stars since he values small business (and so do i). i got their veggie daily special which had mozzarella and basil (and jalapeños? i think). the sauce to crust ratio left more to be desired and the crust was very dry and burnt kinda like a cracker. go try frank pepe’s for good pizza.
Good N.Y slice pizza and nicely charred crust
I didn't try the pizza, got the Italian hoagie. It was pricey at $18 but was a ton of food. I tried the jazz spread, glad I got it on the side because it was super spicy. I think there were two stools at a table but otherwise it's fully takeout. Order inside, pick up outside. Really good sandwich and the pizza looked good but not sure I'd go there again as it was a pretty good walk from my mtg location in the city
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Italian Hoagie
Pepperoni pizza is amazing. Crispy on the top and bottom. Also tried Italian hoagie.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Italian Hoagie, Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Restaurantji Recommends
The best pizza in Seattle, thin and crisp base, delicious toppings and totally fresh. A must visit!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Came here due to the buzz lately about this place on social media. The food was decent, I wasn’t wowed by any of it. You should expect to wait in line about 20 minutes, you first wait in line to order and then again to get your slices. I went on a weekday around 1pm. You should also expect to spend around $20 for lunch even if you’re just getting slices. There is a spot inside for about 2 people to eat but with the line moving past, I don’t think it would be a relaxing spot to eat pizza. It’s mostly a walk-up window style place. These are not complaints just some notable points in order to know what to expect.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Italian Hoagie
As a new englander living in Seattle, pizza and subs haven’t been the same since we moved here. Post alley pizza is the perfect substitute. Tucked back in an alleyway, the scene is set as you wait patiently in the growing line before they open. The pizza and Italian sub still aren’t the most classic NYC slice and sub, but ever so slightly one notch above, in the most perfect way. Slight improvements made, but nothing that strays too far from the original. Unfortunately I don’t think we’ll be trying any other food downtown, we’ll wait in that line anytime we’re in the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Hoagie, Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Friendliest people, Amazing A+++++ pizza, and love the fun vibes!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Post Alley continues to be an absolutely wonderful business. I ordered a small stack of whole pies for my bookclub tonight and they were kind enough to leave it unsliced for me and give me very easy reheating instructions. Got a large Italian salad and hot honey which my book club loved. They all said they can’t wait to go there themselves. If you have an event that you want to host and you want to make it easy for yourself, I highly recommend picking up a stack of pizzas from here. You can order ahead of time. Thank you to the Post Alley Crew! Seattle loves you.
Loading...