Stevie's Famous Beacon Hill

Came here because the people of Seattle rated it the best pizza in the city. It was indeed very tasty! Great crust and flavorful sauce. We have tried the Normie McDonald and Sausage Pizza and both were awesome.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Really disappointing. There's barely any cheese on the pizza, it tastes like the bottom of the oven, and I'll be hungry again in an hour. Why does this cost $6.50?

This pizza could be made better with some very, very basic improvements. Like covering the entire slice with cheese. Why do half the bites have no cheese? Why is the dough completely tasteless, and so thin that it picks up the burnt flavor of your oven (which is probably too hot)?

I love pizza. I make pizza regularly. This pizza sucks.

Food: 2

The Normie is one of the best slices of pizza I’ve ever had.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ordered the Normie Macdonald, sausage pizza, and Caesar salad. All of it was super tasty esp with the pizzas fresh out of the oven. Went on a Monday night, so it wasn’t too busy.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Normie MacDonald Pizza, Caesar Salad

Their tomato pizza that’s the cheeseless option is not good. No veggies, just a few green olives and waaaay too much tomato sauce. I’ve had so many delicious cheeseless pizzas, this one is the worst by far. ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 5

Great pizza, good service. Went on a Saturday afternoon and had the place to ourselves.
Did I mention that the pizza was good, like east coast pizza good.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Normie MacDonald Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza

Staff's working hard, but the location's not currently equipped for the volume of customer it attracts. Waited in line for about 20 min only to be told they're out of slices for at least an hour. Pretty disappointing.

My boyfriend and I tried to eat here the other day on a Friday, and here's a little about our experience. The location is inside of the Clock Out Lounge, a bar that has live music. I'd been here once before with friends, and I thought the pizza was okay. The wait for food was long that time, too. I'm from Chicago, which has a strong pizza culture, so I try not to be a snob. I initially thought the flavors were okay, specifically the sauce. I'm not a fan of New York style because of the floppy crust and tendency to be over sauced, but you make do with what's around, and that's all that's in Seattle.

This visit, my boyfriend and I were gonna order a whole pie and salad to eat in. Pricey, 16-inch pizza at $31 bucks and small salad at $8. After standing in line and discussing what to order, I went over to the bar and got two drinks and two jello shots. In the time it took me to get drinks and find a table, I noticed my boyfriend was still in line. I sat at the table and had a couple of sips, and noticed my boyfriend looking over at me with an irritated expression. I got up to go over to him, and by the time I arrived, some tall dude was at the register asking for his order. My boyfriend orders and we're told it'll be 50 minutes. My boyfriend is exasperated at this point because it took well over 10 minutes for this guy who had been in and out of the kitchen and past the register a few times to acknowledge him. As my boyfriend makes a frustrated noise, the guy says it's a Friday evening like it's an excuse. He then goes on to say we don't need to stay and / or come back at all. My boyfriend walks off, while the guy is saying he only stood in line for like 5 minutes. That was a long 5 minutes. I then responded that they need to have better service.

This is something I've noticed about Seattle. Everyone here is okay paying for overpriced, sub-par food, and shitty service, like it's a cool experience. If you're gonna charge more than your competitors, make sure you have a superior product as well as superior service. My boyfriend was born and raised in Seattle, so this isn't just me being biased, and we'd just got back from a trip to Chicago. The differences in dining experiences were night and day. Great food, cooked well, and great service at a less obnoxious price. Honestly, just go to Pagliacci. You'll at least get a consistent product that's almost half the cost and good service.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 1

Excellent pie!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Really liked the pizza but I found it nonetheless overhyped. Good flavor, enjoyed the sourdough crust, and the red sauce was great, but found the pizza way too floppy. Almost needed a knife and fork.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Build Your Own Red Pie, Pepperoni Pizza

They ran out of whole pies at 6 pm on a Friday, so we ordered slices. The slices took 1.5 hours to get and came out lukewarm. The flavors were good, but absolutely not worth the hassle. Disappointed as we were really looking forward to trying.

Ordered 2 slices, been waiting for an hour, still waiting…

Consistently good pizza. Sourdough crust is as good as it gets. Great neighborhood joint (Beacon Hill).

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stevie’s is located inside the Clock Out lounge and the vibes are great!! The pizza itself was amazing - the cheese pizza had an AMAZING outer crust and very thin crust throughout with very fresh ingredients.

The sauce tasted fresh and the slices had 3 types of cheeses. We didn’t get the hot honey this time but it sounded like it would be an amazing addition.

If you like a pizza with thin crust and high-quality ingredients, then this is your place.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza

No service the bar tender didn't even ask if we wanted anything
Atmosphere, dirty, run down and smells
So we decided to order pizza
And surprise they didn't have any

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1