Best pie in West Seattle! (previous review 5 stars)
Update, first strike, found a long hair in my pizza. Second strike, found a rubber band in my pizza. Third and final strike, found a broken chunk of metal in my pizza.
50 bucks for a pie, out the door, must be to cover their overhead, as a customer I helped with this, Supreme couldn't uphold their end, quality control. I don't do business with people who can't do business. My job is to buy pizza, not fix yours.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Vick
Exceptional
Rook Bankston
DYNO-MITE 🧨🧨🧨🧨🧨
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Eddy Mendi
The amazing reviews online vs what I actually experienced makes me think most of the good reviews are written by drunk / wasted people.
Pizza was atrocious. Flopped worse than a Costco slice with a pound of cheese on it. Felt and tasted like the slices got reheated in a microwave. All soft and rubbery.
Person at the bar seemed friendly. Idk what the deal with the pizza was though. It was so bad I sat there for a second after holding a slice and wondered if I'd said something to offend the guy behind the counter.
No chance since I just ordered a slice and left a 20% tip. Who knows these days. I chalked it up to the pizza just sucks there. Surprising, since everyone was raving about this place online.
Whole foods pizza blows this place out of the water honestly.
Typical dive bar feel, and service was normal. Food was offensive tbh.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Alex
It's fine. Not expensive, but still somehow a bit expensive for what it is. Though to be fair Talarico's across the street is $10 a slice so maybe pizza prices are just getting out of hand in general.
Irma Miller
First time there, was confused as how to order and no one guided us. Ordered two slices of pepperoni and one of their salads to share with my husband. Food was plenty and okay, nothing really special about it. Music was funk/rap, could be a more fun inviting place.
The two workers we encountered were not friendly. Pretty much robotic. Will probably give it another chance at some point. Maybe they were having an off day?
Alyssa Lorentson
I still think Supreme is the best NY style pizza in the area but I have to say the quality has slowly been going down over the past few years. It’s like they’re rushing to get their orders out and are getting sloppy with making them. I love garlic but don’t really appreciate chunks of garlic the size of teeth in my pizza, chop it up a little more please! Take the time to let the pizza finish in the oven, the past several times the dough is soft and undercooked and cheese barely melted.
Food: 4
Tori Twine
Supreme is a great value for pizza by the slice when you just want a snack. The restaurant has the old-school dive bar feel, friendly staff, and a lively atmosphere with a few TVs for sports.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza by the Slice
Anna Walls
Visiting West Seattle for a month, and this was my favorite bar. We asked for a channel on one of the TVs, and the bartender accommodated us in less than 30 seconds. The French 75 I ordered was perfect, and my husband said the beer recommendation was on point. They have a classic video game system with a ton of games, and we both played games from our (millennial) childhood while sitting at the bar. The bartender made us feel funny and smart, even though we were a little drunk. Pizza by the slice!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Katie Vranesic
I dream about this pizza. Their chef is the nicest person alive — she custom makes goat cheese Detroit style pizza for me every time I come in. I can’t say enough good about the staff, the food, everything about Supreme. 10/10 stars.
Sometimes they have great rock shit pumping, sometimes it's hip hop too loud. Pizza is great most of the time but every now and then it's undercooked. Nice staff and great atmosphere most of the time. Their sausage supreme never fails
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Victoria Martinez
Cool spot. I had this on my list from a Seattle food magazine for their Portuguese sausage, ham, and jalapeno pizza. I'm Portuguese and got really excited about linguica being offered. It didn't have too much of the flavor I was expecting or much flavor at all. For a $44 pie I was hoping for more and this left me wanting more. The sizes are huge so even though it was pricey, my husband and I ate this for 3 lunches later that week. I'd recommend getting a slice instead of the whole pie. They reheat it so it's crisper on the bottom opposed to the whole pie was a bit softer.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
simon mcilroy
Best spot for a slice and a pint in the junction.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Katie Dolan
My friend and I had a late-night craving and decided to check out Supreme for the first time. We ordered just two slices to-go (the Detroit and the chef’s choice) and nothing else. The atmosphere was great and everyone seemed to be enjoying themselves, so we were excited to try it.
After about 20 minutes of waiting, we still hadn’t received our slices. It was a bit busy and we were caught up in conversation, so we didn’t think much of it at first — we figured they were still heating them up. But then we noticed the bartender take two slices out of the oven that looked like our order — completely burnt — and set them aside. It was an honest mistake, and we didn’t fault him for that. What was frustrating, though, was that he didn’t acknowledge the error or put in a replacement order.
We waited another 5–10 minutes with still no update, so we finally went up to the bar to check in. The bartender asked us what we had ordered and told us it would be just three more minutes. Eventually, we got our slices — more than 30 minutes after we had originally ordered — with no apology or effort to make the situation right.
The pizza was good, but the experience left a bad taste
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 1
steve mcelroy
The pizza is insanely delicious, but it is a bar so not a family friendly place. Perfect for a date night or hooking up with friends.
Best pie in West Seattle! (previous review 5 stars)
Update, first strike, found a long hair in my pizza.
Second strike, found a rubber band in my pizza.
Third and final strike, found a broken chunk of metal in my pizza.
50 bucks for a pie, out the door, must be to cover their overhead, as a customer I helped with this, Supreme couldn't uphold their end, quality control. I don't do business with people who can't do business. My job is to buy pizza, not fix yours.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Exceptional
DYNO-MITE 🧨🧨🧨🧨🧨
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The amazing reviews online vs what I actually experienced makes me think most of the good reviews are written by drunk / wasted people.
Pizza was atrocious. Flopped worse than a Costco slice with a pound of cheese on it. Felt and tasted like the slices got reheated in a microwave. All soft and rubbery.
Person at the bar seemed friendly. Idk what the deal with the pizza was though. It was so bad I sat there for a second after holding a slice and wondered if I'd said something to offend the guy behind the counter.
No chance since I just ordered a slice and left a 20% tip. Who knows these days. I chalked it up to the pizza just sucks there. Surprising, since everyone was raving about this place online.
Whole foods pizza blows this place out of the water honestly.
Typical dive bar feel, and service was normal. Food was offensive tbh.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
It's fine. Not expensive, but still somehow a bit expensive for what it is. Though to be fair Talarico's across the street is $10 a slice so maybe pizza prices are just getting out of hand in general.
First time there, was confused as how to order and no one guided us. Ordered two slices of pepperoni and one of their salads to share with my husband.
Food was plenty and okay, nothing really special about it. Music was funk/rap, could be a more fun inviting place.
The two workers we encountered were not friendly. Pretty much robotic. Will probably give it another chance at some point. Maybe they were having an off day?
I still think Supreme is the best NY style pizza in the area but I have to say the quality has slowly been going down over the past few years. It’s like they’re rushing to get their orders out and are getting sloppy with making them. I love garlic but don’t really appreciate chunks of garlic the size of teeth in my pizza, chop it up a little more please! Take the time to let the pizza finish in the oven, the past several times the dough is soft and undercooked and cheese barely melted.
Food: 4
Supreme is a great value for pizza by the slice when you just want a snack. The restaurant has the old-school dive bar feel, friendly staff, and a lively atmosphere with a few TVs for sports.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza by the Slice
Visiting West Seattle for a month, and this was my favorite bar. We asked for a channel on one of the TVs, and the bartender accommodated us in less than 30 seconds. The French 75 I ordered was perfect, and my husband said the beer recommendation was on point. They have a classic video game system with a ton of games, and we both played games from our (millennial) childhood while sitting at the bar. The bartender made us feel funny and smart, even though we were a little drunk. Pizza by the slice!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
I dream about this pizza. Their chef is the nicest person alive — she custom makes goat cheese Detroit style pizza for me every time I come in. I can’t say enough good about the staff, the food, everything about Supreme. 10/10 stars.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Sometimes they have great rock shit pumping, sometimes it's hip hop too loud. Pizza is great most of the time but every now and then it's undercooked. Nice staff and great atmosphere most of the time. Their sausage supreme never fails
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Cool spot. I had this on my list from a Seattle food magazine for their Portuguese sausage, ham, and jalapeno pizza. I'm Portuguese and got really excited about linguica being offered. It didn't have too much of the flavor I was expecting or much flavor at all. For a $44 pie I was hoping for more and this left me wanting more. The sizes are huge so even though it was pricey, my husband and I ate this for 3 lunches later that week. I'd recommend getting a slice instead of the whole pie. They reheat it so it's crisper on the bottom opposed to the whole pie was a bit softer.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Best spot for a slice and a pint in the junction.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My friend and I had a late-night craving and decided to check out Supreme for the first time. We ordered just two slices to-go (the Detroit and the chef’s choice) and nothing else. The atmosphere was great and everyone seemed to be enjoying themselves, so we were excited to try it.
After about 20 minutes of waiting, we still hadn’t received our slices. It was a bit busy and we were caught up in conversation, so we didn’t think much of it at first — we figured they were still heating them up. But then we noticed the bartender take two slices out of the oven that looked like our order — completely burnt — and set them aside. It was an honest mistake, and we didn’t fault him for that. What was frustrating, though, was that he didn’t acknowledge the error or put in a replacement order.
We waited another 5–10 minutes with still no update, so we finally went up to the bar to check in. The bartender asked us what we had ordered and told us it would be just three more minutes. Eventually, we got our slices — more than 30 minutes after we had originally ordered — with no apology or effort to make the situation right.
The pizza was good, but the experience left a bad taste
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 1
The pizza is insanely delicious, but it is a bar so not a family friendly place. Perfect for a date night or hooking up with friends.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Pizza by the Slice
Loading...