Supreme
4521 California Ave SW, Seattle
(206) 257-4767
Customers' Favorites
Double Pepperoni Pie
Chicken Wings Tossed
Pizza by the Slice
Pepperoni Pizza
Menu
Photos
+26 photos
+25 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
It's fine. Not expensive, but still somehow a bit expensive for what it is. Though to be fair Talarico's across the street is $10 a slice so maybe pizza prices are just getting out of hand in general.
First time there, was confused as how to order and no one guided us. Ordered two slices of pepperoni and one of their salads to share with my husband.
Food was plenty and okay, nothing really special about it. Music was funk/rap, could be a more fun inviting place.
The two workers we encountered were not friendly. Pretty much robotic. Will probably give it another chance at some point. Maybe they were having an off day?
Food was plenty and okay, nothing really special about it. Music was funk/rap, could be a more fun inviting place.
The two workers we encountered were not friendly. Pretty much robotic. Will probably give it another chance at some point. Maybe they were having an off day?
I still think Supreme is the best NY style pizza in the area but I have to say the quality has slowly been going down over the past few years. It’s like they’re rushing to get their orders out and are getting sloppy with making them. I love garlic but don’t really appreciate chunks of garlic the size of teeth in my pizza, chop it up a little more please! Take the time to let the pizza finish in the oven, the past several times the dough is soft and undercooked and cheese...
You May Also Like
Pegasus Pizza and Pasta - 4520 California Ave SW
![]()
Italian, Salad, Pizza
Lady Jaye - 4523 California Ave SW
![]()
American, Smokehouse, Cocktail Bar, Pet Friendly
Azuma Sushi - 4533 California Ave SW
![]()
Japanese, Sushi Bar, Sushi, Vegetarian