Tonight we got the chance to experience the newly renovated and expanded Antojitos Mexicano on College Ave in Appleton. We were NOT disappointed, to put it simply it was beautiful and delicious.It’s swanky enough to be a solid go to when you want to dress up for a classy night out, but casual enough that you can go in jeans and a hat (like we did tonight).The foot print is more than double the size, so much more spacious and open than ever before. If you’re wondering how all that additional room is possible, it’s because the restaurant is expanded to fill the neighboring building as well. Joining the two buildings was done so well it looks like it’s always been that way.Covering two buildings doesn’t mean it feels too open or not inviting, it’s quite the opposite. It has a cozy feel to it created in many different ways. By adding sitting areas with couches, quaint tables, little nooks for drinks and appetizers and all the different looks and textures that were used, it feels like you’re able to experience the restaurant in many different areas, all with their own ambiance. Many different styles of chairs and and seating ensure you’ll be happy to enjoy your time there while soaking in the beautiful decor, lighting and of course those you’re with. There’s even a large community table for groups or getting to know others.The food was as great as always, with quite a few new additional items on the menu but also so many of the same items we always loved. If you’re like us, you’ll also notice new dishes, plates, and much more. It’s a like a new restaurant, but one where you know you’ll already love the food, drinks and staff.Speaking of drinks, there’s now 2 bars. The original bar and back bar area is still there but now there is a new, very large bar in the front of the new part. We didn’t partake in having drinks tonight but the drink menu is expanded as well. Of course there’s the favorites like Margaritas (our favorite being the BMW), Mojitos, Paloma’s etc, but there is also many new drinks on the menu (craft cocktails, beers and others that we’ll have to explore over the years).We can’t wait to go back again and again. Congrats the to Antojitos’s team on their new chapter and thank you for providing a place for your customers to create memories with each other, while enjoying delicious food and drinks in such a beautiful place! We’re lucky to have such an amazing place in Appleton!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mister Sachs
The food is on the fancier side and the taste matches it. The marg flights are awesome and the environment is modern and comforting. It took me too long to get around to trying this
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Virgin Jalapeno Margarita
Laurie Gross
As amazing as ever! Just dined in on grand reopening night and was so pleased with our entire experience. The atmosphere from the second you walk up to the door (before you even enter!) is welcoming with the most authentic vibe.We were immediately greeted by multiple smiling faces at the hostess stand and directed to a table in the beautiful new seating area. The new lighter colors on the walls brighten up the interior and really create a space that makes you feel like You’re somewhere you want to hang out all night. We were quickly greeted by our server, and given drink menus and food menus. She stopped back multiple times giving us plenty time to take in all the new choices and kindly asked if we had any questions. I was impressed by how many staff they had on opening night. We were also given chips and salsa (just as delicious — my favorite is the bean dip!) right away along with water, while we waited for our drinks. I was also impressed by how quickly we received our drinks from the bar, and how attentive our server was the entire experience, even though she had multiple tables. I tried something new on the menu, a build your own bowl, and it was absolutely delicious. It’s obvious that each ingredient to every item on the menu is thoughtfully decided upon, and every entrée is carefully prepared.We were there tonight for a girls night, but I cannot wait to bring the kids to see it and dine here. There are so many new seating options, including couches and upholstered chairs, and beautiful custom art on the walls. Also new bathrooms!I am so proud of this local Appleton establishment and cannot wait to go back (again and again)! We are very fortunate to have this place and such an authentic Mexican food experience here in our own town.
Just visited after renovations. The atmosphere was absolutely gorgeous. The food was average upon reopening they were very skimpy on the chips and salsa, there was no buy one get one deal on Monday and only offered margaritas in 12oz glasses which were $9 each or a pitcher for $38. Every side was an additional price as well although prior to reopening that wasn’t even a thing and was included with the meal. They also took many of the fan favorites off of the menu as well. There were plenty of waitresses there and had enough people working but our waitresses were lacking and seemed to forget about our table. The other staff was great and was very helpful when they saw we were getting little to no service. I don’t recommend this place at all there are better restaurants to give business to that are more family oriented and have better deals and food. I understand they just re opened but hoping this is an eye opener for regular customers and business owners about past experiences that were better than this time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 1
E-Ben Grisby
The food is definitely worth the price!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
la
They’re closed
Debra Grossinger
Flautas were overfried and dried out. Bean dip was served luke warm. Anyone that knows anything about food safety knows this could be a red flag.. we took a chance and we paid for it.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Cody Reas
Anyone who ate the bean dip with chips at my table had stomach issues the next day. Won’t be going back anytime soon.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
J
Great place. Best mole ever and a low sugar margarita option. Lovely chips. Very hip decor. just go hungry. portions huge!
We went here recently and waited a good 10 or 15 minutes once seated to have our waitress great us. The Marg was very very light on liquor, couldn't taste it at all. Out of the four of us, only 1 of us liked the food we got and the bill was over $120. The nacho appetizer was very good I must say. Was very disappointed that they didn't offer a military discount at all though. Always a down side when companies don't support the people who fight for their freedom.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Nachos
Siena
This is my go to place when I crave chicken mole. Tried strawberries basil martini and I really liked it! The service is great too!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mole Sauce
Nicolas viveros
I loved the food, presentation, variety and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Tina D
Food was good but way too expensive! Small portions too.Noisy and small tables. Plus we had to plug a meter to park. No parking lot. Fee for using a credit card. We won’t be back.Parking: It’s ridiculous that you gave to pay to eat somewhere.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Alan Arenz
Great tamales. Got the house favorite, one pork, one chicken with green tomatillo sauce. Unique salsas for ships. Nice strawberry lemonade.
Love the remodel...it looks wonderful.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fajita Combo, Shrimp Ceviche Guacamole
Tonight we got the chance to experience the newly renovated and expanded Antojitos Mexicano on College Ave in Appleton. We were NOT disappointed, to put it simply it was beautiful and delicious.It’s swanky enough to be a solid go to when you want to dress up for a classy night out, but casual enough that you can go in jeans and a hat (like we did tonight).The foot print is more than double the size, so much more spacious and open than ever before. If you’re wondering how all that additional room is possible, it’s because the restaurant is expanded to fill the neighboring building as well. Joining the two buildings was done so well it looks like it’s always been that way.Covering two buildings doesn’t mean it feels too open or not inviting, it’s quite the opposite. It has a cozy feel to it created in many different ways. By adding sitting areas with couches, quaint tables, little nooks for drinks and appetizers and all the different looks and textures that were used, it feels like you’re able to experience the restaurant in many different areas, all with their own ambiance. Many different styles of chairs and and seating ensure you’ll be happy to enjoy your time there while soaking in the beautiful decor, lighting and of course those you’re with. There’s even a large community table for groups or getting to know others.The food was as great as always, with quite a few new additional items on the menu but also so many of the same items we always loved. If you’re like us, you’ll also notice new dishes, plates, and much more. It’s a like a new restaurant, but one where you know you’ll already love the food, drinks and staff.Speaking of drinks, there’s now 2 bars. The original bar and back bar area is still there but now there is a new, very large bar in the front of the new part. We didn’t partake in having drinks tonight but the drink menu is expanded as well. Of course there’s the favorites like Margaritas (our favorite being the BMW), Mojitos, Paloma’s etc, but there is also many new drinks on the menu (craft cocktails, beers and others that we’ll have to explore over the years).We can’t wait to go back again and again. Congrats the to Antojitos’s team on their new chapter and thank you for providing a place for your customers to create memories with each other, while enjoying delicious food and drinks in such a beautiful place! We’re lucky to have such an amazing place in Appleton!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food is on the fancier side and the taste matches it. The marg flights are awesome and the environment is modern and comforting. It took me too long to get around to trying this
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Virgin Jalapeno Margarita
As amazing as ever! Just dined in on grand reopening night and was so pleased with our entire experience. The atmosphere from the second you walk up to the door (before you even enter!) is welcoming with the most authentic vibe.We were immediately greeted by multiple smiling faces at the hostess stand and directed to a table in the beautiful new seating area. The new lighter colors on the walls brighten up the interior and really create a space that makes you feel like You’re somewhere you want to hang out all night. We were quickly greeted by our server, and given drink menus and food menus. She stopped back multiple times giving us plenty time to take in all the new choices and kindly asked if we had any questions. I was impressed by how many staff they had on opening night. We were also given chips and salsa (just as delicious — my favorite is the bean dip!) right away along with water, while we waited for our drinks. I was also impressed by how quickly we received our drinks from the bar, and how attentive our server was the entire experience, even though she had multiple tables. I tried something new on the menu, a build your own bowl, and it was absolutely delicious. It’s obvious that each ingredient to every item on the menu is thoughtfully decided upon, and every entrée is carefully prepared.We were there tonight for a girls night, but I cannot wait to bring the kids to see it and dine here. There are so many new seating options, including couches and upholstered chairs, and beautiful custom art on the walls. Also new bathrooms!I am so proud of this local Appleton establishment and cannot wait to go back (again and again)! We are very fortunate to have this place and such an authentic Mexican food experience here in our own town.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Virgin Jalapeno Margarita, Fiesta Queso, Tamale Dinner, Shrimp Tacos, Shrimp Ceviche Guacamole
Just visited after renovations. The atmosphere was absolutely gorgeous. The food was average upon reopening they were very skimpy on the chips and salsa, there was no buy one get one deal on Monday and only offered margaritas in 12oz glasses which were $9 each or a pitcher for $38. Every side was an additional price as well although prior to reopening that wasn’t even a thing and was included with the meal. They also took many of the fan favorites off of the menu as well. There were plenty of waitresses there and had enough people working but our waitresses were lacking and seemed to forget about our table. The other staff was great and was very helpful when they saw we were getting little to no service. I don’t recommend this place at all there are better restaurants to give business to that are more family oriented and have better deals and food. I understand they just re opened but hoping this is an eye opener for regular customers and business owners about past experiences that were better than this time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 1
The food is definitely worth the price!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They’re closed
Flautas were overfried and dried out. Bean dip was served luke warm. Anyone that knows anything about food safety knows this could be a red flag.. we took a chance and we paid for it.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Anyone who ate the bean dip with chips at my table had stomach issues the next day. Won’t be going back anytime soon.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Great place. Best mole ever and a low sugar margarita option. Lovely chips. Very hip decor. just go hungry. portions huge!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Nachos
Restaurantji Recommends
We went here recently and waited a good 10 or 15 minutes once seated to have our waitress great us. The Marg was very very light on liquor, couldn't taste it at all. Out of the four of us, only 1 of us liked the food we got and the bill was over $120. The nacho appetizer was very good I must say. Was very disappointed that they didn't offer a military discount at all though. Always a down side when companies don't support the people who fight for their freedom.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Nachos
This is my go to place when I crave chicken mole. Tried strawberries basil martini and I really liked it! The service is great too!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mole Sauce
I loved the food, presentation, variety and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Food was good but way too expensive! Small portions too.Noisy and small tables. Plus we had to plug a meter to park. No parking lot. Fee for using a credit card. We won’t be back.Parking: It’s ridiculous that you gave to pay to eat somewhere.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Great tamales. Got the house favorite, one pork, one chicken with green tomatillo sauce. Unique salsas for ships. Nice strawberry lemonade.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tamales