When I moved to appleton this was my GO TO place, the selections were crazy and the food was always fresh! I was so sad to find out they shut down a few months back and haven’t been able to find anything close to Bagelicious… is there any talk of this location coming back?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Asiago Bagel
Kevin Kelly
Are you guys ever going to open agin? Great bagels by the way!
Julia Shipley
Don’t say open if your not. We just drove over an hour away to find out your closed due to “no staff” , ridiculous.
Kortnee Davidovich
I love starting my days with this place being the first stop! I can't beat a toasted sundried tomato bagel with scallion cream cheese.
Pat Clusman
Nice place to stop for a breakfast bagel. Good selection of bagels, cream cheeses, and sandwich options. Friendly staff.
Caleb Hein
Great bagel place in downtown Appleton, definitely a worthy breakfast consideration for anyone in town. They have a wide variety of bagels and will make any of their bagels to order.
Cynthia B.
Absolutely amazing! So mouthwatering, local, and made right in front of you! Very friendly staff, warm environment and inviting.
Lisa Hartz
AMAZING customer service!! Delicious soft bagels & delicious smooth flavored cream cheese spread!! one happy momma here
CowCountryVintageSewing MachinesAndRestoration
Good food, pleasant staff, but their precautions against covid-19 could be much improved.
Quality, fresh, well priced and lots of options. Make sure to stop if you like bagels
Jill Lallensack
Very helpful for our first time there.
Collin Schmidt
Always fantastic. Good menu selection, nice employees, great food.
Autumn K.
Found this gem on a whim. Everything was absolutely delicious. The menu is simple but they also provide so many options for bagels and cream cheese. My kids loved their breakfast sandwich. 5 stars!
G R
Reminds me of the bagels back home in NYC area. Excellent customer service. I highly recommend.
Permanently
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
When I moved to appleton this was my GO TO place, the selections were crazy and the food was always fresh! I was so sad to find out they shut down a few months back and haven’t been able to find anything close to Bagelicious… is there any talk of this location coming back?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Asiago Bagel
Are you guys ever going to open agin? Great bagels by the way!
Don’t say open if your not. We just drove over an hour away to find out your closed due to “no staff” , ridiculous.
I love starting my days with this place being the first stop! I can't beat a toasted sundried tomato bagel with scallion cream cheese.
Nice place to stop for a breakfast bagel. Good selection of bagels, cream cheeses, and sandwich options. Friendly staff.
Great bagel place in downtown Appleton, definitely a worthy breakfast consideration for anyone in town. They have a wide variety of bagels and will make any of their bagels to order.
Absolutely amazing! So mouthwatering, local, and made right in front of you! Very friendly staff, warm environment and inviting.
AMAZING customer service!! Delicious soft bagels & delicious smooth flavored cream cheese spread!! one happy momma here
Good food, pleasant staff, but their precautions against covid-19 could be much improved.
Restaurantji Recommends
Quality, fresh, well priced and lots of options. Make sure to stop if you like bagels
Very helpful for our first time there.
Always fantastic. Good menu selection, nice employees, great food.
Found this gem on a whim. Everything was absolutely delicious. The menu is simple but they also provide so many options for bagels and cream cheese. My kids loved their breakfast sandwich. 5 stars!
Reminds me of the bagels back home in NYC area. Excellent customer service. I highly recommend.