Glass Nickel Pizza Co. – Appleton

Great food as always.

Ordered pizza and salads for delivery. Service was great. Pizza was really good. Salads were awful. Cheese was dried out, bacon was raw and all fat, lettuce was old and red around edges. Ended up throwing the salads away. I have eaten here alot of times and will continue to do so although won't be ordering any more salads. Obviously they don't check them much to see what they look like.

One star only for the bad website, unusable on phone

We received a pizza delivery from here. It was earlier than anticipated. The delivery person, Kayla?, deserved a bigger tip than we included on the order. The crust was perfectly done for me. The sauce had a great Italian seasoning flavor. The ingredients were fresh and evenly distributed. The cook on the pizza was great- browned slightly but not crunchy. I will definitely order from here again.

Hostess wasn’t very nice. Asked for a booth (there were a lot open) and was told she had only one on the end in the middle of everything. She was pretty short with us. Waitress was cordial but that was it. Pizza was good though. Thankfully.

Ruined my birthday. Website said Dine In was open, most definitely wasn't! Had my mind set on it for a week, got there after checking twice, and Dine In was closed. Terrible. We then tried to walk in for Dine In, and all 3 times someone walked by, they ignored us. (Even though Take Out is open.) Love the food, hate the service.

We came here on a Thursday night to celebrate my daughter's birthday only to find a sign on the door that the dinning room is closed. Then we went in to order take out and got completely ignored by 3 different people. This is unprofessional and unacceptable no matter how short staffed you are.

If you like your calzone and Stromboli with raw dough- glass nickel is for you! Both were crispy on the outside but mush, raw, undercooked, dangerous, cold inside. On top of it, you’ve raised your prices and offer food poisoning as a replacement.

Went here for the first time. When I first called to ask a question, the guy that answered could’ve been more friendly. I got 2 gluten free crust pizzas (only comes in 10”, so they’re small) and both had crust so burnt that they were very hard to chew. Not worth the $34.29

We were the only people there besides a guy waiting for his togo order.. had 4 people walk past us and it took 10 mins (felt like 20) then we got our order taken.. service was great after that.. they messed up our order but everything was still great

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 2

God awful service, we didn’t even get food. It was about 6:25 pm when we got there and we went it and got seated. then they asked us for drinks and we told them water and nickle nuggets, then they didn’t write it down, or go to the kitchen, and instead outside. When they came back with our drinks after about 10 minutes they went back outside and came back In to seat more people, now 3 tables full. They come back and ask us what we want to order, and we order two salads and a medium pizza, without writing it down they then waddle off back outside with the other waiters. About an hour passes with no food or then checking in on us. we order it to go and only get the salads, as they say that the pizza is cooking, keep in mind everyone else including the people who came after us for food, and after half an hour they come back with the receipt and tell us how much it costs (NO PIZZA) the. Waddle back outside, and we decide to leave, without half the food, of course we did pay, full price without half of the food, and now it’s about 7:45 pm to 7:50, and we drive home looking for any other place open (there’s nothing open) so we get cheap food at a Walmart, while they get stoned.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Nickel Nuggets, Pepperoni Pizza

My family came here, and I’ve been before I thought it was great until today. The waiter took drink orders , and I ordered nickel nuggets, he came back 15-20 minutes later and asked about food order. We ordered 2 salads and a medium pepperoni pizza. He never came back. 30 minutes later , I saw him pass by our table, asked for food to go. 30 minutes later we got salads. Never saw the pizza. In the meantime saw many ppl come n go. I’m wouldn’t suggest this place. Never going back.

YUM-MEE This pizza is amazing! So tasty ? A wonderful experience overall.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Nickel Nuggets

Food was cold, very little sauce on pasta. Floating in water. Same in green bay gave this one a chance and it was worse.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 3

It's a decent pizza with good service

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4