Great American Cookies

4301 West Wisconsin Avenue, Appleton
(920) 734-8726

Recent Reviews

stacey staffeld

Cookies ( double doozies) did not taste fresh this time… I always get them when I go to mall and was very disappointed this time.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Taliha Leon

The two gents that closed Thursday Jan 18th(Daniel and Matt I believe)? We’re extremely nice and let me make a cookie purchase even though they were about to clock out and leave for the night.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Josh Van

Cookies are good, customer service wasn't

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 3

Glori Ellenbecker

Ordered on line .. requested a twisted tea can design to be put on the cake..it turned out great! Thank you!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake

Kathy Jackson

This location is especially good with really nice people and great service. Even with a last minute order. Cookies are yummy as always

LaDonna Henslee

Like other reviews, I would like to give them a 0 star review. All of my kids like these cookie cakes for their birthdays, so I get several a year, and maybe once I will get one that is not an oily mess. You pay nearly $50 for this mess, and they want a tip! Shame on you Great American Cookie Cake!

Melanie S

Their double doozie cookies are the best. Large or mini.

N Zibby

Very very good cookies they become addicting a little high priced but what is not now a days

BLynn Homes

Placed order online, they called to confirm order. Cookie cake was ready and perfectly decorated. I order from here every year and they never let me done. Great store, great employees!

Capt. Tiger Hall

Great selection of cookies ? ? ? Awesome workers too. Make them smile ? ? because they make your day!

Briana Denman

Cookies are delicious. Lots of variety to choose from, which is awesome. The customer service gentleman who helped me was kinfa rude and seemed annoyed. He left all my boxed up cookies behind the register after checking out and just walked away. I had to shuffle my full arms to reach and grab them. but again, great cookies. I loved them.

B_onthe_road State Park Traveler

Placed order online, they called to confirm order. Cookie cake was ready and perfectly decorated. I order from here every year and they never let me done. Great store, great employees!

Amanda M

Cookies never disappoint but the employee young blonde hair girl as much as she was fast with getting orders she was not attentive towards everything else. I am no sure if its just her or who ever trained her but she would get our order and seem inpatient if you take long and would just grab a cookie without actually asking if thats the cookies we wanted and ring us up than leave without a "thank you or good bye or do you want the receipt"I saw receipt piled at both registers, i grabed mine under other receipts.

Amanda

Cookies never disappoint but the employee young blonde hair girl as much as she was fast with getting orders she was not attentive towards everything else. I am no sure if its just her or who ever trained her but she would get our order and seem inpatient if you take long and would just grab a cookie without actually asking if thats the cookies we wanted and ring us up than leave without a "thank you or good bye or do you want the receipt"I saw receipt piled at both registers, i grabed mine under other receipts.

Rebecca M K

Their cookies are scrumptious and the large cookie cakes had very creative, intricate designs. Will definitely consider using them for birthday parties or other special occasions. ?

Load More