Luigis Pizza of Appleton

Made a large order for 20 people. Service was fabulous, everything was taken care of, great experience

Had dinner at Luigi’s this evening and I’m still thinking about it hours later. This family-run Italian restaurant is something truly special.
I ordered the manicotti, and it was absolutely phenomenal. The pasta was perfectly cooked, the filling rich and flavorful, and the sauce tasted like it had been simmering all day. Every bite felt like a labor of love—comforting, indulgent, and deeply satisfying.
The service was equally lovely: friendly, attentive, and genuine.
Can’t wait to come back. If you’re thinking about going, do yourself a favor and order the manicotti—you won’t regret it.

Not long ago we were searching for a local pizza spot and decided to go to Luigis since they are right up the road. The young kman who greeted us was clearly not happy to be there. Questions weren't asked to figure out what I was there for, rather he just gave me orders. Directing me away from the front desk. Took some pushing back to tell him I'm not here to order or sit down, I am picking up an order that I had already called in. Hope they gave him customer service lessons or moved him to the back of house. Haven't gone back since.

Very friendly and good service. The pizza was amazing! Big servings for a great price.

The most authentic Italian food I’ve had in a long time. I come from an Italian household and the meatballs took me back to when I was a child. The atmosphere was amazing and inviting. Everything was great. I can’t wait to return.

Great food, great atmosphere, excellent service! The prices are great! Best Italian in the Valley!

Just found this place. Shame on Google for not showing here as an option. Great prices and even more important amazing food. And another thing! Best service I've had in a long time.

Excellent service, fresh, hot, delicious pizza and pasta.....will definitely return!

Luigi's has great pizza at a decent price. My son and I had our own twelve inch pies, but they seemed bigger than that because we were stuffed. Fresh ingredients and family owned make for a great experience. Mama mia!

They are still open, even with the construction going on! Amazing service. Quick. Always refilling drinks. Food is amazing. Got a pizza and cheesy bread. Very filling.

Excellent pizza! They even take great care of our dairy-free needs. 🥰 Thank You for the great service today and always!!

Cannot figure out why people are raving about the food. We got pizza delivered with bread sticks and cheesebread. It was the most bland food ever. The pizza crust seemed like a premade crust you buy from the grocery store. It reminded me of a very basic cracker. There was so little sauce on the pizza, so the only flavor we had was the cheese and toppings. The cheesebread was dry, cold, and flavorless. The bread sticks were a little better. I love to support local but this was very disappointing.

Food: 2

I have been a customer for years and there is just something about your hometown pizza place, right? The family atmosphere there is welcoming and heartfelt. The food is just like your mother would make, if she was Italian and cooked from the heart. We get takeout mostly, but their dining room is intimate and fun. I recommend their meatballs, most of all, which they have as an app, but if you're like me, you might want to just order those with extra meat sauce for your pasta dinner some nights. Their lasagna and shells are amazing, bursting with cheese and spinach and swimming in fresh tomato sauce. Their pizza, well, it's also outstanding. Any way you like it. (We like Luigi's Special.) The calzones are great too and their salads are always fresh. Jo, I know you know, but I seriously appreciate all you do to keep it fresh and of the utmost quality. You are doing an amazing job of carrying on your dad's tradition and upholding your establishment's reputation. THANK YOU!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We had a great first dinning experience today. The food was good, well priced and lots of cheese! The cheesy garlic bread won the kids over. The service was also great!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheesy Bread

Love the pizza! Love the service! Love supporting family run businesses! Thanks Jo for always making us feel welcome! And, for always remembering we have one daughter who does not love black olives! Delicious! I highly recommend the Josephine pizza!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5