Rye Restaurant

w 54911, 308 W College Ave, Appleton
(920) 380-4745

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Rhyder

Stellar service, fresh oysters, great cocktails, and amazing presentation of main entrees.

Diane

I enjoyed my dinner, everything was delicious and beautifully presented. My waitress was very nice and very attentive.

Ellyn

We had the pleasure of being served by Willow last night and I cannot recommend her highly enough! From the moment we were seated, she was attentive, friendly, and genuinely caring. She anticipated our needs, offered excellent recommendations, and handled everything with professionalism and a smile. Her energy and dedication made our experience truly memorable. It's rare to encounter someone who combines efficiency, warmth, and professionalism so seamlessly. She clearly goes above and beyond for every guest, and her positive attitude is infectious. Any team would be lucky to have her in a leadership role, as she sets a high standard for service and embodies the best qualities of hospitality.

Deborah

Excellent experience. Got a bit noisy as the restaurant filled up. If need quiet it is better to ask for a table (or booth) in the lobby rather than in the main restaurant. Food and service are the same excellent quality as in the main restaurant.

Katie

We love Rye! It's always so amazing, favorites are the Kale salad, oysters and risotto. My husband often gets the pork chop and loves it! I love the wine selection and cute atmosphere.

Kim

We thoroughly enjoyed our dining experience, sampling several delicious appetizers, including the risotto balls, cheese curds, French onion soup, and beet salad, before our generous main courses arrived. Our waitress was exceptional. Two of us devoured our salmon, while the ribeye was slightly tough despite being cooked medium-rare. The overall experience was exc ellent. It was rounded out by wonderful dessert options and was started with specialty drinks. We will definitely be returning!

Aidan

We went here before a show at the Performing Arts Center for a pre-weekend getaway. We loved the food, the service, and the ambience - it was a wonderful experience all the way around.

Maria

This is my second time dining at Rye. I brought three friends this time. All of the food was fabulous!!! We split two salads. I loved the beet salad. Our entrees were amazing. Such complex flavors!!!! I wish I didn't live 300 miles away!

Linda

This is one of my favorite places on earth! Each time I'm here, I think, oh my gosh this is the BEST. Meal. Ever. Truly, it takes me a few minutes to taste my food because I'm eating it with my eyes first!!

R yan

Amazing job by all of the employees. Our server was wonderful, we had great interactions with the bar tender and our food was cooked perfectly.

Lauren

An absolute must! If considering Rye, go! It was 10/10 from the moment we entered- low noise, incredible service, outstanding meal and drinks. The cost matches the value, which don't often find to be true. Can't wait to return!

Debbie Henderson

I think the food is over priced. They took some really good stuff off the menu that I liked so not a huge menu selection.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 5

Joanna

It was very energetic in there for sure but unfortunately it took away from some conversation with my wife. We felt like we had to really speak up in parts of conversation, but other than, LOVED our experience! Everything was fantastic and we'll be back again!

Tia

Our food was outstanding. Our waitress was outstanding. It was a theatre night and she was still very attentive. Our food came out with minimal wait time. We were celebrating our friend's retirement. She gave him a wonderful retirement wine pour. We had oysters and crab cakes which were delicious. I had the cod. It was a very large portion. My husband had the salmon. Both were marvelous. Our friends had lemon chicken and beef with pasta. Both terrific. Dessert consisted of hot skillet chocolate chip cookie with ice cream , pumpkin apple bread pudding. Both divine. Our experience was a 10!

Karen

We will definitely return to try more menu options. The filet and salmon were outstanding; I also loved the corn and cheddar risotto. Our server was great, and the service was very timely.

Loading...