We chose Simple Simon Bakery for our wedding desserts, and it was one of the best decisions we made! Instead of a traditional cake, we went with their 3” mini pies and they were an absolute hit with our guests. Everyone loved them!
We served a mix of pumpkin, caramel apple, classic apple, and cherry, and every flavor was delicious. The pies were perfectly baked, beautifully presented, and just so cute on display. It was the perfect mix of cozy and elegant, and such a fun twist on traditional wedding dessert.
Simple Simon Bakery helped make our reception feel so warm and memorable, our guests are still raving about those mini pies, and we couldn’t agree more!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lyndsey Hietpas
Used them for our wedding and the services 10/10 the entire time! Of course the desserts were tasty but they delivered our items and set it all up at our venue on our wedding day. Went so Smooth!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Larry Torska
Bought a caramel apple pie they had today had it for dinner is the best apple pie I’ve ever had
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Josh and Alyssa
We recommend using Simple Simon Bakery for any of your bakery needs. Dawn made the cupcakes and cakes for our wedding. She was very easy to work with and responsive to emails. The whole process of working with Simple Simon Bakery is convenient. We had a taste testing and after that initial tasting we bought a few more samples to ensure we knew what flavors we wanted. There are so many different flavors offered that there is something here for everyone. The cupcakes and cake we had ordered were amazing and so delicious! We sent Dawn inspiration pictures on how we wanted our cake decorated and Dawn brought our vision to life. We had Simple Simon Bakery deliver the cake and cupcakes to our venue and it was a seamless process. When they delivered the cake and cupcakes they worked with the venue staff to have it all set for us. Simple Simon bakery did not have to contact us during the delivery, this was so nice to not have to worry about it during our day. From start to finish, working with Dawn at Simple Simon Bakery was so easy and positive.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bakery, Wedding Cake
Yaoster G
Best bakery anywhere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Aubrey Johnson
Simple bakery, with very kind people who help you find what you need. Plus lots of delicious goodies. Also guided us to another bakery for friends who were celiac
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alexandra Vredeveld
Simple Simon provided us with desserts for our wedding August 2025 and we couldn't be more thankful we went with them! Cheesecakes were a hit at our rehearsal then guests raved about the brownies, cookies and cupcakes they got to try at our reception. We also got a two tiered cake for us which was absolutely perfect! From the first meeting I knew we would be well taken care of and they would make our vision come to life. Thank you Simple Simon!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Destinee Usta
This was my first time ordering a cake , I called originally and asked about the process which she directed me to the online form . I was nervous but upon filling it out I realized how easy and effortless they made it . I was able to describe what I wanted with a photo . I said they could put their own twist On things and the cake turned out better than the Inspo pic I left in the order form . I’m beyond satisfied and so grateful they were polite and creative . Would definitely recommend💕
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Isley Justinger
We had Simple Simon for our wedding at the Waters and everything was fantastic! We ordered a small cake just for the bride and the groom and it was perfect and decorated perfectly to match our nautical theme! We also ordered 5 different flavors of cupcakes for the guests and they absolutely loved them! Dawn was amazing setting it all up beautifully the morning of the wedding! I highly recommend using Simple Simon for your wedding dessert!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Saralynn A
Ordered a Baby Yoda shaped cake for my Grandson's birthday. Turned out absolutely adorable! He was so happy. Tasted wonderful, too. Staff was so helpful and friendly.
Visiting from oklahoma, I found this place and it's amazing. A little pricey on the cup cake but sooooo worth it. Thanks for a wonderful, sweet morning
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bakery, Cookies
Elizabeth Miller
Simple Simon is incredible! We ordered from Simple Simon for our wedding cake and dessert bar and it all tasted amazing. Dawn was so helpful throughout the process. We were able to sample potential desserts, she helped us get an idea of how much to order, and she also set our desserts at the venue. Our cake was also delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jessica Blattner
Simple Simon Bakery went above and beyond my expectations for an order I put in. I wanted to recognize employees in my department that had to work over the holiday weekend and I am not local to Appleton. They delivered an assortment of muffins, donuts and cookies, even though they were closed for the day. When I asked if they had any fruit options, they offered to pick up a fruit tray from the local grocery store! The team appreciated the treats!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Austin Button
Probably one of those hidden gems.a small bakery that you dont know about until you're told about it, then you dont want to go anywhere else. Great and delicious looking pastries. I wanted to try them all unfortunately my wallet didn't agree. The service was great and they were very friendly.
Clare Conteh-Morgan
We hired Simple Simon for our wedding cake and cupcakes. We could not be happier with our cake and cupcakes and the service! Our cake was beautiful and exactly what we wanted, and everything was delicious. We got four cupcake flavors: white, chocolate, carrot cake, and almond. The carrot cake was especially popular with our guests! We got exactly what we wanted. Dawn even called me to ask how everything went. It was also a smooth process with the consulting and planning side of things. Thank you Simple Simon for being a part of making our wedding dreams come true!
We chose Simple Simon Bakery for our wedding desserts, and it was one of the best decisions we made! Instead of a traditional cake, we went with their 3” mini pies and they were an absolute hit with our guests. Everyone loved them!
We served a mix of pumpkin, caramel apple, classic apple, and cherry, and every flavor was delicious. The pies were perfectly baked, beautifully presented, and just so cute on display. It was the perfect mix of cozy and elegant, and such a fun twist on traditional wedding dessert.
Simple Simon Bakery helped make our reception feel so warm and memorable, our guests are still raving about those mini pies, and we couldn’t agree more!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Used them for our wedding and the services 10/10 the entire time! Of course the desserts were tasty but they delivered our items and set it all up at our venue on our wedding day. Went so Smooth!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bought a caramel apple pie they had today had it for dinner is the best apple pie I’ve ever had
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We recommend using Simple Simon Bakery for any of your bakery needs. Dawn made the cupcakes and cakes for our wedding. She was very easy to work with and responsive to emails. The whole process of working with Simple Simon Bakery is convenient. We had a taste testing and after that initial tasting we bought a few more samples to ensure we knew what flavors we wanted. There are so many different flavors offered that there is something here for everyone. The cupcakes and cake we had ordered were amazing and so delicious! We sent Dawn inspiration pictures on how we wanted our cake decorated and Dawn brought our vision to life. We had Simple Simon Bakery deliver the cake and cupcakes to our venue and it was a seamless process. When they delivered the cake and cupcakes they worked with the venue staff to have it all set for us. Simple Simon bakery did not have to contact us during the delivery, this was so nice to not have to worry about it during our day. From start to finish, working with Dawn at Simple Simon Bakery was so easy and positive.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bakery, Wedding Cake
Best bakery anywhere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Simple bakery, with very kind people who help you find what you need. Plus lots of delicious goodies.
Also guided us to another bakery for friends who were celiac
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Simple Simon provided us with desserts for our wedding August 2025 and we couldn't be more thankful we went with them! Cheesecakes were a hit at our rehearsal then guests raved about the brownies, cookies and cupcakes they got to try at our reception. We also got a two tiered cake for us which was absolutely perfect! From the first meeting I knew we would be well taken care of and they would make our vision come to life. Thank you Simple Simon!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This was my first time ordering a cake , I called originally and asked about the process which she directed me to the online form . I was nervous but upon filling it out I realized how easy and effortless they made it . I was able to describe what I wanted with a photo . I said they could put their own twist On things and the cake turned out better than the Inspo pic I left in the order form . I’m beyond satisfied and so grateful they were polite and creative . Would definitely recommend💕
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had Simple Simon for our wedding at the Waters and everything was fantastic! We ordered a small cake just for the bride and the groom and it was perfect and decorated perfectly to match our nautical theme! We also ordered 5 different flavors of cupcakes for the guests and they absolutely loved them! Dawn was amazing setting it all up beautifully the morning of the wedding! I highly recommend using Simple Simon for your wedding dessert!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered a Baby Yoda shaped cake for my Grandson's birthday. Turned out absolutely adorable! He was so happy. Tasted wonderful, too. Staff was so helpful and friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Visiting from oklahoma, I found this place and it's amazing. A little pricey on the cup cake but sooooo worth it. Thanks for a wonderful, sweet morning
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bakery, Cookies
Simple Simon is incredible! We ordered from Simple Simon for our wedding cake and dessert bar and it all tasted amazing. Dawn was so helpful throughout the process. We were able to sample potential desserts, she helped us get an idea of how much to order, and she also set our desserts at the venue. Our cake was also delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Simple Simon Bakery went above and beyond my expectations for an order I put in. I wanted to recognize employees in my department that had to work over the holiday weekend and I am not local to Appleton. They delivered an assortment of muffins, donuts and cookies, even though they were closed for the day. When I asked if they had any fruit options, they offered to pick up a fruit tray from the local grocery store! The team appreciated the treats!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Probably one of those hidden gems.a small bakery that you dont know about until you're told about it, then you dont want to go anywhere else. Great and delicious looking pastries. I wanted to try them all unfortunately my wallet didn't agree. The service was great and they were very friendly.
We hired Simple Simon for our wedding cake and cupcakes. We could not be happier with our cake and cupcakes and the service! Our cake was beautiful and exactly what we wanted, and everything was delicious. We got four cupcake flavors: white, chocolate, carrot cake, and almond. The carrot cake was especially popular with our guests! We got exactly what we wanted. Dawn even called me to ask how everything went. It was also a smooth process with the consulting and planning side of things. Thank you Simple Simon for being a part of making our wedding dreams come true!
Loading...