Good food. The waitress was doing her best. Very understaffed.
Jason McDonald
This was our first time at Wiseguys and overall we enjoyed our dinners. We ordered a pizza to share and a cheesy garlic bread. The bread was just okay... nothing special. But the marinara sauce for dipping was outstanding. We then got our pizza... it was a hand-tossed combination. The toppings and sauce were very very good. However, the dough was unexceptional at best. It didn't have much flavor and our pizza was overcooked... most of the bottom and especially around the edges were black. I think if it wasn't burnt it might have helped with the flavor. But overall it was a good pie. Next time I will probably try the Chicago style.
Sara Baumgart
Took over an hour to get a 9 inch pizza. Server took out order, then didn't check on us until food came, the didn't check on us after food came.
Kaitlyn Moore
Had an amazing first experience at Wiseguys Pizzeria. Addison was our server and she made us feel so welcome! Food delicious with a wide selection of gluten free options for myself and low carb options for my wife. This is definitely our new date night spot!
curtis radloff
We've driven past this place so many times and finally decided to give it a try. Atmosphere was outstanding along with the service. The drink selection was good and the food was incredible. If your looking fir a nice cozy pizza place, this is the place to go. We will definitely return.
theodore krueger
My wife had Gluten Free Pizza and said it was the best in town. My kid and got the stuffed deep dish, it was fantastic!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joseph B. Nowak
One of the best kept secrets in the valley. This pizza is hands down some of the best I've ever had. I worked here for a very brief time in high school and I remember seeing everything being made fresh in the kitchen and over 10 years later I can tell nothings changed. The crust, the cheese, the sauce, it's all so delicious. I HIGHLY recommend getting the zesty sauce if you don't mind a little kick, i promise it'll be the most flavorful pizza sauce you've ever had. The pepperoni tastes freshly sliced and not like the cheap overly processed crap and same with the sausage. The owners Mike & Brenda are amazing people and I'm so glad this place is still here all these years later. Our server was great too. I absolutely love the atmosphere too- it's very classy and intimate. Absolutely love this place and I'll gladly keep making the trip from Green Bay.
Nice atmosphere. Friendly waitress. Average service at best. We waited almost an hour for our food and the place wasn’t that busy. Food was t good enough to wait that long for it. Again, average at best. We had higher hopes. We will try one more time.
I just wanted to say thank you for all the meals I've had over the past several years with my religious historian friend Chester. Unfortunately our friend has died. We always loved going into Wiseguys and getting a beer and pizza together. He was a good friend and will be missed. Thank you for having the best place to eat to have friends with. Great staff, great service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
CJ
This is my favorite pizza in Appleton. The food is always delicious. Some of the servers are better than others. The garlic flapper pizza is great. Drinks are kinda pricey.
Best Chicago style pizza in the Fox Valley
Good food. The waitress was doing her best. Very understaffed.
This was our first time at Wiseguys and overall we enjoyed our dinners. We ordered a pizza to share and a cheesy garlic bread. The bread was just okay... nothing special. But the marinara sauce for dipping was outstanding. We then got our pizza... it was a hand-tossed combination. The toppings and sauce were very very good. However, the dough was unexceptional at best. It didn't have much flavor and our pizza was overcooked... most of the bottom and especially around the edges were black. I think if it wasn't burnt it might have helped with the flavor. But overall it was a good pie. Next time I will probably try the Chicago style.
Took over an hour to get a 9 inch pizza. Server took out order, then didn't check on us until food came, the didn't check on us after food came.
Had an amazing first experience at Wiseguys Pizzeria. Addison was our server and she made us feel so welcome! Food delicious with a wide selection of gluten free options for myself and low carb options for my wife. This is definitely our new date night spot!
We've driven past this place so many times and finally decided to give it a try. Atmosphere was outstanding along with the service. The drink selection was good and the food was incredible. If your looking fir a nice cozy pizza place, this is the place to go. We will definitely return.
My wife had Gluten Free Pizza and said it was the best in town. My kid and got the stuffed deep dish, it was fantastic!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
One of the best kept secrets in the valley. This pizza is hands down some of the best I've ever had. I worked here for a very brief time in high school and I remember seeing everything being made fresh in the kitchen and over 10 years later I can tell nothings changed. The crust, the cheese, the sauce, it's all so delicious. I HIGHLY recommend getting the zesty sauce if you don't mind a little kick, i promise it'll be the most flavorful pizza sauce you've ever had. The pepperoni tastes freshly sliced and not like the cheap overly processed crap and same with the sausage. The owners Mike & Brenda are amazing people and I'm so glad this place is still here all these years later. Our server was great too. I absolutely love the atmosphere too- it's very classy and intimate. Absolutely love this place and I'll gladly keep making the trip from Green Bay.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sauce, Garlic Bread, Pepperoni Pizza, Mozzarella Sticks
Nice atmosphere. Friendly waitress. Average service at best. We waited almost an hour for our food and the place wasn’t that busy. Food was t good enough to wait that long for it. Again, average at best. We had higher hopes. We will try one more time.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 3
Great food. Great vibe! We'll be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bruschetta
Restaurantji Recommends
Excellent!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sauce, Pepperoni Pizza
Pizza exceeded my expectations! Service, atmosphere and drinks were very good too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The deep dish pizza was great. Our server was excellent.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hawaiian Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza
I just wanted to say thank you for all the meals I've had over the past several years with my religious historian friend Chester. Unfortunately our friend has died. We always loved going into Wiseguys and getting a beer and pizza together. He was a good friend and will be missed. Thank you for having the best place to eat to have friends with. Great staff, great service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is my favorite pizza in Appleton. The food is always delicious. Some of the servers are better than others. The garlic flapper pizza is great. Drinks are kinda pricey.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Loading...