Good Fellas Tavern

109 S State St, Argyle
(608) 543-3606

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Fried Cheesecurds & Greenbeans
Shaved Prime Rib Sandwich
Pizza of the Month
Homemade Chips
Chicken Wings
French Dip
Fish Fry
Reuben
Fries

Menu

Warm Ups
Chicken Strips
Breaded tender and juicy strips served with choice of sauce.
French Fries
Deliciously golden brown.
Deep-Fried Green Beans
Lightly battered beans served with a house-made chipotle dip.
Cheese Curds
Sour Cream and Chive Fries
Seasoned fries served with ranch.
Sweet Potato Ridges
Crunchy outside seasoned to perfection with a tender inside served with ranch.
Homemade Chips
Hand seasoned and perfectly crispy served with house sauce.
Homemade Mozzarella Sticks
Mozzarella cheese hand wrapped in an egg roll wrapper, fried perfection, and served with marinara.
Tarter Tots
Crunchy outside and fluffy inside.
Boneless Beer Battered Wings
Try them tossed in ranch, BBQ, sweet Vidalia onion, parmesan garlic, sweet chili, or buffalo sauce.

Best Burgers Around
Bacon Cheeseburger
Served with three slices of bacon. All of our 1/2 lb burgers are fresh, never frozen ground beef served on a toasted ciabatta bun with pickles. All burgers are cooked medium to medium-well.
Hamburger
Our traditional burger. All of our 1/2 lb burgers are fresh, never frozen ground beef served on a toasted ciabatta bun with pickles. All burgers cooked medium to medium-well.
Cheeseburger
Your choice of American, cheddar, swiss, or pepper jack. All of our 1/2 lb burgers are fresh, never frozen ground beef served on a toasted ciabatta bun with pickles. All burgers cooked medium to medium-well.
Enfuego Burger
Pepper jack cheese and pickled jalapenos drizzled with homemade chipotle ranch. All of our 1/2 lb burgers are fresh, never frozen ground beef served on a toasted ciabatta bun with pickles. All burgers cooked medium to medium-well.
Mushroom Swiss Burger
Grilled fresh mushrooms and swiss cheese. All of our 1/2 lb burgers are fresh, never frozen ground beef served on a toasted ciabatta bun with pickles. All burgers cooked medium to medium-well.
The Big Fella Burger
Our signature burger is served with bacon, cheese, lettuce, tomato, onions, pickles, and house sauce. All of our 1/2 lb burgers are fresh, never frozen ground beef served on a toasted ciabatta bun with pickles. All burgers cooked medium to medium-well.

Reality Picks
Grilled Chicken Strips
Unbreaded, lightly seasoned strips of all white chicken served with choice of sauce.
Shrimp Skewers
Two skewers of five shrimp each grilled in a buttery scampi sauce.

Homemade Pizza
Wise Guy Pizza
Fresh mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black and green olives. Made with fresh ingredients.
Cheese Sticks Pizza
12 inches of delicious oven-baked breadsticks smothered in cheese, served with marinara and garlic butter. Made with fresh ingredients.
Cheese Pizza
Perfectly melted mozzarella cheese. Made with fresh ingredients.
Godfather Pizza
Sausage and pepperoni. Made with fresh ingredients.
Big Island Pizza
Traditional Hawaiian pizza with pineapple and Canadian bacon. Made with fresh ingredients. Made with fresh ingredients.
Boss Pizza
Pepperoni, sausage, and Canadian bacon. Made with fresh ingredients.
Italian Pizza
Sausage and mushrooms. Made with fresh ingredients.
Kingpin Pizza
Pepperoni, bacon, sausage, and Canadian bacon. Made with fresh ingredients.
Soprano Pizza
Pepperoni, sausage, Canadian bacon, fresh mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black and green olives. Made with fresh ingredients.

Fish Fry

Fried Cod Fish Fry

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: nextdoor
Photo credit: nextdoor
+10 photos
Photo credit: google
+9 photos
Add a photo

Order Online

Recent Reviews

We stopped into Good Fellas Pub on our way home from a wrestling tournament with two very hungry kids. Even though it was just before the kitchen was closing, Hailey gladly took our order and made us feel so welcome. Once we arrived, she gave us the best service—we truly appreciated her kindness and attentiveness. The pizza was absolutely delicious and hit the spot after a long day. We’re so glad we found this place and will definitely be returning. Highly recommend
July 2025
Our group of seven had an awesome lunch. The smoked brisket was outstanding and my wife said her grill chicken was one of the best she has had. My bloody Mary with the locally made vodka was also one of the best I've had. We will definitely be back here again!
May 2025
Excellent little pub. I've eaten here twice and the food is far superior than typical, and great selection of sandwiches including brisket and prime rib. Always seems to be busy (which is a good sign) and relaxed vibe. There is a back room with slot machines and a few more tables.
February 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Central 52 - 300 E Milwaukee St
Pizza, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Juice Bar & Smoothies
Corner Pub & Deli - 213 E Milwaukee St
Bar & Grill, Pubs
Sportz page - 205 E Milwaukee St
Bar, American, Sports Bar

Good Fellas Tavern

109 S State St, Argyle, WI 53504
(608) 543-3606