Great local place to hang out. Food is good, and they just started making fresh pizzas.
Darien Dwars
Best bar tender goes to Brady nice n speedy
Dominick Rodriguez
Awesome place! Coming from the chicago area, this place felt like home when it comes to people and general feel. It's a little small but definitely enough room for the crowd. Tenders are awesome people! Pool table is tucked in the back, so it's easy to play on without people getting in the way. Solid ass place to go and chill
Jodi Olson
We stopped in for a few drinks and had a pizza. The pizzas are decent, very thin crust. The restroom was very clean. There was a band playing and it was a bit loud, but made the bar lively.
Shane Hughes
Friendly staff. Great burgers.
Olivia Webster
Disappointing dining experience. Our server seemed a bit off and kept an unusual distance from the table, making it hard to hear him. I had a couple very simple requests with my order that weren’t followed, and my glass sat empty for most of the meal, was never asked if I wanted more to drink. Food was dropped off by the cook, not the server, and no one checked in to see how things were. The portion of fries was shockingly small for the price. Overall, not worth the visit. Won’t be returning. :(
Jenna Hayes
Stopped in this afternoon for lunch after shopping on the square, the bar was busy and full of great energy from staff. Our burgers and appetizers were SO good and the bartenders were attentive our whole experience.
Pat Holzem
Favorite place in baraboo!
mark endres
Went for a burger and was totally disappointed!
JA L
It's as ud want a great local gritty bar & burger joint to be!
I took on the 2025 Wisconsin Beef Counsel Best Burgers in the state of Wisconsin. There were eight places nominated for the best burger. I hit my last stop at, the Iron Horse, in Hurley Wisconsin. The other stops were; Straight Home from Elland , Brothers on Oak in Baraboo , The Dump in Cambria, Minn's in Menasha, Burgers and Beignets in Fond du Lac, Local Press Burger Bar Kewaskum and 11:11 brazenhead Pub West Bend. My criteria that I use to judge were: size of the burger, bun, prepared as orderd presentation, flavor, business ambience, and price. Here we go in order from worst to First. They fell into definite categories. There were three that were horrible or why were they listed! Then the, pretty good but left room for improvement. And the top three that were excellent and hired to choose from.
#1 Place Brothers on Oak Their third pound burger with fries and soda will set you back the lowest of the eight restaurants at a price of $13. Brothers on Oak scored perfect on everything. As mentioned it was a third pound burger served on a local bakery bun. The bakery is just across the alley, baked fresh everyday. The burger was served fresh and juicy and the fries were the best of the bunch as well! They were hot and crispy to bite into. In the area of ambience this would be the top. You can sit and enjoy your meal plus, there is an area with your pool tables, jukeboxes, DJ stand and dance floor. Congrats
Bruce Gibson
Stopped in after hearing their burgers are one of the top 8 in the state of Wisconsin. Was really disappointed. There was only one person waiting on the bar patrons as well as cooking food. It took a long time to get a drink. The burger was okay and fries were average. My wife ordered a fajita pita but the waiter was not sure how to make it since she had not made one in a long time. The Fajita Pita came out alright but it was the lack of help that made us feel like we were imposing on the waiter. She was rushing around getting drinks, taking orders, cooking, and whatever else. Two other workers came in early but made no effort to help her until exactly 5:00 pm, their starting time I assume. We probably will never go back.
Steven Bowden
Very good food
Selena Seibert
We love everything about Brothers! I cannot remember, for the life of me, my go to sandwich...(the permitheus...? It's a gyro with their amazing fresca sauce) but It's so good! They're the first place in the area to bring back breakfast combo bars! The staff is so much fun and I love to watch them market their featured food. They will let customers try out their upcoming featured mini beers and so forth. It's one of our favorite go-to's for lunch!
Cory Warneke
Good food at a fair price. Fast friendly staff and sports on the TVs. What more could you ask for?
Great local place to hang out. Food is good, and they just started making fresh pizzas.
Best bar tender goes to Brady nice n speedy
Awesome place! Coming from the chicago area, this place felt like home when it comes to people and general feel. It's a little small but definitely enough room for the crowd. Tenders are awesome people! Pool table is tucked in the back, so it's easy to play on without people getting in the way. Solid ass place to go and chill
We stopped in for a few drinks and had a pizza. The pizzas are decent, very thin crust. The restroom was very clean. There was a band playing and it was a bit loud, but made the bar lively.
Friendly staff. Great burgers.
Disappointing dining experience. Our server seemed a bit off and kept an unusual distance from the table, making it hard to hear him. I had a couple very simple requests with my order that weren’t followed, and my glass sat empty for most of the meal, was never asked if I wanted more to drink. Food was dropped off by the cook, not the server, and no one checked in to see how things were. The portion of fries was shockingly small for the price. Overall, not worth the visit. Won’t be returning. :(
Stopped in this afternoon for lunch after shopping on the square, the bar was busy and full of great energy from staff. Our burgers and appetizers were SO good and the bartenders were attentive our whole experience.
Favorite place in baraboo!
Went for a burger and was totally disappointed!
It's as ud want a great local gritty bar & burger joint to be!
Restaurantji Recommends
I took on the 2025 Wisconsin Beef Counsel Best Burgers in the state of Wisconsin. There were eight places nominated for the best burger. I hit my last stop at, the Iron Horse, in Hurley Wisconsin. The other stops were; Straight Home from Elland , Brothers on Oak in Baraboo , The Dump in Cambria, Minn's in Menasha, Burgers and Beignets in Fond du Lac, Local Press Burger Bar Kewaskum and 11:11 brazenhead Pub West Bend.
My criteria that I use to judge were: size of the burger, bun, prepared as orderd presentation, flavor, business ambience, and price. Here we go in order from worst to First. They fell into definite categories. There were three that were horrible or why were they listed! Then the, pretty good but left room for improvement. And the top three that were excellent and hired to choose from.
#1 Place
Brothers on Oak
Their third pound burger with fries and soda will set you back the lowest of the eight restaurants at a price of $13. Brothers on Oak scored perfect on everything. As mentioned it was a third pound burger served on a local bakery bun. The bakery is just across the alley, baked fresh everyday. The burger was served fresh and juicy and the fries were the best of the bunch as well! They were hot and crispy to bite into. In the area of ambience this would be the top. You can sit and enjoy your meal plus, there is an area with your pool tables, jukeboxes, DJ stand and dance floor.
Congrats
Stopped in after hearing their burgers are one of the top 8 in the state of Wisconsin. Was really disappointed. There was only one person waiting on the bar patrons as well as cooking food. It took a long time to get a drink. The burger was okay and fries were average. My wife ordered a fajita pita but the waiter was not sure how to make it since she had not made one in a long time. The Fajita Pita came out alright but it was the lack of help that made us feel like we were imposing on the waiter. She was rushing around getting drinks, taking orders, cooking, and whatever else. Two other workers came in early but made no effort to help her until exactly 5:00 pm, their starting time I assume. We probably will never go back.
Very good food
We love everything about Brothers! I cannot remember, for the life of me, my go to sandwich...(the permitheus...? It's a gyro with their amazing fresca sauce) but It's so good! They're the first place in the area to bring back breakfast combo bars! The staff is so much fun and I love to watch them market their featured food. They will let customers try out their upcoming featured mini beers and so forth. It's one of our favorite go-to's for lunch!
Good food at a fair price. Fast friendly staff and sports on the TVs. What more could you ask for?
Loading...