Jimmy John's

844 8th Ave Ste D, Baraboo
(608) 690-5686

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Scott Wales

Only place to get a lettuce wrap un-wich that's keto.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jessica Miller

I couldn't take a picture because it was too gross to share, but there was like 4 black, curly hairs in my sub.. I don't know if I ate anymore, but I was so grossed out, I almost threw up. Also, I ordered it with the french onions on it, and it was loaded, too full with them, along with the horseradish sauce I added. I don't think I will be going back there anytime soon, and this was actually my 2nd visit this week alone. Kind of a regular there. I will go elsewhere from now on. Disgusted with the sub, and I think I made someone pissed by adding those extras to the sub. It actually was ruined.

Atmosphere: 2

Service: 1

Becky Blessinger

I ordered delivery from Jimmy John's in Baraboo and wanted it delivered to the hotel. It wasn't delivered to my door. I heard the delivery driver was eating my meal when I called to question them about it. This is unacceptable! I won't go here or ask for a delivery ever again.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Kyle Weis

Great sandwiches, of course. Loses 1 star because of a small gripe: My pickle is never cut the way I want it. Also, most times I get carry out, so the cleanliness of the store is a non-issue, but it is often a little dirty (just like, leftover crumbs on tables, nothing obscene).

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Susan G

Good sandwiches

Andrea Jones

Freaky fast?? More like freaky slow!!

Victoria Hiller

Love their sandwiches and go about once a week. Staff is always friendly. They also have an app where you can build up to free food

Mike Campbell

They were really fast and it was good tasting.

Heather Plemmons

Had a delivery order. Just a Italian sub meal took over an hour literally ordered at 6:38 arrived after 7:40. They say they were busy but that's ridiculous of course my sub was soggy. No straw for my fountain drink and the "fresh" cookie is packaged. I called and was told my order was 4 of 7 the driver had. I feel sorry for the 7th. My sister's pizza hut came in 1/2 the time. I only live 4 minutes away I could have walked there in the over 1/2 hour delivery time.

Food: 2

Service: 2

R Schindler

2 yrs ago, my family went to Jimmy John's for subs. Each one of us got sick. Coronavirus. Somebody didn't wash their hands or was infected that worked there at that time. Have never gone back. If you're going to handle food, be clean. 2 days later we were driving to Mpls to catch a plane to Fla. It didn't happen. No refund from airlines. Do you know what it's like to be coming from both ends in a hotel room with only one bathroom.

Payton Legner

I always come and get a fresh loaf of bread for my son and they told me oh can’t do it we don’t have enough bread to do it! So yup never coming back! I’m a paying customer!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 1

Scott

Eat here if you want food poisoning.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

Melissa Tijerina

I never really write reviews, and dislike having to write a negative review. I ordered online and checked my receipt to make sure I ordered correctly. I order the beach club, which highlights avacado spread as it's selling point. I added bacon to my order as well. I was really sad to see that when my wrap arrived it had no avacado OR bacon, which is an added expense. The manager on duty credited my account and remade my wrap. He even delivered it; off duty to my out of area home. Which is super amazing! But, the new wrap still hanging NO avacado! I'm so disappointed.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Ron Berg

Nice restaurant blocked by construction but still open

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lindsey Miller

We placed an order while visiting for a gymnastics meet. I just received a call from manager Carly apologizing for the delay and offering a credit for the inconvenience. Wow! I honestly didn’t even think it was taking too long? Just assumed 30-45min was normal for a delivery. Either way, the communication and customer service was excellent!!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...