We had a larger group with kids everything was great Giro‘s taco salads pizzas burgers everything was good. Clam chowder was excellent
Grace Howard
Sorry to hear they are closing (COVID, etc.) because we enjoyed our meal. The sweet potato fries were great with the side tarragon mayo and the local whitefish was delicious both on my sandwich and my companion's salad.
Landon Nelson
Nothing to write home about. Pretty quick take out service, and the food was decent. I guess I was just expecting more based on the reviews. We had a better food experience at the Manypenny Bistro down the road. I’m sure during non COVID times they’re a lot better, but for the money I enjoyed the Bistro more. I might try this place again if I ever return to Bayfield.
Bonnie MacSwain
I had been at this restaurant previously and really liked it, but not this time. Now they have takeout only due to covid. Ordered for takeout and was told it would be ready in 15 minutes. I stood outside next to the sign that said pickup takeout orders here for 20 minutes while three employees saw me waiting there. I finally went in after calling and not getting an answer on the phone. My food was there waiting and cold. No offer to warm it up but they did take down the sign outside that said pickup orders here with an arrow.
Jrmmb
A favorite with locals and visitors offering a safe and eclectic setting. Good service, food and drink reasonably priced.
P9873EIjimb
convenient parking..OR a short hike on the Brownstone Trail from the Seagull Bay th Motel. Can be busy during the Summer tourist Season...but any wait is worth the time. During the Pandemic all precautions were observed.
Kay Christensen
Great food and it was perfect to have picnic tables outside to enjoy the take out
Flyer62932656209
The meals we had at Maggie's were great even though we didn't get to enjoy the funky atmosphere of the dining room because of concerns with covid. The Warm Sicilian pasta with chicken was superb; the chicken so tender, the pasta flavors bright and perfectly seasoned with tomatoes, basil, feta, red onions, and olives. The fries, served with creamy tarragon sauce and the flamingo tenders were great. The salads large and full of assorted other veggies. The service was extremely gracious and professional ..Minimal packaging, paper containers and no styrofoam. We were here for two days and ate there both days. We'll be back.
Mark Oliver
Stopped in today (9-26-20) and saw they had a great outdoor setup for this Covid world. Food was still AMAZING. food is always amazing! Can’t wait to come back
Stefano Peralma
Staff was nice but we felt rushed at times. The place looks cool with many decorations. Very good cheese curds. The tomato bisque and the chili was also very good. The brie and chicken and Greek salad flat bread were good but the margherita flat bread had a ton of unnecessary garlic. The burger didn't taste very good so maybe stick to the flat breads and fish tacos which looked good on the table next to ours.
Good meal. Nothing crazy amazing. My burger was overcooked for sure but the serving sizes were good and drinks were tasty. Service was quick too.
Sarah
We got takeout here while vacationing in Bayfield County during the pandemic. We got the whitefish sandwiches, and they were decent. The fish tasted good, but everything else about the sandwich was just ok. The chips that came with it were very good though. We also ordered onion rings because the sauce on the menu sounded good, but we were disappointed to find that the sauce was missing when we opened the takeout box. We appreciated that all employees inside the restaurant were wearing masks, and we liked that that they still offered a takeout option.
Mike Meegan
Not a good experience here and think it will be are last and only visit. Food was nasty and cold. Drinks didnt even taste good.
MartyScatterday
Fun and funky place. Had a nice lunch of yummy fish tacos. Wish they had some bbq on the lunch menu.
maryrose1122
Good food and an interesting selection. I had a whitefish reubin sandwich...SO good! You can dine in, wear a mask til you get to a table. Order at a window for pick up. I ate outside under their “bigtop” tent across the street. Reasonably priced. $$.
We had a larger group with kids everything was great Giro‘s taco salads pizzas burgers everything was good. Clam chowder was excellent
Sorry to hear they are closing (COVID, etc.) because we enjoyed our meal. The sweet potato fries were great with the side tarragon mayo and the local whitefish was delicious both on my sandwich and my companion's salad.
Nothing to write home about. Pretty quick take out service, and the food was decent. I guess I was just expecting more based on the reviews. We had a better food experience at the Manypenny Bistro down the road. I’m sure during non COVID times they’re a lot better, but for the money I enjoyed the Bistro more. I might try this place again if I ever return to Bayfield.
I had been at this restaurant previously and really liked it, but not this time. Now they have takeout only due to covid. Ordered for takeout and was told it would be ready in 15 minutes. I stood outside next to the sign that said pickup takeout orders here for 20 minutes while three employees saw me waiting there. I finally went in after calling and not getting an answer on the phone. My food was there waiting and cold. No offer to warm it up but they did take down the sign outside that said pickup orders here with an arrow.
A favorite with locals and visitors offering a safe and eclectic setting. Good service, food and drink reasonably priced.
convenient parking..OR a short hike on the Brownstone Trail from the Seagull Bay th Motel. Can be busy during the Summer tourist Season...but any wait is worth the time. During the Pandemic all precautions were observed.
Great food and it was perfect to have picnic tables outside to enjoy the take out
The meals we had at Maggie's were great even though we didn't get to enjoy the funky atmosphere of the dining room because of concerns with covid. The Warm Sicilian pasta with chicken was superb; the chicken so tender, the pasta flavors bright and perfectly seasoned with tomatoes, basil, feta, red onions, and olives. The fries, served with creamy tarragon sauce and the flamingo tenders were great. The salads large and full of assorted other veggies. The service was extremely gracious and professional ..Minimal packaging, paper containers and no styrofoam. We were here for two days and ate there both days. We'll be back.
Stopped in today (9-26-20) and saw they had a great outdoor setup for this Covid world. Food was still AMAZING. food is always amazing! Can’t wait to come back
Staff was nice but we felt rushed at times. The place looks cool with many decorations. Very good cheese curds. The tomato bisque and the chili was also very good. The brie and chicken and Greek salad flat bread were good but the margherita flat bread had a ton of unnecessary garlic. The burger didn't taste very good so maybe stick to the flat breads and fish tacos which looked good on the table next to ours.
Restaurantji Recommends
Good meal. Nothing crazy amazing. My burger was overcooked for sure but the serving sizes were good and drinks were tasty. Service was quick too.
We got takeout here while vacationing in Bayfield County during the pandemic. We got the whitefish sandwiches, and they were decent. The fish tasted good, but everything else about the sandwich was just ok. The chips that came with it were very good though. We also ordered onion rings because the sauce on the menu sounded good, but we were disappointed to find that the sauce was missing when we opened the takeout box. We appreciated that all employees inside the restaurant were wearing masks, and we liked that that they still offered a takeout option.
Not a good experience here and think it will be are last and only visit. Food was nasty and cold. Drinks didnt even taste good.
Fun and funky place. Had a nice lunch of yummy fish tacos. Wish they had some bbq on the lunch menu.
Good food and an interesting selection. I had a whitefish reubin sandwich...SO good! You can dine in, wear a mask til you get to a table. Order at a window for pick up. I ate outside under their “bigtop” tent across the street. Reasonably priced. $$.
Loading...