The Pickled Herring
1 Rittenhouse Ave, Bayfield
(715) 779-3330
Customers' Favorites
Cheese Curds in Wisconsin
Sweet Potato Wedges
Wisconsin Poutine
Trout and Salmon
Fish and Fries
Fish and Chips
Chicken Tenders
Homemade Chips
Apple Crisp
Fish Fry
Menu
Photos
+34 photos
+33 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
1st time here & it didn’t disappoint! We split the beef nachos as an appetizer - they were AMAZING and could have been a meal in itself! I had the Cavatapi Shrimp Alfredo - the shrimp were very large (which I think wasn’t expecting) & deliciously seasoned. My husband had the Ribeye steak. He said it was very good and really enjoyed the seasoned green beans. Thanks for a great experience, we’ll be back when you reopen next season!
Ate at the bar so we could watch a Packer game while we ate. Bartender/server was personable and friendly.
Vegetarian options: Friend with me ordered the veggie burger. Had to send it back as it was heated through. Otherwise said it was good.
Vegetarian options: Friend with me ordered the veggie burger. Had to send it back as it was heated through. Otherwise said it was good.
What would have been 1 STAR turned into a 5. We arrived on Friday evening of Apple Fest. We had read online that they had a dog friendly porch. There were tables out on the porch that were taken, some tables empty. My husband asked could we arrange to have a table on the porch because we had our pups with. The young man with a beard said “no the deck is closed” (yet there were people on the deck and it was only around 7pm) “we don’t serve out there”. My husband said,...
You May Also Like
Pier Plaza Restaurant - 1 Rittenhouse Ave
![]()
American, Bar, Seafood, Pet Friendly
The Deck - 20 Rittenhouse Ave
![]()
Bar, Pet Friendly