The Pickled Herring
1 Rittenhouse Ave, Bayfield
(715) 779-3330
Customers' Favorites
Cheese Curds in Wisconsin
Sweet Potato Wedges
Wisconsin Poutine
Trout and Salmon
Fish and Fries
Fish and Chips
Chicken Tenders
Homemade Chips
Apple Crisp
Fish Fry
Menu
Photos
+34 photos
+33 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
This is a fantastic spot for dinner and drinks. If you have a herring lover in your midst, this is a must: theirs is locally caught and made in house. The smoked trout dip was also out of this world, and the salmon salad with green goddess dressing was 12/10 stars. Plus great cocktails, and they have the local Apfelhaus cider (sadly not on tap but still good). Nice to find a good Hugo spritz in northern WI of all places!
We had a nice dinner at The Pickled Herring. Service was good, and even though we had to wait a short time for a table, it worked out perfectly—we grabbed drinks at the bar and stood at a little standing bar that kept us out of the way. My husband and I shared the fish fry, which was more than enough for the two of us, and we also split the onion rings with homemade blue cheese dressing (so good—definitely the highlight!). The fish fry itself was decent, though nothing to...
You May Also Like
Pier Plaza Restaurant - 1 Rittenhouse Ave
![]()
American, Bar, Seafood, Pet Friendly
The Deck - 20 Rittenhouse Ave
![]()
Bar, Pet Friendly
Farmhouse Kitchen and inn/ Yaabe’s Cafe - 858 Fort Rd
![]()
Coffee & Tea, American, Vegan, Motels
Seven people ate and all seven had different things and everyone LOVED it.
Toni was our server and she is so good that even the if the food was trash (absolutely delicious) we would still come back again. She is friendly, and knowledgeable.
We ate outside and what a perfect atmosphere and view.
Six starts for service and food.