I ordered the baked fish, which was absolutely delicious! It was flavorful, juicy, and cooked perfectly. Their fries even had good flavor and were cooked well. Their salad bar was pretty average for a salad bar but it was great that they had one. All the food at the salad bar looked fresh and tasted good. We ordered a mile-high grasshopper dessert, which was absolutely AMAZING, and they even brought out little bowls and spoons so all 6 of us could share it.
We made reservations so we didn't have any wait time to be seated. The service was fantastic - everyone was super polite and hospitable. Our waitress, Grace, was very attentive and sweet. We got our food very quickly (granted we were there pretty early). The owner even came out and went around and asked how everyone's dinner was which was a nice touch.
The price was pretty on point for the type of restaurant and food we ordered. Love that it's locally owned and operated. Super charming and nice place. Fancy enough to dress up but totally cool to not. Atmosphere was great.
Overall great experience and will definitely be going back!
Terry Kurzinski
One of Wisconsin better supper club. Went for fish fry ended up adding salad bar and au gratin potatoes. Sure am glad I did. Extra price was well worth it. Clam chowder was as good or better than back east . Tons of clams
Mark Weisensel
Fish was great but both the Grasshopper and Brandy Alexander were too much ice cream with little flavor for our group of 6. Trying to impress with the volume left it weak in flavor!
Cindie Bishop
Old school super club!
Brian Schlarb
Food was great, very friendly, loved it great chef.
Ali S.
I was really hoping that the new owner would elevate the dining experience to reflect the prices. Unfortunately, I as well as my whole party were disappointed. We had a large party for my parent's 30th anniversary, there were ten of us. We were seated and to say the area was cramped is an understatement. We could hardly move without rubbing elbows with our own party let alone several others. The tables were not level and every move sent the beverages rocking. The wait for beverages from the bar was, well, ridiculous. We went to the salad bar and they literally brought out piping HOT plates for salad.... who does that?? On to the entrees... we had a wide variety. Most of us recieved either our main OR our side but NOT ONE of us recieved them at the same time. I got my garlic mash but by the time my steak arrived it was stone cold. That being said the steak was fair, not great but not terrible. The prime rib my brother had was definitely less than satisfying and not cooked well, he had to request additional horseradish just to eat it. We continually ordered drinks but had to keep reminding the waitress to deliver them. My water was empty for at least half if the meal and I had to ask for more. We have dined here many times over the years and it's always been hit or miss, this time was clearly a miss. Unfortunate considering we spent nearly $400. I doubt we'll be back... it's a pity as I'd had high hopes with the new management.
0l blue c10
First time here soup salad bar was awesome love the flavor on my prime rib I'd definitely come back
Ann Mader
Had a wonderful time at Benedetti’s! Awesome bar tender, waitress and staff in general. A couple visits from the owner added to overall wonderful experience! Steaks were done to perfection. Salad bar had a nice selection of different options and the soup (clam chowder) was delicious! My husband had the cheesecake with blueberries and it was very good. The mile high ice cream drinks (saw one that everyone was sharing) was tempting but we were all too full! We all agreed that this is one supper club we need to come back to!
Laurice Hartzell
We had a wonderful meal as usual.
Amy Carey
I hadn't been to Benedetti's in years. I'm so glad we made the decision to revisit! The filet and orange roughy were to die for! And let's not forget the largest grasshopper I've ever seen. Great job Benedetti's. Jennifer, Nate and Jayme are top notch!
It's been years since we've eaten at Benedetti's, knowing it was under new ownership we wanted to give it a another try. We had some cocktails at the bar before dinner, they were delish! After having good conversation with the bartender, we decided to eat at the bar vs. going to a table. We are always looking for a good fish fry and decided on it as our entrees since Wednesdays they have fish fry. The calamari appetizer, was really good as were the entrees! Nice size portions too. We finished it off with brandy alexander to go.
If it's been a while since you've dined here, I strongly suggest you give it another go! We'll be back and with our friends :)
Nina Perona
It's been years since we've eaten at Benedetti's, knowing it was under new ownership we wanted to give it a another try. We had some cocktails at the bar before dinner, they were delish! After having good conversation with the bartender, we decided to eat at the bar vs. going to a table. We are always looking for a good fish fry and decided on it as our entrees since Wednesdays they have fish fry. The calamari appetizer, was really good as were the entrees! Nice size portions too. We finished it off with brandy alexander to go.
If it's been a while since you've dined here, I strongly suggest you give it another go! We'll be back and with our friends :)
Matthew Ahrens
Great dinner and kid friendly, staff amazing
Matt Muhlberger
Super friendly staff, excellent food, and a great atmosphere!! What else can you ask for on a Friday night out with the family in Wisconsin?
Chrissy Buonincontro
Are you looking for the nostalgic supper club? The one with an amazing salad bar and ice cream drinks.
Loved the salad bar and had a New York Strip, grilled to perfection.
Staff was attentive and friendly. Recommend the baked potato, it was the best one I’ve EVER had! Light and fluffy!
I ordered the baked fish, which was absolutely delicious! It was flavorful, juicy, and cooked perfectly. Their fries even had good flavor and were cooked well. Their salad bar was pretty average for a salad bar but it was great that they had one. All the food at the salad bar looked fresh and tasted good. We ordered a mile-high grasshopper dessert, which was absolutely AMAZING, and they even brought out little bowls and spoons so all 6 of us could share it. We made reservations so we didn't have any wait time to be seated. The service was fantastic - everyone was super polite and hospitable. Our waitress, Grace, was very attentive and sweet. We got our food very quickly (granted we were there pretty early). The owner even came out and went around and asked how everyone's dinner was which was a nice touch. The price was pretty on point for the type of restaurant and food we ordered. Love that it's locally owned and operated. Super charming and nice place. Fancy enough to dress up but totally cool to not. Atmosphere was great. Overall great experience and will definitely be going back!
One of Wisconsin better supper club. Went for fish fry ended up adding salad bar and au gratin potatoes. Sure am glad I did. Extra price was well worth it. Clam chowder was as good or better than back east . Tons of clams
Fish was great but both the Grasshopper and Brandy Alexander were too much ice cream with little flavor for our group of 6. Trying to impress with the volume left it weak in flavor!
Old school super club!
Food was great, very friendly, loved it great chef.
I was really hoping that the new owner would elevate the dining experience to reflect the prices. Unfortunately, I as well as my whole party were disappointed. We had a large party for my parent's 30th anniversary, there were ten of us. We were seated and to say the area was cramped is an understatement. We could hardly move without rubbing elbows with our own party let alone several others. The tables were not level and every move sent the beverages rocking. The wait for beverages from the bar was, well, ridiculous. We went to the salad bar and they literally brought out piping HOT plates for salad.... who does that?? On to the entrees... we had a wide variety. Most of us recieved either our main OR our side but NOT ONE of us recieved them at the same time. I got my garlic mash but by the time my steak arrived it was stone cold. That being said the steak was fair, not great but not terrible. The prime rib my brother had was definitely less than satisfying and not cooked well, he had to request additional horseradish just to eat it. We continually ordered drinks but had to keep reminding the waitress to deliver them. My water was empty for at least half if the meal and I had to ask for more. We have dined here many times over the years and it's always been hit or miss, this time was clearly a miss. Unfortunate considering we spent nearly $400. I doubt we'll be back... it's a pity as I'd had high hopes with the new management.
First time here soup salad bar was awesome love the flavor on my prime rib I'd definitely come back
Had a wonderful time at Benedetti’s! Awesome bar tender, waitress and staff in general. A couple visits from the owner added to overall wonderful experience! Steaks were done to perfection. Salad bar had a nice selection of different options and the soup (clam chowder) was delicious! My husband had the cheesecake with blueberries and it was very good. The mile high ice cream drinks (saw one that everyone was sharing) was tempting but we were all too full! We all agreed that this is one supper club we need to come back to!
We had a wonderful meal as usual.
I hadn't been to Benedetti's in years. I'm so glad we made the decision to revisit! The filet and orange roughy were to die for! And let's not forget the largest grasshopper I've ever seen. Great job Benedetti's. Jennifer, Nate and Jayme are top notch!
Restaurantji Recommends
It's been years since we've eaten at Benedetti's, knowing it was under new ownership we wanted to give it a another try. We had some cocktails at the bar before dinner, they were delish! After having good conversation with the bartender, we decided to eat at the bar vs. going to a table. We are always looking for a good fish fry and decided on it as our entrees since Wednesdays they have fish fry. The calamari appetizer, was really good as were the entrees! Nice size portions too. We finished it off with brandy alexander to go. If it's been a while since you've dined here, I strongly suggest you give it another go! We'll be back and with our friends :)
It's been years since we've eaten at Benedetti's, knowing it was under new ownership we wanted to give it a another try. We had some cocktails at the bar before dinner, they were delish! After having good conversation with the bartender, we decided to eat at the bar vs. going to a table. We are always looking for a good fish fry and decided on it as our entrees since Wednesdays they have fish fry. The calamari appetizer, was really good as were the entrees! Nice size portions too. We finished it off with brandy alexander to go.
If it's been a while since you've dined here, I strongly suggest you give it another go! We'll be back and with our friends :)
Great dinner and kid friendly, staff amazing
Super friendly staff, excellent food, and a great atmosphere!! What else can you ask for on a Friday night out with the family in Wisconsin?
Are you looking for the nostalgic supper club? The one with an amazing salad bar and ice cream drinks. Loved the salad bar and had a New York Strip, grilled to perfection. Staff was attentive and friendly. Recommend the baked potato, it was the best one I’ve EVER had! Light and fluffy!
Loading...