Service has always been wonderful. Bartender is attentive and makes a great bloody Mary. Everyone working is so fun.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salad Bar, Grasshopper Ice Cream Drink
Emmy Steines
Excellent food, great service, and the best Old Fashions around. Try one sour with blue cheese olives. Yum! Baked cod is delicious and while it's not listed on the menu you can order 1 piece.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kevin Maurer
Great supper club, excellent service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Steak, Brandy Alexander Ice Cream
Rusty Schoon
Good food, Bar was packed. Don't care to much to walk through a bunch of drunks after a filling meal. The layout of the place is off somehow.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: French Fries, Steak, Salad Bar
eric stauffacher
Definitely a must try if you haven't been here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Steak, Salad Bar
Kay Meinders
There were 4 of us celebrating an early Valentine's day and were absolutely thrilled with our dinners, drinks and outstanding service. It definitely was amazing!
Brent Erickson
Decided to give Benedetti's a try as it's been years since I have been there. Food was better than I remember. Service was great and portions seemed like it was 10 years ago. We will be going back soon.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: French Fries, Grasshopper Ice Cream Drink
Thomas Aaker
Had southern chicken. Chicken was bland, not seasoned well and dry. Broccoli was cold when served. Augraten potatoes seemed soupy and bland. Not like in times past.Tasted ravioli, which was very good. Loved the flavors.Broccoli soup was good and salad bar was maintained.Others had a variety from the menu and all enjoyed their meal. Which is why I rated at 4. Just feels that mine was done first and then sat.Servers were very attentive.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grasshopper Ice Cream Drink
Aaron Smith
This is a classic Wisconsin supper club that does everything right! The service is very good and the food is excellent! We drive over an hour from Illinois to come here. The prime rib on Saturday is excellent and they cook it to perfection every time. The ribs are great also. You must try the cheesy scalloped potatoes! The salad bar and soup is included with your meal. The salad bar is awesome and the soup is always homemade. They have a full bar also. Be sure to make reservations as it gets very busy. I can't recommend Benedetti's enough!
Servers are great. Food is bland. They don't know steak temps. No seasoning used on steak. If I wanted a bland steak no seasoning I would cook my own. It's nice to try different flavors each establishment can bring to their table. But bit here. Then the chef tells our very nice waitress to watch us check the 2nd steak to make sure it was correct temperature. Chef has a attitude as he's been doing it so long he can't do wrong. Don't act like you're chef Ramsey because the real chef Ramsey needs to pay this kitchen nightmare a visit.
Exceptional service. Patient while we perused the menu. There were a couple things missing from the menu we saw online. My orange roughly was moist and had wonderful flavor. My friend had the broiled cod special. She said it was wonderful. My husband's blackened walleye was a bit overcooked and the blackening seasoning was missing a little bite. The salad bar is small but has a nice variety of choices. The xmclam chowder was very tasty. We didn't have room for an ice cream drink, but I've both the mudslide and treasure chest in the past. Recommend both.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mudslide Ice Scream, Orange Roughy, Prime Rib and Au Gratin Potatoes
Summer Brown
Our visit to Benedetti’s Supper Club was a complete disappointment. Our party of 12 arrived before 5 pm without reservations, hoping to enjoy an early dinner. The hostesses, unfortunately, were the epitome of unwelcoming; their refusal to accommodate us, despite numerous open tables, left a sour taste from the start. We even suggested splitting our group into smaller tables to no avail.A kind fellow diner relinquished their table, offering it to us, and we ended up scattered across three tables. The hostility continued when the hostess showed displeasure as my 17-month-old walked from our table to his grandpa’s. To add to the frustration, one of our tables was rushed to finish and leave, citing the need for the table, only to find it unoccupied half an hour later. This unacceptable, they seated us and did not mention a “time limit” and they were only dining at the table for 30 minutes.The culinary experience mirrored the service—disappointing. The fish, American fries, French fries, and baked potato were all disappointingly bland, and the kids' Mac n cheese resembled a budget box of Kraft. As out-of-town visitors spending time with family, this experience was a low point, and we won't be returning. Treating patrons with respect seems to be a lesson lost on Benedetti’s Supper Club. Even after expressing our grievances to the manager, an apology was offered without any meaningful attempt to rectify the mistreatment of our group. A regrettable experience that left us with no desire to return.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Raymond Maderich
Probably one of theBest prime ribs EVERJUST INCREDIBLE
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Summer S.
Our visit to Benedetti's Supper Club was a complete disappointment. Our party of 12 arrived before 5 pm without reservations, hoping to enjoy an early dinner. The hostesses, unfortunately, were the epitome of unwelcoming; their refusal to accommodate us, despite numerous open tables, left a sour taste from the start. We even suggested splitting our group into smaller tables to no avail.A kind fellow diner relinquished their table, offering it to us, and we ended up scattered across three tables. The hostility continued when the hostess showed displeasure as my 17-month-old walked from our table to his grandpa's. To add to the frustration, one of our tables was rushed to finish and leave, citing the need for the table, only to find it unoccupied half an hour later. This unacceptable, they seated us and did not mention a "time limit" and they were only dining at the table for 30 minutes.The culinary experience mirrored the service--disappointing. The fish, American fries, French fries, and baked potato were all disappointingly bland, and the kids' Mac n cheese resembled a budget box of Kraft. As out-of-town visitors spending time with family, this experience was a low point, and we won't be returning. Treating patrons with respect seems to be a lesson lost on Benedetti's Supper Club. Even after expressing our grievances to the manager, an apology was offered without any meaningful attempt to rectify the mistreatment of our group. A regrettable experience that left us with no desire to return. All I really wanted was the grasshopper and after part of our group was rushed out I wasn't about to order anything more.
Michelle Jones
Terribly bland food. When you see that in other reviews, do not ignore it. We nicely said something to the waitress bc everything, ESPECIALLY the steaks, were so flavorless and each one (prime rib and filet mignon) were $40. She said it is it purposeful bc the general population they serve prefer blander tasting foods. The salad bar was ok but the au gratin potatoes were crunchy and very undercooked and had no flavor. The au jus was just brown water. Also I ordered initially prime rib (medium) and it came out grey/brown with absolutely no pink in sight. So they did let me substitute for a filet mignon since it was cooked so poorly which was nice but that was flavorless as well. Waitress was nice about all that but extremely slow. We had to wait 20 mins for refills, 10 mins for our check, another 10 mins for a box and she completely forgot bread until I said something. Sad part is we even serve ourselves the salad bar. And the bread btw? Meant to be like crispy Italian rolls. Two were good. The other 2 were hockey pucks that could've probably given someone a concussion had they been thrown at someone's head. Best thing I can say is the feel of the restaurant was nice and the iceberg lettuce was fresh. We eat at many different places. We are not picky, trust me. But this was the worst food we've gotten and the worst $100 we spent in several years. We will never ever be back, nor recommend this place. I was generous with 2 stars bc salad bar was decent, the atmosphere was nice and the waitress, although slow and forgetful, was nice.
Service has always been wonderful. Bartender is attentive and makes a great bloody Mary. Everyone working is so fun.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salad Bar, Grasshopper Ice Cream Drink
Excellent food, great service, and the best Old Fashions around. Try one sour with blue cheese olives. Yum! Baked cod is delicious and while it's not listed on the menu you can order 1 piece.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great supper club, excellent service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Steak, Brandy Alexander Ice Cream
Good food, Bar was packed. Don't care to much to walk through a bunch of drunks after a filling meal. The layout of the place is off somehow.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: French Fries, Steak, Salad Bar
Definitely a must try if you haven't been here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Steak, Salad Bar
There were 4 of us celebrating an early Valentine's day and were absolutely thrilled with our dinners, drinks and outstanding service. It definitely was amazing!
Decided to give Benedetti's a try as it's been years since I have been there. Food was better than I remember. Service was great and portions seemed like it was 10 years ago. We will be going back soon.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: French Fries, Grasshopper Ice Cream Drink
Had southern chicken. Chicken was bland, not seasoned well and dry. Broccoli was cold when served. Augraten potatoes seemed soupy and bland. Not like in times past.Tasted ravioli, which was very good. Loved the flavors.Broccoli soup was good and salad bar was maintained.Others had a variety from the menu and all enjoyed their meal. Which is why I rated at 4. Just feels that mine was done first and then sat.Servers were very attentive.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grasshopper Ice Cream Drink
This is a classic Wisconsin supper club that does everything right! The service is very good and the food is excellent! We drive over an hour from Illinois to come here. The prime rib on Saturday is excellent and they cook it to perfection every time. The ribs are great also. You must try the cheesy scalloped potatoes! The salad bar and soup is included with your meal. The salad bar is awesome and the soup is always homemade. They have a full bar also. Be sure to make reservations as it gets very busy. I can't recommend Benedetti's enough!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salad Bar, Soup & Salad, Steak, BBQ Pork Ribs, Chessesy Scallop Potatoes
Servers are great. Food is bland. They don't know steak temps. No seasoning used on steak. If I wanted a bland steak no seasoning I would cook my own. It's nice to try different flavors each establishment can bring to their table. But bit here. Then the chef tells our very nice waitress to watch us check the 2nd steak to make sure it was correct temperature. Chef has a attitude as he's been doing it so long he can't do wrong. Don't act like you're chef Ramsey because the real chef Ramsey needs to pay this kitchen nightmare a visit.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Exceptional service. Patient while we perused the menu. There were a couple things missing from the menu we saw online. My orange roughly was moist and had wonderful flavor. My friend had the broiled cod special. She said it was wonderful. My husband's blackened walleye was a bit overcooked and the blackening seasoning was missing a little bite. The salad bar is small but has a nice variety of choices. The xmclam chowder was very tasty. We didn't have room for an ice cream drink, but I've both the mudslide and treasure chest in the past. Recommend both.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mudslide Ice Scream, Orange Roughy, Prime Rib and Au Gratin Potatoes
Our visit to Benedetti’s Supper Club was a complete disappointment. Our party of 12 arrived before 5 pm without reservations, hoping to enjoy an early dinner. The hostesses, unfortunately, were the epitome of unwelcoming; their refusal to accommodate us, despite numerous open tables, left a sour taste from the start. We even suggested splitting our group into smaller tables to no avail.A kind fellow diner relinquished their table, offering it to us, and we ended up scattered across three tables. The hostility continued when the hostess showed displeasure as my 17-month-old walked from our table to his grandpa’s. To add to the frustration, one of our tables was rushed to finish and leave, citing the need for the table, only to find it unoccupied half an hour later. This unacceptable, they seated us and did not mention a “time limit” and they were only dining at the table for 30 minutes.The culinary experience mirrored the service—disappointing. The fish, American fries, French fries, and baked potato were all disappointingly bland, and the kids' Mac n cheese resembled a budget box of Kraft. As out-of-town visitors spending time with family, this experience was a low point, and we won't be returning. Treating patrons with respect seems to be a lesson lost on Benedetti’s Supper Club. Even after expressing our grievances to the manager, an apology was offered without any meaningful attempt to rectify the mistreatment of our group. A regrettable experience that left us with no desire to return.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Probably one of theBest prime ribs EVERJUST INCREDIBLE
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our visit to Benedetti's Supper Club was a complete disappointment. Our party of 12 arrived before 5 pm without reservations, hoping to enjoy an early dinner. The hostesses, unfortunately, were the epitome of unwelcoming; their refusal to accommodate us, despite numerous open tables, left a sour taste from the start. We even suggested splitting our group into smaller tables to no avail.A kind fellow diner relinquished their table, offering it to us, and we ended up scattered across three tables. The hostility continued when the hostess showed displeasure as my 17-month-old walked from our table to his grandpa's. To add to the frustration, one of our tables was rushed to finish and leave, citing the need for the table, only to find it unoccupied half an hour later. This unacceptable, they seated us and did not mention a "time limit" and they were only dining at the table for 30 minutes.The culinary experience mirrored the service--disappointing. The fish, American fries, French fries, and baked potato were all disappointingly bland, and the kids' Mac n cheese resembled a budget box of Kraft. As out-of-town visitors spending time with family, this experience was a low point, and we won't be returning. Treating patrons with respect seems to be a lesson lost on Benedetti's Supper Club. Even after expressing our grievances to the manager, an apology was offered without any meaningful attempt to rectify the mistreatment of our group. A regrettable experience that left us with no desire to return. All I really wanted was the grasshopper and after part of our group was rushed out I wasn't about to order anything more.
Terribly bland food. When you see that in other reviews, do not ignore it. We nicely said something to the waitress bc everything, ESPECIALLY the steaks, were so flavorless and each one (prime rib and filet mignon) were $40. She said it is it purposeful bc the general population they serve prefer blander tasting foods. The salad bar was ok but the au gratin potatoes were crunchy and very undercooked and had no flavor. The au jus was just brown water. Also I ordered initially prime rib (medium) and it came out grey/brown with absolutely no pink in sight. So they did let me substitute for a filet mignon since it was cooked so poorly which was nice but that was flavorless as well. Waitress was nice about all that but extremely slow. We had to wait 20 mins for refills, 10 mins for our check, another 10 mins for a box and she completely forgot bread until I said something. Sad part is we even serve ourselves the salad bar. And the bread btw? Meant to be like crispy Italian rolls. Two were good. The other 2 were hockey pucks that could've probably given someone a concussion had they been thrown at someone's head. Best thing I can say is the feel of the restaurant was nice and the iceberg lettuce was fresh. We eat at many different places. We are not picky, trust me. But this was the worst food we've gotten and the worst $100 we spent in several years. We will never ever be back, nor recommend this place. I was generous with 2 stars bc salad bar was decent, the atmosphere was nice and the waitress, although slow and forgetful, was nice.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 3