Pie Shack
133 W Huron St, Berlin
(920) 290-3020
Customers' Favorites
Malibu Wrap with French Fries
Bacon Cheeseburger and Fries
Scalloped Potatoes and Ham
Cobb Salad with Beet Eggs
Chocolate Chip Cream Pie
Chicken Tender Sandwhich
Chicken Pineapple Wrap
Strawberry Shortcake
Chocolate Cream Pie
Sweet Potato Fries
Menu
Photos
+21 photos
+20 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Driving through town never been here before and I saw THE PIE SHACK! Who wouldn't stop! Vintage atmosphere 👌🏽 and delicious pie 🥧 that's a win win! The lady with a tattoo arm sleeve (didn't get her name)(awesome tattoo btw) was super friendly! I got the peanut butter pie and its so good! Will definitely stop again if I am ever back through this town.
I've been driving 9 miles each way for breakfast at the pie shack for about 4 years now. We rent a lakeside cottage on Green Lake for a couple weeks at a time in late May and late August. She works on writing her current book and still sees clients on zoom, so I get to find a place with pancakes. I have high standards, so when I say that Jay makes the best and largest buttermilks I've enjoyed. High praise. Since that's what i eat here, I can only add that sll of...
Hubby and I split lunch here, a wrap and sweet potato fries, all very good. We each had a piece of pie, oh my, delicious!! I had the peanut butter, he had the cookie dough! They even topped them with whip cream and a drizzle of chocolate. So so good! Don't walk, run to this place for pie! Honestly the best peanut butter pie I've ever had! Staff was very sweet too!
