The Red Mill Inn & Pizza

Living in Florida it is always great when we return to Milwaukee area and can come for one of the best fish fry in the area. Walleye, pan fish and cod are always great.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Honestly, I don’t think I could high 5 a restaurant more! Dined in yesterday. Saturday at 6ish. It was very busy with a bustling bar. We only waited 20 minutes for a table. They were short staffed but you’d never know it. All of our servers were amazing and kind. Sasha was our main dude but the sweet gals were awesome as well. Our bartender Ross was super great, friendly and a pleasure. Chop salad was delicious, pizza was probably the best we’ve ever had. Thin, crispy and perfect. 100% can’t wait to go back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

It's been a long time since we were at this restaurant and boy have we been missing out. We started out with two old fashions muddled as they should be. Then we moved to our appetizer which was garlic bread with the marinara. The marinara was exceptional. Then we finished our dinner with beef stroganoff. Which hands down was one of the best I've ever had. All of that teamed with the service by two servers, Tina and Rosie. First of all, the recommendations on the meal and everything presented quick efficiently and with a super smile and great conversation.

I believe this will be one of our main haunts from this day forward. As I write this we are sharing some of the chocolateiest cake I've ever had. It's my personal preference that it's more dense but intense with chocolate flavor.

A+++

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great place love the vibe.

We went to The Red Mill in Brookfield last Sunday and had one of the worst dining experiences we’ve ever had. While we were there, we witnessed what looked like the manager (possibly the owner) screaming at a very young server who was clearly overwhelmed but working incredibly hard. She had nearly every table in the restaurant, and instead of helping her, he berated her in front of everyone, saying she wasn’t doing enough and should be seating tables and serving. She handled it as calmly as she could, even asking why he was yelling at her, and I’m pretty sure she quit before she walked out in tears.

Before she left, she said something that really caught our attention, about the restaurant not keeping up with health standards. That was honestly alarming. The food was mediocre at best, and the restaurant itself didn’t look particularly clean. The patio is nice, but after what we saw and heard, we won’t be coming back. We’re now genuinely concerned about what’s going on in that kitchen.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Happened by this place while heading to pick up a passenger. I looked them up and seemed like a place our group would enjoy so I booked it for last night. It's a bit loud, but it is bar and restaurant. Seemed to want to cram everyone into one dining room when there are multiple, which increased the noise.

Our server was great, when she was able to come to our table. They are not staffing appropriate servers which 1) made for very long waits between having her come to our table, but 2) was not her fault. She was friendly and accommodating, and tried her best given the understaffing.

The food we had was just delicious. In our group we ordered Chicken Parmesan Sandwich, Shrimp Alfredo Dinner, Beef Stroganoff, and I ordered the Mozzarella Won Tons and the Meatball Sandwich. Everyone thoroughly enjoyed their choices. High praise came for the house made alfredo, and the salads that came with the two dinners looked and (I'm told tasted) very fresh. The Won Tons were delicious. They both crispy and chewy, and they use mozzarella not as string cheese. The parmesan garlic butter was so good that you don't need sauce. I did have the marinara on some of them though and it was tasty. The Meatball sandwich had good flavor and just enough sauce so the sandwich wasn't dry, but not so much that it was messy to eat. It is served on a soft roll, making it easier to eat than when made on toasted bread. Don't get me wrong I love a good toasted roll, but it makes for messy eating of certain types of sandwiches. Because I ate all of the Won Tons I did take half my sandwich home. Dinner for tonight!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

My wife and I topped in for dinner this past Friday. The food and service were very good. I thought that the prices were very reasonable. They have a nice patio, and with such nice weather, we were sorry that we didn't eat there.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

My wife and I went on the recommendation of a good friend. The place was very busy but we got seated (and served) fairly quickly. The pizza choices are amazing. So many different combinations. We (as a group) had the Dill pickle & Peparoni, the Meat Meat Meat pizza and the Margarita pizza. All very very thin crust but very tasty. However my FAVORITE thing was the fried egg plant. Crispy, flakey batter (similar a bit to Tempera). By far the best I’ve ever eaten. The service was friendly and quick. Ample parking as well. The outside seating is a nice addition. We will be back. Sorry I didn’t take any pictures to show.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

The Red Mill is a favorite local haunt in the neighborhood (and for good reason) but this review is about how amazing they were in hosting our Son's rehearsal dinner with his to be beautiful Bride. Our kids had specifically requested the Red Mill Inn as their location of choice for their Rehearsal and Phil and his staff delivered an incredible experience that will not soon be forgotten. They let us bring in decor and made the planning SO EASY and their execution was FLAWLESS. We were a party of 36 on their patio and everything went PERFECTLY. They are ultra professional and super friendly and the food was out of this world! They are an easy recommendation for a Friday night dinner or a major celebration. Thank you Phil and staff for making our evening so magical! 💕

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The absolute BEST gluten free pizza! You brought me to tears! The pizza tasted just like “regular” pizza! Thank You!!

A Little historic 200 yr old establishment with a large menu for even the pickiest of eaters. Known for the hand tossed pizzas and great cocktails.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I am in town for work as I write this - and needed to find a good pizza place for dinner one night because it had been too long since I had pizza. I came here based on the review that someone left near midnight on July 4th. (It was not a good review and I had to see this place for myself!). This place is nestled in a neighborhood with easy-in parking and had a good vibe about it. What followed upon entering was a cheery greeting. This person was my server whose positive and upbeat attitude was refreshing for this weary traveler. I had the Magnifica pizza (aptly named!) and it was stellar. The crust was great, ingredients were awesome. I came from the Chicago burbs (but don't hold that against me) and was in my pizza-element. I now have a new place to visit EVERY time I'm in town for work.

Thanks for making my first visit as awesome as can be. Looking forward to visiting again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We had a wonderful experience here! The food was delicious but what really made our visit stand out was the service. We had a large group, and our waiter, Ross, went above and beyond to take care of us. He was attentive, friendly, and made sure everyone had exactly what they needed. It’s not easy handling a big table, but Ross did it with a smile. Highly recommend this place for both the food and the exceptional service!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We lost power at our house tonight and decided we wanted to try a new place for dinner while we waited for our power to be restored. We walked in a we were quickly seated for a family of 6! The service was wonderful and we really enjoyed the specialty pizza selection and premium crafted sodas! The pickle pepperoni pizza was amazing!!! We will definitely be back and hope to enjoy the lovely patio next time when it's not rainy out!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We’ve lived within a 5 minute drive for years and never tried this place. Pizza was amazing, we had the pepperoni pickle pizza and olive and sausage. My young kids loved it and so did my wife and I. This will be part of our normal rotation!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5