Mr. B's of Brookfield | A Bartolotta Steakhouse

We ordered a filet and the salmon. Both were excellent. It was our anniversary and we were very happy with the food, drinks and service.

Sadly, although I had reservations that indicated that this was a special occasion, we were seated at the table closest to the kitchen, essentially in a hallway that connected it and the bathrooms to the main dining room. A peek in the dining room revealed that nearly all of the tables there were designed for larger parties. I would not go there again as a party of two. Our first courses were good: a Strawberry Spinach salad and Loaded Seafood Bisque. For our entrees, my husband took the bone-in ribeye special which was very good, but I ordered a 8oz filet which was severely over cooked. I ordered medium rare but my steak had only a tinge of barely pinkish meat in the center. When the bill came, the manager had comped it, but the damage was done. Our options were to send it back and awkwardly eat in shifts, or to put up with it. We chose the latter. I do not recommend that you order an 8 oz there, as the waiter seemed unfazed and seemed to think that steaks that small were hard to cook to medium rare. Overall I found his service aloof and a bit condescending. He did not enhance our evening at all. I suspect he decided that he should direct his attention in towards the large tables in the pleasant dining room. He definitely was not trying to impress us.

Wonderful restaurant from start to finish. Excellent ambiance, wonderful service and wonderful food and cocktails. On the pricy side. We had a gift card. Highly recommend for a special night out.

This was our second time dining at Mr. B's and I can't say we'll be back. The cost simply does not match the experience. My husband and I ordered the porterhouse for two meal. Not only did it come out cold, but the cast iron skillet that it was to be served hot in was also cold. We notified our server who asked if they should try to reheat it which we declined as our steak was medium rare and we didn't want it overcooked. She told us she'd “see what she could get management to budge on” to compensate for the error. We were given two free deserts. While the gesture was kind, two desserts don't adequately compensate for a $140 meal. Our server was incredibly rushed the entire evening, not necessarily contributing to a comfortable atmosphere. We were also served wine that was previously corked so both the taste and visible pieces of cork floating in the glass didn't enhance our time. Given the cost for the experience we had (our bill before tip was over $250 for 2) we cant justify dining here again, especially since we drove 35 minutes for this date. If you're looking for a great steak and excellent service, there are plenty of better options in the lake country area.

Service was excellent,steaks were seasoned and cooked to perfection.signature cocktails were excellent (old fashion)

We went for our 23rd anniversary. As always the food was delicious. The only complaint I ever have is my steak always has pink when it's supposed to be well done. Lucy our waitress was attentive, professional, and excellent.

We've always considered Mr. B's our favorite steakhouse, but this visit was disappointing. My ribeye was overcooked and tough—unusual for a place with such a great reputation. With so many excellent steakhouses in Milwaukee, we may wait a while before returning. Hope to see the usual high standards next time.

Bartollata is an excellent restaurant chain. Mr. B's is a steakhouse that has the service and ambience that I enjoy most. Hence I am a frequent patron. Never been disappointed yet

Outdoor patio was nice. Steak was just ok. Second time dining here and same experience with the food. Very average and overpriced for the quality

Five ladies that came to celebrate some special birthdays...everything was wonderful from start to finish!! Food was hot and delicious...service was fantastic!! See you again! Cheryl Randall

The service was excellent. We had the filet which was prepared perfectly. I really enjoyed all the different sauces to choose from

As always fantastic food and the service is amazing as well. Always a great time with amazing food

The food was amazing, best steaks we’ve had! Staff was absolutely incredible, from the hostess, manager, to wait staff. Thank you for a highly enjoyable experience, we’ll be back!

Bartalotta’s Steakhouse in Brookfield was a great experience! We went out on a Friday night early with another couple around 5:30 p.m. because we had not planned it until that day. The food was delicious and the service wonderful. Although food has gotten so much more expensive over the past few years, we enjoyed our evening out thoroughly! The staff was very efficient and polite and we had some delicious entrees. I had salmon, my husband and one of our friends had a delicious steak sandwich, and the fourth person ordered something they loved. We ate it all and enjoyed every bite and moment. If you’re looking for a nice dining experience with professional waiters and a qualified chef, this is your place. Many thanks to the staff at Mr. B’s Steakhouse in Brookfield!

3 of us had the 12 oz filet which were excellent and our 4th had the salmon which was also very good. Service by our two waitstaff was exceptional and welcoming. A well paced meal enjoyed by all.