Antioch Pizza Shop - Burlington, WI

980 Milwaukee Ave Suite 200, Burlington
(262) 757-4992

Recent Reviews

Rick Drew

I can't believe they have so much here - Cannoli made to order, ice cream, pizza, sandwiches. Friendly staff. Tasty Italian beef sandwiches.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Italian Beef

JA

The staff is always nice. The food is always great. What more can I say.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Deep Dish Pizza, 12 Thin Crust, Hot Dog, Personal Cheese Pizza, Wings with Sauce on the Side

Jesse

I'm an idiot and ordered online to their Libertyville location.The Burlington location made the order and gave us free drinks while we waited.They refunded my card fir the Libertyville order and were absolutely top notch when it came to handling my stupid mistake.I'll be back as long as they're here.

Bifford Skinner

Quick and tasty, only needed more selection at lunchtime. Good price 2skices and a soda.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Italian Beef & Sausage Combo Special, Bacon Cheeseburger

K D

Terrible! This branch is just awful. Pizza always cold. So poorly run. Never going back.

Rev Psyko

Atmosphere would be 5 if there was music, Chicago style pizza is delicious and the sausage they use for their pizzas is top

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Deep Dish Pizza, Cheese and Sausage Pizza

Ralph Fugate

Great place. Friendly staff. Love the high tables.Parking: Open space.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: 1 lb Boneless Wings, Cheese and Sausage Pizza

Harry F.

Hi, I've had your delicious pizza before and had a neighbor pick it up for me. I just don't know why you don't do delivery. I have a disability that limits me from getting out. Most all other places offer delivery which is great! I really wish you would consider delivery cuz you have good food.I love good pizza!!! Sincerely, Harry...

Brian L.

I love the double-decker pizza. Great service and a well kept restaurant. It looks nice inside. We order from there often.

Michael

7:39 on a Thursday pizzas ordered. Go to poc up and locked up lights off. That btown for ya clost 40 min early. Wasnt the only oke standijg there as staff ignored us.Own several businesses in Burlington closijg manager - fired without question. I tread mh staff to several hundreds snd sometimes over a thousand a week. Owner should know what the last minutes of the light can be for the til.Aside from being spendy, always tipped $20's .They have lost our business for good.

Food: 4

Service: 1

Beth Heng

We ordered 3 LG thin crust pizzas ( a small cheese pizza was included per your special) for take out. Great service! Super clean & order was done on time. 1of the 3 large pizzas was amazing. The other 2 were unfortunately way overdone. I didn’t notice until I got home & opened everything up. The two I’m referring to were dried out, over cooked. Disappointed. The neighbors on both sides had recommended your place for great pizza. They were eating with us & said that hasn’t happened to them before. disappointed it happened with my order. *****************My husband gave Antioch pizza a second chance and I’m glad he did. This time we ordered wings and a large pan pizza (both for pick-up. Both were amazing. Great tasting not overdone and held up good for leftovers. Not sure what happened on our first visit, but we will return again after this last order.

Dirk G.

So I usually love this place. Literally the only place I order and have dumped a ton of money on pizza here. I called 20 minutes before they closed to grab a small pizza and was told , they're not selling anymore pizza tonight.... But they're still open. As you can imagine this is frustrating. Especially when you have kids that had their hearts set on this pizza. Not sure why they stay open until 7 if they don't sell anything for basically the last half hour??? Used to live this place but now not sure. I Am sure it's due to people only doin half of their jobs these days.. wonder if the owner l owns they're turning down money and customers during business hours. Amazing pizza. Confusing business handle. Guess I'll find somewhere that sells their product until the posted closing time. Not gonna fall for this twice

speter awaken

Went to Caseys gas station to get pizza & of course they were out of pizza for the 20th time going there, so my wife said let's try Antioch pizza, I was skeptical but went & the girl gave us the special 2 pizza slices and a drink for 6 DOLLARS, I was like for real & the girl working was like yep. I'm used to going to casey's & paying 8$ and some change for this . They had like 5 different kinds of pizzas in the warmer, WAAAAAY Better than casey's. If u gone to caseys & had the same results of no pizza as i do, COME TO ANTIOCH PIZZA, they will have pizza made for ya and a drink for 6$.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Laura B.

The pizza crust was soggy! It was the second time it happened. I went back to complain and the person argued with me that that's the way it comes out. Don't argue with the customer and change the way it is cooked. I won't go back.

YANA STERLING

Super cool lil find! I was on lunch break and just wanted to sit inside a nice cool place and not spend so much money. I found it! I ordered the lunch special, 2 slices of pizza and a drink for $6 bucks, you can't beat that!! Self serve drinks, plenty of room, very spacious and clean. The employees were so nice and very welcoming! Definitely stopping back for the ice cream!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Load More