Sassy Cow Creamery Store

W4192 Bristol Rd, Columbus
(608) 837-7766

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Grilled Cheese and Tomato Soup
Grilled Cheese and Chips
Potato Salad
Sandwich

Menu

Classic Grilled Cheese
The Original
Sassy cow cheddar. Includes side and white or chocolate milk.
Two Brothers Cheese
Sassy cow butterkase and muenster. Includes side and white or chocolate milk.
Triple Cheese
Sassy cow cheddar, havarti, and muenster. Includes side and white or chocolate milk.

Signature Grilled Cheese
Ham and Havarti
Sassy cow havarti with smoked applewood ham. Includes side and white or chocolate milk.
Chicken Fajita
Sassy cow butterkase with strips of chicken, roasted peppers, and onions. Includes side and white or chocolate milk.
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Sassy cow muenster with chicken, bacon, and ranch. Includes side and white or chocolate milk.
BBQ Pulled Pork
Sassy cow cheddar with hickory-smoked pulled pork smothered in BBQ sauce. Includes side and white or chocolate milk.
The Cubano
Cuban-style sassy cow havarti with pulled pork, ham, pickles, and yellow mustard. Includes side and white or chocolate milk.
Cheesesteak
Sassy cow muenster with sliced beef steak, roasted peppers, and onions. Includes side and white or chocolate milk.

Salads
Farmhouse Salad
Oven-roasted chicken breast with mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumber, cheddar, and croutons. Includes side and white or chocolate milk.
Fiesta Salad
Oven-roasted fajita chicken breast with mixed greens, tomatoes, cheddar, and tortilla strips. Includes side and white or chocolate milk.

Half Pint Sides
Original Grilled Cheese
Sassy cow cheddar. Includes side and white or chocolate milk.
Ham and Cheddar Grilled Cheese
Sassy cow cheddar with smoked apple wood ham. Includes side and white or chocolate milk.

Beverages
White Pint
Chocolate Pint
Bottled Water

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+46 photos
Photo credit: google
+45 photos
Add a photo

Order Online

Recent Reviews

Sassy Cow is always a challenge, which flavor to pick? Or worse yet, which 2 flavors best go together? Oreo cheesecake and triple chocolate? Black cherry and peach? Oh, the agony! Don't worry, they're all good! (The peach is one of my favorites) For a few bucks you can enjoy a couple for yourself! Some Sunday options are available as well. Bring a cooler and do some shopping for other Sassy Cow dairy products while you're here. The facility is very nice and they...
May 2025
Sandwiches, ice cream, cheese and more local products here. Everyone should support the US farmers and dairyman. This place has the best homemade flavors of ice cream and tasty milk. If you haven't tried their breakfast sandwich, you should!
April 2025
Caring staff and great people. Feels like home and has a great vibe. The perfect place for quality dairy for a grab and go.

They also have great sandwiches and of course ice cream.
March 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Pan-O-Gold Baking Co - 1000 Wilburn Rd
Bakery
Buck & Honey's - Sun Prairie - 804 Liberty Blvd
American, Bar, Burgers, New American, Vegan
Panda Garden - 922 Windsor St
Chinese, Seafood

Sassy Cow Creamery Store

W4192 Bristol Rd, Columbus, WI 53925
(608) 837-7766