9 Best Caterers near Cottage Grove

Stoddard's Meat Market & Catering Caterers • $$
205 East Cottage Grove Road, Cottage Grove

“Terry and Tami were great to work with! The food was delicious and had multiple compliments. Terry drove out to our site to ensure that our needs were met. The staff were very friendly and very kind! I highly recommend Stoddards!“

4.4 Superb142 Reviews
Doubledays Caterers • $
4586 Baxter Rd, Cottage Grove

“We had our 45th class reunion at Doubledays. It was fantastic!!!! Great location. Great service. Fantastic food & variety & you did not go hungry!! My vote is to have are 50th reunion there also.
Next up going to the fish fry on Fridays.
Check them out you will not be disappointed.
If I could give 10 stars ? I would.“

4.3 Superb106 Reviews
Upstairs Downstairs Catering Caterers •
1617 North Stoughton Road, Madison - 6.99 miles

“Upstairs Downstairs Catering did an amazing job at our wedding! We had appetizers, a buffet, desserts, coffee, and a late-night snack, and every single dish was incredible. The Tenderloin Roquefort was a huge hit, along with the Garlic Mashed Potatoes. We were definitely glad to have leftovers!

Saima was absolutely wonderful to work with. She was responsive, helpful, and had great insight throughout the entire planning process. She played a huge role in making our experience so positive.

The day-of-event servers/staff were efficient, helpful, and flexible. As soon as they arrived, they worked with me to finalize the details. They ensured the night was smooth and efficient!

The food was incredible, the staff was great, and everything came together perfectly. I’ll gladly recommend Upstairs Downstairs Catering to anyone looking for an amazing caterer!“

4.9 Superb98 Reviews
Halverson's Everything Nice Caterers • $$
1965 Barber Drive, Stoughton - 9.46 miles

“Wonderful job ladies!! Food was great, fun time. I appreciate all you did for us.“

5 Superb20 Reviews
Twisted Radish Catering Caterers • $$
1219 North Sherman Avenue, Madison - 7.06 miles

“I recently used Twisted Radish Catering for my wedding reception at the Frank Lloyd Wright Taliesin Visitor Center in Spring Green WI and they were absolutely fantastic! COMMUNICATION: I live out of state and thought it might be difficult to work remotely with a caterer, but Nicki made the whole experience easy and fun. I really felt like she took the time to make sure I was happy with everything and was always available to chat on the phone or quick to respond to my emails. GRAZING BOARDS + APPETIZERS: I was drawn to Twisted Radish by the photos on their website of their elaborate grazing boards (because appetizers are always one of my favorite parts of a wedding..), and it was so fun creating a delicious spread with Nicki's help. The end result was even better than I expected, she went out of her way to make sure everything was displayed beautifully and it all tasted amazing. DINNER: We did a plated dinner with three different main course options - Wedding Day Salmon, Herbed Tri Tip and Apple Cider Chicken. Each plate came with heirloom carrots with rosemary and orange, garlic broccoli with chili flakes, roasted fingerling potatoes, poached pear salad and sourdough dinner rolls. She even surprised us with butter boards for the rolls! Every dish tasted amazing, even better than I imagined. COFFEE AND DESSERT: Nicki set up a incredible coffee station complete with almond and oat milks in vintage carafes. I have a lot of coffee snobs in the family, and they all approved of the coffee. She also make us two homemade ice cream flavors (vanilla bean and blackberry) that were fantastic. STAFF: Everyone from Twisted Radish was so kind and extremely professional. You can tell they love what they do. I would 100% recommend Twisted Radish for any future events needing delicious and beautiful food. I feel extremely lucky they were available because I feel like we got the very best of the best!“

5 Superb10 Reviews
Cranberry Creek Catering Caterers • $$
1501 Lake Point Drive, Madison - 7.37 miles

“Cranberry Creek catered my daughter’s wedding reception yesterday. The food was delicious. The presentation and taste was a 10. The staff was very attentive. The owner was very accommodating and flexible to the changes as we moved along in the prep leading up to the actual day. Highly recommend Cranberry Creek for any event!“

4.6 Superb10 Reviews
Primal 'Cue Barbecue Joint and Catering Barbecue • $
836 Grove Street, Sun Prairie - 6.88 miles

Customers` Favorites

Smoked St Louis-Style Spareribs Half Rack
Smoked St Louis-Style Spareribs Full Rack
Pulled Pork Sandwich and Cheesy Potatoes
Corn Bread Muffins with Honey Butter
Traditional Sweet Barbecue Sauce
Sliced Smoked Beef Brisket
Smoked Chicken Leg Quarter
Pulled Pork and Tri Tip
Vinegar Barbecue Sauce
Smoked Chopped Chicken

“Outstanding spot! It’s in the local ice rink so don’t be surprised. Very original BBQ options but creatively awesome! The BBQ smash burger was incredible and my wife couldn’t stop raving about the bbq wrap. A true local hidden gem!“

4.8 Superb219 Reviews
PAPAs BBQ Barbecue • $
400 E Broadway, Monona - 6.29 miles

Customers` Favorites

Brisket Sandwich and French Fries
Cheese Burger and Fries
Chicken Wings
Cheeseburgers
Pork Ribs
Rib Tips

“Great food!! We loved the visit with the big guy himself! What a great personality and the best beans ever!!“

4.7 Superb140 Reviews
MACS (Macaroni And Cheese Shop) Sun Prairie Caterers • $
2804 Prairie Lakes Drive Unit 106, Sun Prairie - 7.19 miles

Customers` Favorites

Loaded Baked Potato Mac Only Mac Daddy Size
Philly Cheese Steak with Mac and Cheese
Chicken Bacon Ranch Mac N Cheese
Jalapeno Popper Mac and Cheese
Buffalo Chicken Mac Mac Daddy
Buffalo Mac and Cheese
Three Little Piggies
Buffalo Chicken
BBQ Chicken
Memphis Mac

“I am not a huge Mac and cheese fan, but wanted to try this place. Wow- it was so yummy! I had the chicken bacon ranch and it was delicious! I will definitely eat here again!!“

3.9 Good167 Reviews