Food was cold, but service was so bad we couldn't get it fixed. Had to ask for everything that should have been brought automatically. Won't eat there again.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 1
Amber E.
This place used to be amazing! It is now a shell of what it used to be. So sad to see a place go so far downhill. They used to give cinnamon rolls and tons of great relish prior to even getting your meal, now you get a few carrots and celery. The last 2 times I have been there they don't have half of the food on the menu, tonight they ran out of salad...wth? The potatoes are half orders of what they once were, and the au gratin have nasty cheese on top that tastes like it was kept in a shoe. The prime rib was mid at best, and my lobster was raw. The prices have gone up but the quality has gone down drastically! So very sad to say, but I will not be returning!!
rick wells
Always a good dinner. Old Fashioned dinner club w/ relish tray n the works. If you leave hungry, blame yourself.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Parmesan Encrusted Walleye, Smoked BBQ Ribs, Irish Steak, Fish and Chips, Onion Straws
Ricky Moll
It was subpar to sum up my experience here. The top sirloin was flavorless even with the supposedly sautéed mushrooms that tasted like they were boiled. overall the price was crazy for the amount of food. I mean french fries should be more than 10 especially when the steak is like 4 oz. I would not suggest the potatoes augratin it tasted like cheap boxed mac and cheese. The beef vegetable soup was the only highlight I can speak highly of. Well besides the true supper club look. Again for the price ... wayyyy not worth it.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
Jerry S.
Restaurant was very short staffed on a Sunday evening. Only One waitress who was very new. We Waited quite a while just for some water and then to order dinner. The House salad was very plain, just some chopped up lettuce with bland little croutons. Blue cheese dressing had very little flavor. Relish tray was slow in coming and nothing really special about it. Ordered rib eye steak that was flavorful, cooked close to medium rare and decent size. My wife had bluegill that was good and somewhat unique. House salad was served after main course was served and then only after reminding the waitress. Had old fashioneds at the bar before dinner that seemed a bit light on the booze. All in all not a very good experience, especially considering the relatively pricy menu.
DiAnn Blankenheim
Make reservations as like everywhere else we r short help. If impatient, pls go someplace
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
nettie fogel
Nice place, bar, separate seats for dinner. Rustic setting. Very cute atmosphere. Service was great. Thanks Caitlin!! Prime rib was sooo good, melt in your mouth. Nice portions. It's a great place in the middle of nowhere. Make it a point to go!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Shawn Wehnke
Been a long time since I've been there. Had the prime rib. Everything tasted great just as I remembered. Thanks
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
William G.
A great Wisconsin supper club! Friendly service, inexpensive drinks and dependable food quality.
Harleychick3cat
They must have reservations here since groups that arrived after us got seated before the 2 of us? Can't say how the food was since we left after 45 minutes waiting at the bar drinking overpriced old fashioneds that were orange color from all the bitters. No one seemed to be leaving during that time so I assume the kitchen was just as short handed as the wait staff.
I would recommend making a reservation, even though they weren't SUPER busy they were running on low staff so it took a while to be seated! Once they knew we were waiting they took our order at the bar and when we got to the table our appetizers and soups/salads were there! For food we ordered prime rib and New York strip steak. The prime rib was definitely the way to go. To die for. Steak was pretty good but could've used some more seasoning! The hashbrowns were incredible. Some of the best supper club hashbrowns ever. The soups and salads were awesome! Your meal comes with bread and a really nice relish tray. The cheese spread is SO GOOD! Once we got sat we had such great service too! Just be prepared to be patient. Hopefully they can get a good group of staff soon! Would definitely come back :)
Charles Johnson
Great place to eat with a very friendly staff ?. Will definitely go again
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Prime Rib and Lobster
Susan T
Before my grandsons graduation my family went to Reds supper club for dinner. It was not a good experience. I ordered the filet mignon, it was cooked to perfection, but it was tough to chew and lacked much flavor. Was very disappointing. Also, I ordered the au gratin potatoes, another big disappointment. It was a bowl with a lot of stringy cheese in it and what look like a few hashbrowns for potatoes. It was mushy and had no flavor. My daughter also had ordered a fillet mignon, hers was the same as mine but she just eat it anyways. I handed the waitress my plate with the full filet mignon -2 small bites, and a dish of hash browns -2 bites. She said she would go and tell the cook. When she came back with all of our checks, she said nothing to me and just handed me my bill. I had expected to see some type of compensation for my meal, but there was nothing I was charged full price. She said nothing about the plate of food I returned, not even an apology. Because we needed to get to the ceremony, I decided not to make a fuss, so I just paid the bill and left hungry and dissatisfied. My other family members were not really happy with their food either. I will neither recommend this restaurant, nor will I go there again!
Gayle Dehaan
It's near where we live and is good upscale food.
Linda VanNatta
We had a great meal. Portions were good size and everything was delicious. Maloree was our server and she did a great job. Thanks and we will be back!
Food was cold, but service was so bad we couldn't get it fixed. Had to ask for everything that should have been brought automatically. Won't eat there again.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 1
This place used to be amazing! It is now a shell of what it used to be. So sad to see a place go so far downhill. They used to give cinnamon rolls and tons of great relish prior to even getting your meal, now you get a few carrots and celery. The last 2 times I have been there they don't have half of the food on the menu, tonight they ran out of salad...wth? The potatoes are half orders of what they once were, and the au gratin have nasty cheese on top that tastes like it was kept in a shoe. The prime rib was mid at best, and my lobster was raw. The prices have gone up but the quality has gone down drastically! So very sad to say, but I will not be returning!!
Always a good dinner. Old Fashioned dinner club w/ relish tray n the works. If you leave hungry, blame yourself.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Parmesan Encrusted Walleye, Smoked BBQ Ribs, Irish Steak, Fish and Chips, Onion Straws
It was subpar to sum up my experience here. The top sirloin was flavorless even with the supposedly sautéed mushrooms that tasted like they were boiled. overall the price was crazy for the amount of food. I mean french fries should be more than 10 especially when the steak is like 4 oz. I would not suggest the potatoes augratin it tasted like cheap boxed mac and cheese. The beef vegetable soup was the only highlight I can speak highly of. Well besides the true supper club look. Again for the price ... wayyyy not worth it.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
Restaurant was very short staffed on a Sunday evening. Only One waitress who was very new. We Waited quite a while just for some water and then to order dinner. The House salad was very plain, just some chopped up lettuce with bland little croutons. Blue cheese dressing had very little flavor. Relish tray was slow in coming and nothing really special about it. Ordered rib eye steak that was flavorful, cooked close to medium rare and decent size. My wife had bluegill that was good and somewhat unique. House salad was served after main course was served and then only after reminding the waitress. Had old fashioneds at the bar before dinner that seemed a bit light on the booze. All in all not a very good experience, especially considering the relatively pricy menu.
Make reservations as like everywhere else we r short help. If impatient, pls go someplace
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nice place, bar, separate seats for dinner. Rustic setting. Very cute atmosphere. Service was great. Thanks Caitlin!! Prime rib was sooo good, melt in your mouth. Nice portions. It's a great place in the middle of nowhere. Make it a point to go!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Been a long time since I've been there. Had the prime rib. Everything tasted great just as I remembered. Thanks
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
A great Wisconsin supper club! Friendly service, inexpensive drinks and dependable food quality.
They must have reservations here since groups that arrived after us got seated before the 2 of us? Can't say how the food was since we left after 45 minutes waiting at the bar drinking overpriced old fashioneds that were orange color from all the bitters. No one seemed to be leaving during that time so I assume the kitchen was just as short handed as the wait staff.
Atmosphere: 3
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
I would recommend making a reservation, even though they weren't SUPER busy they were running on low staff so it took a while to be seated! Once they knew we were waiting they took our order at the bar and when we got to the table our appetizers and soups/salads were there! For food we ordered prime rib and New York strip steak. The prime rib was definitely the way to go. To die for. Steak was pretty good but could've used some more seasoning! The hashbrowns were incredible. Some of the best supper club hashbrowns ever. The soups and salads were awesome! Your meal comes with bread and a really nice relish tray. The cheese spread is SO GOOD! Once we got sat we had such great service too! Just be prepared to be patient. Hopefully they can get a good group of staff soon! Would definitely come back :)
Great place to eat with a very friendly staff ?. Will definitely go again
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Prime Rib and Lobster
Before my grandsons graduation my family went to Reds supper club for dinner. It was not a good experience. I ordered the filet mignon, it was cooked to perfection, but it was tough to chew and lacked much flavor. Was very disappointing. Also, I ordered the au gratin potatoes, another big disappointment. It was a bowl with a lot of stringy cheese in it and what look like a few hashbrowns for potatoes. It was mushy and had no flavor. My daughter also had ordered a fillet mignon, hers was the same as mine but she just eat it anyways. I handed the waitress my plate with the full filet mignon -2 small bites, and a dish of hash browns -2 bites. She said she would go and tell the cook. When she came back with all of our checks, she said nothing to me and just handed me my bill. I had expected to see some type of compensation for my meal, but there was nothing I was charged full price. She said nothing about the plate of food I returned, not even an apology. Because we needed to get to the ceremony, I decided not to make a fuss, so I just paid the bill and left hungry and dissatisfied. My other family members were not really happy with their food either. I will neither recommend this restaurant, nor will I go there again!
It's near where we live and is good upscale food.
We had a great meal. Portions were good size and everything was delicious. Maloree was our server and she did a great job. Thanks and we will be back!