I had been looking forward to dinner at The Village Supper Club, and while parts of the evening were lovely, the food was a major letdown.
Let’s start with the good: The service was outstanding — friendly, attentive, and welcoming. The ambiance was absolute perfection, cozy and charming, and the lake view at sunset was truly breathtaking. My Old Fashioned was delicious and well-balanced — exactly what you’d hope for at a supper club.
But… the food. Unfortunately, it was not good. My walleye was smothered in a heavy sauce and came breaded, which turned it into a soggy mess — totally overpowered the fish. The pork ribeye had zero flavor (how is that even possible?), and was also drowning in sauce. Honestly, it tasted like something you'd get in a cafeteria. The mashed potatoes, while plated beautifully, were cold.
So much potential, but the kitchen really missed the mark on the food dishes we ordered.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Relish Tray
M B
The atmosphere the people everything was wonderful. I personally was disappointed with their cut of prime rib for the price. Tasted ok but I question the quality of the meat more grisly then I've ever had before.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Chuck Mize
Nice new upscale facility with a great lake view. We asked about the size of the Brussels Sprout salad and were told that it was enough for one. It was HUGE! We could have easily split. We split the 8 oz filet. The kitchen would not divide the entree. An extra plate was provided, for a $5.00 upcharge!!! Ordered the peppercorn sauce. We didn't get it, but we were offered no consideration for the screw up. The prices are astronomical, like downtown Chicago. It was good, but not that good. Very disappointing. We won't be back.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 2
Tina Lund
Mediocre food. Service at the bar was good, but Old-Fashioneds are $14! Ouch. Our server at our table never asked us if we wanted a drink. Good thing we had water and it was refilled. I had the baked fish. Fish was Ok. Potato pancakes were like hockey pucks. But, beautiful atmosphere. Definitely a one and done for me.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 3
Margit Patterson
Beautiful surroundings. Wonderful bread basket and desserts. Good old fashioned.
Parking: The parking lot is located across the street and not marked.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 4
M M
0 for 2. Some of the worst food I've had in my life and 25 years ago I was homeless eating out of a McDonalds dumpster (it was better). When the food is bad it ruins the atmosphere too.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Pork Shank
Anne Morrow
We were highly anticipating dining at this restaurant..we were staying nearby at lake lawn resort. Their were 8 in out party and we had a cocktail at the bar and were seated after a 20 minute wait. Wish I was aware about the booths..They crammed 8 of us into one booth. I wish now I would have asked for table seating. We were all very uncomfortable and made it hard to enjoy dinner. My bill was over 600 dollars and no one was comfortable to enjoy the food. Skip the relish tray..old sweet pickles..couple of pretzels and old vegetables. Definitely won't be returning on our next family trip to Delavan. Our waiter was very young but personable. Too bad about the booths.
Michelle Edgell
Husband and I came in Friday 6:20 our reservation was at 6:30. Sat at bar ordered 2 Margaritas that were on the drink menu in front of us. Bartender rolled his eyes. Then I said we'll just have wine. He said good thing we only have and showed us little fresh squeezed lime juice he had and said good thing we changed to wine. Well dinner was fabulous as always. We had 2 more Margs. Both of us were sick. After a long week of work you want to be treated nice and have our favorite drink. Won't be back for a while!
Beth Hope
Excellent food and dessert . Go for the food and stay for the view !
Ryan Martin
Terrible food. Tried it twice. Terrible both times.
Great dinner, setting, and service! Will be back for summer dining for sure!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pork Shank
Connor Lindloff (Connor Lewis)
Good food! The meal comes with nice bread and butter. I would recommend this place for special events like birthdays or other occasions.
Wheelchair accessibility: Yes, you can access the building with a wheelchair.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Bone-In Ribeye
Rusty Stauffacher
We had the cheese curds they we over salted said something to the server she did nothing was their for birthday Feb 2 my steak was blah no was no seasoning. Half of it was very tough we were last year for the opening. Figured it might be better after a year but we were wrong. Will not be going back
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 4
HGF
Food not much to write home about, steaks chewy and rossoto ok, cheese curds way over salty, but server went above and beyond. Atmosphere was fantastic as was the view of the lake. Ordered an old fashioned and it was very weak to me, overpriced
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Paul Strozewski
I had the almond crusted walleye with cream sauce and that’s all I could taste, it was like the fish wasn’t even there. My fault, I should have known better than to get crusted fish with some kind of sauce. My wife’s prime rib was tough and the potatoes and soup were just warm. Service was good though and the place is nice but I think once was enough. We were underwhelmed.
I had been looking forward to dinner at The Village Supper Club, and while parts of the evening were lovely, the food was a major letdown.
Let’s start with the good:
The service was outstanding — friendly, attentive, and welcoming. The ambiance was absolute perfection, cozy and charming, and the lake view at sunset was truly breathtaking. My Old Fashioned was delicious and well-balanced — exactly what you’d hope for at a supper club.
But… the food.
Unfortunately, it was not good. My walleye was smothered in a heavy sauce and came breaded, which turned it into a soggy mess — totally overpowered the fish. The pork ribeye had zero flavor (how is that even possible?), and was also drowning in sauce. Honestly, it tasted like something you'd get in a cafeteria. The mashed potatoes, while plated beautifully, were cold.
So much potential, but the kitchen really missed the mark on the food dishes we ordered.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Relish Tray
The atmosphere the people everything was wonderful. I personally was disappointed with their cut of prime rib for the price. Tasted ok but I question the quality of the meat more grisly then I've ever had before.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Nice new upscale facility with a great lake view. We asked about the size of the Brussels Sprout salad and were told that it was enough for one. It was HUGE! We could have easily split. We split the 8 oz filet. The kitchen would not divide the entree. An extra plate was provided, for a $5.00 upcharge!!! Ordered the peppercorn sauce. We didn't get it, but we were offered no consideration for the screw up. The prices are astronomical, like downtown Chicago. It was good, but not that good. Very disappointing. We won't be back.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 2
Mediocre food. Service at the bar was good, but Old-Fashioneds are $14! Ouch. Our server at our table never asked us if we wanted a drink. Good thing we had water and it was refilled. I had the baked fish. Fish was Ok. Potato pancakes were like hockey pucks. But, beautiful atmosphere. Definitely a one and done for me.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 3
Beautiful surroundings. Wonderful bread basket and desserts. Good old fashioned.
Parking: The parking lot is located across the street and not marked.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 4
0 for 2. Some of the worst food I've had in my life and 25 years ago I was homeless eating out of a McDonalds dumpster (it was better). When the food is bad it ruins the atmosphere too.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Pork Shank
We were highly anticipating dining at this restaurant..we were staying nearby at lake lawn resort.
Their were 8 in out party and we had a cocktail at the bar and were seated after a 20 minute wait.
Wish I was aware about the booths..They crammed 8 of us into one booth.
I wish now I would have asked for table seating.
We were all very uncomfortable and made it hard to enjoy dinner.
My bill was over 600 dollars and no one was comfortable to enjoy the food.
Skip the relish tray..old sweet pickles..couple of pretzels and old vegetables.
Definitely won't be returning on our next family trip to Delavan.
Our waiter was very young but personable.
Too bad about the booths.
Husband and I came in Friday 6:20 our reservation was at 6:30. Sat at bar ordered 2 Margaritas that were on the drink menu in front of us. Bartender rolled his eyes. Then I said we'll just have wine. He said good thing we only have and showed us little fresh squeezed lime juice he had and said good thing we changed to wine. Well dinner was fabulous as always. We had 2 more Margs. Both of us were sick. After a long week of work you want to be treated nice and have our favorite drink. Won't be back for a while!
Excellent food and dessert . Go for the food and stay for the view !
Terrible food. Tried it twice. Terrible both times.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great dinner, setting, and service! Will be back for summer dining for sure!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pork Shank
Good food! The meal comes with nice bread and butter. I would recommend this place for special events like birthdays or other occasions.
Wheelchair accessibility: Yes, you can access the building with a wheelchair.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Bone-In Ribeye
We had the cheese curds they we over salted said something to the server she did nothing was their for birthday Feb 2 my steak was blah no was no seasoning. Half of it was very tough we were last year for the opening. Figured it might be better after a year but we were wrong. Will not be going back
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 4
Food not much to write home about, steaks chewy and rossoto ok, cheese curds way over salty, but server went above and beyond. Atmosphere was fantastic as was the view of the lake. Ordered an old fashioned and it was very weak to me, overpriced
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
I had the almond crusted walleye with cream sauce and that’s all I could taste, it was like the fish wasn’t even there. My fault, I should have known better than to get crusted fish with some kind of sauce. My wife’s prime rib was tough and the potatoes and soup were just warm. Service was good though and the place is nice but I think once was enough. We were underwhelmed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Loading...