Great view Excellent service Ribs were dry, steak ordered as medium rare was medium and roasted vegetables were raw to burnt
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Madeline Ackerlund
Maja was incredible at managing our big group and was wonderfully personal. She is a seasoned pro. Asher at the bar was also so hospitable that he even came out just to help us give some chips to our nephew at the other end of the table. For wonderful service and ambience, this can’t be beat.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeff T
Not your Mom & Dad's Carrington! Under new management and a new chef, this restaurant has vastly improved from previous years! Service was awesome. Keep in mind, they do not take reservations unless your group is 8 or more. Plenty of staff on hand. Our server, Martina, was excellent, checking by often to make sure things were good. Atmosphere is quiet. Casual with a formal feel to it. Seating also outside if you want to absorb the sunset. All that said, what really stood out was the food. My wife and I had a full rack of ribs and for $36, this ended up being 3 meals for us. These ribs were huge! A lot of meat on the bone and done perfectly with a Door County cherry glaze and served over roasted vegetables. A smoked gouda mac & cheese just glistened in the bowl. That's right, a bowl full. Quite enjoyable with my espresso martinis. Well worth the money.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Liz Gruenwald
Beautiful place..Great food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mark Braatz
Dianna and Asher were great as usual and the food was excellent both nights we went last week. Definitely worth a visit.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Donald Frederick
Asher, our server, was excellent. The ribs were dry and didn't look anything like the website photos. The Mac and cheese was great. Again the service was above and beyond.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
Valerie Bervid
The ribs were dry and not at all like what we had 2 years ago and the current pictures are out dated. The atmosphere was loud and hard to hear our friends. Had a singer that did not sing well and was really loud. Asher our waiter was phenomenal!!!! He went above and beyond. He deserves a raise.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 5
Diane Chapman
I can’t say enough good about our experience at Carrington. We had by far the best meal and service. Dana ( our waitress) was phenomenal. We live in Milwaukee and have so many options for great food but this was by far one of the best meals we have ever had. We started with old fashions which here perfect. For an entree we had Tenderloin/ Ribeye steaks. Both with onion and mushrooms. Our steaks were perfect!! The meals were accompanied with grilled vegetables and homemade mashed potatoes / and homemade baked Mac n cheese. Dana was so sweet and made the experience so good. The views of Green Bay from out table were amazing too. We’ve become so accustomed to high prices for mediocre food and service, so this deserves an excellent review. Hope you go to Carrington in Egg Harbor when in Door County. We will certainly be back!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Adam Erickson
Outstanding food and service with stunning water views!
jan k
Great waitress. Husband and l ordered the fish dinners/cod. It looked and tasted like it was a reheated dish. It was Not fresh, not hot. Nothing special about presentation, more like diner food. Even the fries tasted old, reheated. Wedge salads were good. We stay at the Landmark every winter, but won't return to the Carrington.
Came to door county for the first time for a winter wedding and Diana delivered amazing service to us. Diana and Jolina allowed us to continue a great evening out with old friends. We couldn’t appreciate the customer service more. Thank you, Diana & Jolina!
Brian Spies
Our bartender Diana went above and beyond. We were in a conundrum and she really helped us out. Great place, great atmosphere, great time.
Jaime Petersen
Thanksgiving buffet was awful! Never again and extremely disappointed. It truly ruined the day.
Scott
Great views of the bay.
jeremy z
As per always hard individual to please when referring to restaurants with my culinary background
Service was all right, saw an old friend Food was okay nothing to brag about Atmosphere was all right everything seemed to focus upon the view Pricing was up there $130 for 2 1/2 people Would I recommend maybe for large groups or banquets wedding?
Great view
Excellent service
Ribs were dry, steak ordered as medium rare was medium and roasted vegetables were raw to burnt
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Maja was incredible at managing our big group and was wonderfully personal. She is a seasoned pro. Asher at the bar was also so hospitable that he even came out just to help us give some chips to our nephew at the other end of the table. For wonderful service and ambience, this can’t be beat.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Not your Mom & Dad's Carrington!
Under new management and a new chef, this restaurant has vastly improved from previous years!
Service was awesome. Keep in mind, they do not take reservations unless your group is 8 or more. Plenty of staff on hand. Our server, Martina, was excellent, checking by often to make sure things were good.
Atmosphere is quiet. Casual with a formal feel to it. Seating also outside if you want to absorb the sunset.
All that said, what really stood out was the food. My wife and I had a full rack of ribs and for $36, this ended up being 3 meals for us. These ribs were huge! A lot of meat on the bone and done perfectly with a Door County cherry glaze and served over roasted vegetables. A smoked gouda mac & cheese just glistened in the bowl. That's right, a bowl full. Quite enjoyable with my espresso martinis. Well worth the money.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Beautiful place..Great food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dianna and Asher were great as usual and the food was excellent both nights we went last week. Definitely worth a visit.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Asher, our server, was excellent.
The ribs were dry and didn't look anything like the website photos. The Mac and cheese was great. Again the service was above and beyond.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
The ribs were dry and not at all like what we had 2 years ago and the current pictures are out dated. The atmosphere was loud and hard to hear our friends. Had a singer that did not sing well and was really loud. Asher our waiter was phenomenal!!!! He went above and beyond. He deserves a raise.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 5
I can’t say enough good about our experience at Carrington.
We had by far the best meal and service.
Dana ( our waitress) was phenomenal.
We live in Milwaukee and have so many options for great food but this was by far one of the best meals we have ever had.
We started with old fashions which here perfect.
For an entree we had Tenderloin/ Ribeye steaks. Both with onion and mushrooms. Our steaks were perfect!! The meals were accompanied with grilled vegetables and homemade mashed potatoes / and homemade baked Mac n cheese.
Dana was so sweet and made the experience so good. The views of Green Bay from out table were amazing too.
We’ve become so accustomed to high prices for mediocre food and service, so this deserves an excellent review.
Hope you go to Carrington in Egg Harbor when in Door County. We will certainly be back!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Outstanding food and service with stunning water views!
Great waitress. Husband and l ordered the fish dinners/cod. It looked and tasted like it was a reheated dish. It was Not fresh, not hot. Nothing special about presentation, more like diner food. Even the fries tasted old, reheated. Wedge salads were good. We stay at the Landmark every winter, but won't return to the Carrington.
Restaurantji Recommends
Came to door county for the first time for a winter wedding and Diana delivered amazing service to us. Diana and Jolina allowed us to continue a great evening out with old friends. We couldn’t appreciate the customer service more. Thank you, Diana & Jolina!
Our bartender Diana went above and beyond. We were in a conundrum and she really helped us out. Great place, great atmosphere, great time.
Thanksgiving buffet was awful! Never again and extremely disappointed. It truly ruined the day.
Great views of the bay.
As per always hard individual to please when referring to restaurants with my culinary background
Service was all right, saw an old friend
Food was okay nothing to brag about
Atmosphere was all right everything seemed to focus upon the view
Pricing was up there
$130 for 2 1/2 people
Would I recommend maybe for large groups or banquets wedding?
Loading...