Casey's BBQ & Smokehouse

It was Sunday, late afternoon/early evening, in February and the only complaint from our crew was that baked potatoes weren't available until five😆 The coffee was fresh and all that was left was a pile of bones. Aisha(sp?) was an excellent waitress! Very courteous and considerate.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brisket chili was tough and chewy. The corn muffin had no taste. The wing’s skin was burnt black, I had to peel it off to find the chicken. The waiter said maybe it was because it was old??

The wife and I stopped by here for a quick lunch. Alexander was our bartender and he was very welcoming from the moment we walked in.

We ordered the Bbq melt sandwich with brisket and a brisket quesadilla, both recommended by Alexander.

The whole experience was fantastic and we will definitely return when we come back to Door County.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Bbq brisket not great. Tasted old to me and didn’t look fresh.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

The most tender, melt in your mouth brisket I have ever had! Hubby had the quarter chicken plate. The sweet potato fries, corn nuggets, and pork and beans were very good. We sat at the bar because it was hot outside and the service was very good. It’s expensive - $50 for our meals and one beer each, but it was so good!

Food was AMAZING. We had Brisket sandwich, and Pulled Pork sandwich.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best brisket I’ve ever tasted. Yum!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Wow, we were both awed by the scenery out the back patio facing the water. Our server was very nice and welcoming letting us enjoy our drink and relax to enjoy that view. Ordered app of smoked chicken wings that were delicious. We were left alone to enjoy, we both ordered prime rib sandwiches that came with cole slaw,chips,4 pickle slices. We ate it all and felt like we had a whole steak dinner. Very generous portion. It was thee best meal of our vacation. We will be back to try the ribs.

My sister had the Two Meat combo and smoked beef brisket and smoke chicken, pork and beans and Mac and Cheese. She loved it. I wasn’t real hungry so I got a grilled chicken sandwich, which was good. Staff were friendly. It was a pleasant atmosphere.

Omg- yummmm! We have a ton of leftovers but this was by far the best bbq around! Me and my husband got the 5 meat plate to share and we still have enough for lunch today and probably dinner haha. This was a damn good dinner spot!

My wife and I were looking for a casual spot with a water view, and we hit the jackpot with Casey's in Egg Harbor in Door County, Wisconsin. We found this place quite by accident and am glad we did. Located on the west side of Door County, Casey's offers an incredible outdoor elevated view of beautiful Green Bay (the body of water, not the city). And there was a bonus - the food was both tasty and reasonably priced! Give yourself a treat at Casey's!!!

EXCELLENT Bar-B-Que! The pulled pork has amazing flavor, hearty portions and extremely satisfying! The sauce is more of a Carolina style and very tasty! The fried shrimp is some of the best I’ve ever eaten! Generous portions of food! Delightful service, nice bar. We’ll be back!

Wasn’t expecting much and still missed expectations. Personally had the two meat sampler, Chicken and pork shoulder. Both terribly dry and lacking any flavor. House sauce needs improvement as well NOT that you should need sauce on Good bbq. Appetizer serving sizes small for the price. As a family of six, we’ve eaten far better for far less in the area. Unfortunately options are limited through the winter holiday week.

Great food, sat outside, did not get a good view of sunset as tree was in the way. We had good service, a little buggy. Nice place to eat

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Prime Rib Sandwich, Brisket

They told us not to come back supposedly it was because we didn't leave a good tip but i think it was a racist thing because we were all Mexican the lady there is full of crap saying that it was cause of the tip

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 2