My Wife and I where visiting Door Country and stopped at a number of bakeries. We both agree that Macready was the best.
Jennifer Young
The cherry cranberry bread, cherry scone, and chicken pot pie were amazing! I also loved the sugar or butter cookie (can't remember what it was called, because I was having an out of body experience while eating it!). It was that delicious! Wish I would have bought more items to bring home.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Scones, Cranberry Bread
AndrewM533
Everybody writes reviews about their experience at the location they're reviewing. I am not. My review is about enjoying a loaf of bread from McCready's after I returned home. A bowl of homemade goulash with some generously buttered white bread from McCready's made for a particularly satisfying and comforting meal on a cool October evening. I look forward to McCready's bread toasted at breakfast tomorrow.
Pamela F
Cute little shop! The sandwich was delicious! The smell when you walk in is so good smells like fresh bread! I would definitely stop there again!!!
Ben W.
Good lunch spot with pretty good sandwiches. Wish they had hot sandwiches too but cold was good. Served bread as well. Maybe a little pricey but all is well with service too!
Stacy A
Cute spot, kind people. Helpful and happy to chat. Had a pastry, and then hung out across the street to look at the water.
Robert Kosin
Best outdoor dining to compliment fresh sandwich or a short walk to public park over looking Green Bay .
Melissa Rose
I've been here several times before and had great experiences. Went here Saturday afternoon and was not impressed at all. Not sure if it's new staff or what but the sandwich wasn't very good and the soup was super bland. Plenty of parking and the restroom was cleaned. Loved the outdoor seating and live music. Relatively friendly staff but insane prices for food. A half of sandwich and soup was over 14 dollars without a beverage. My sandwich was really small and nothing over the top when it comes to taste. Sadly I was super disappointed and not sure if I'd go back.
Dave Froeming
GREAT bread sandwiches! Chips too. Awesome chocolate chip cookies and cinnamon rolls! I had the turkey with double turkey….excellent!! So fresh. Awesome dining outdoors with live music!! Highly recommend!!
atropicalsnorkeler
The quality seems to be a hit or miss. My bread was fresh and tasty but my husband’s was dry. My husband’s tomato bisque soup was good. The sandwiches were average, a little overpriced in our opinion. There were several flies in the store, including ones landing on the pastries and bagels. Lunch time is very busy and seating is sparse.
Homemade cranberry chicken salad on freshly made bread! Yum! We sat outside to eat and listened to live music! Perfect last stop for our last lunch in Door County!
Stacy Bo Bacy
Cute spot, kind people. Helpful and happy to chat. Had a pastry, and then hung out across the street to look at the water.
Lynn J.
They have amazing breads and great customer service. Their location is in the quaint Door County village of Egg Harbor.
Joel Hembel
Absolutely amazing bakery. I’mIn love with the Cherry bread!! You must try❤️
Nathan Larsen (Nate)
I suppose its Egg and I'm sure everything is over priced. I felt that for the quality of service and food we paid too much.
My Wife and I where visiting Door Country and stopped at a number of bakeries. We both agree that Macready was the best.
The cherry cranberry bread, cherry scone, and chicken pot pie were amazing! I also loved the sugar or butter cookie (can't remember what it was called, because I was having an out of body experience while eating it!). It was that delicious! Wish I would have bought more items to bring home.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Scones, Cranberry Bread
Everybody writes reviews about their experience at the location they're reviewing. I am not. My review is about enjoying a loaf of bread from McCready's after I returned home. A bowl of homemade goulash with some generously buttered white bread from McCready's made for a particularly satisfying and comforting meal on a cool October evening. I look forward to McCready's bread toasted at breakfast tomorrow.
Cute little shop! The sandwich was delicious! The smell when you walk in is so good smells like fresh bread! I would definitely stop there again!!!
Good lunch spot with pretty good sandwiches. Wish they had hot sandwiches too but cold was good. Served bread as well. Maybe a little pricey but all is well with service too!
Cute spot, kind people. Helpful and happy to chat. Had a pastry, and then hung out across the street to look at the water.
Best outdoor dining to compliment fresh sandwich or a short walk to public park over looking Green Bay .
I've been here several times before and had great experiences. Went here Saturday afternoon and was not impressed at all. Not sure if it's new staff or what but the sandwich wasn't very good and the soup was super bland. Plenty of parking and the restroom was cleaned. Loved the outdoor seating and live music. Relatively friendly staff but insane prices for food. A half of sandwich and soup was over 14 dollars without a beverage. My sandwich was really small and nothing over the top when it comes to taste. Sadly I was super disappointed and not sure if I'd go back.
GREAT bread sandwiches! Chips too. Awesome chocolate chip cookies and cinnamon rolls! I had the turkey with double turkey….excellent!! So fresh. Awesome dining outdoors with live music!! Highly recommend!!
The quality seems to be a hit or miss. My bread was fresh and tasty but my husband’s was dry. My husband’s tomato bisque soup was good. The sandwiches were average, a little overpriced in our opinion. There were several flies in the store, including ones landing on the pastries and bagels. Lunch time is very busy and seating is sparse.
Restaurantji Recommends
Homemade cranberry chicken salad on freshly made bread! Yum! We sat outside to eat and listened to live music! Perfect last stop for our last lunch in Door County!
Cute spot, kind people. Helpful and happy to chat. Had a pastry, and then hung out across the street to look at the water.
They have amazing breads and great customer service. Their location is in the quaint Door County village of Egg Harbor.
Absolutely amazing bakery. I’mIn love with the Cherry bread!! You must try❤️
I suppose its Egg and I'm sure everything is over priced. I felt that for the quality of service and food we paid too much.