My wife and I booked Pink Bakery to do our wedding cake in October of 2023. Kim was incredibly helpful in helping us make decisions and providing options for cakes and desserts. She was very accessible and always responded when we had questions, both via email and on the phone. We were also able to adjust our order according to the final guest list, she was very accommodating! We are very grateful that she was able to deliver the cake herself to Sturgeon Bay, and it was absolutely fantastic. We opted for a vanilla cake with raspberry compote and a chocolate ganache drizzle for our cutting cake, and then cookies & cream cakes for the other guests. These are, by far, the best cakes I’ve ever had. Our guests devoured the cakes, leaving very little left over! You will not be disappointed by Pink Bakery for your special occasion.
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Andrea W.
We have been in search of a bakery. We had eaten at another business owned by this owner so we wanted to give this a try! We walked in on a Saturday mid morning with lots of goodies available. We asked the person working what her favorite item was as we couldn't decide. She said the morning buns, we plan on getting one of these on our next visit. Our 1st trip resulted in us purchasing 3 peanut butter cookies, 1 sugar cookie with icing and sprinkles, and 2 of the caramel pecan rolls. I will dissect each of these: PB Cookie: They are thick and huge! It was the perfect crunchy edges and chewy inside. It was perfect. My husband had 2! Sugar Cookie: we have a bakery in our hometown that has the most amazing sugar cookies. I have to say that this one BEATS the ones from home. I will be taking some home for friends. Caramel Pecan Roll: this buttery, flakey, nutty, and caramel flavor meld together to make this amazing roll. My husband and I couldn't put it down it was so tasty. We will be taking these home too! We met the sweetest couple when we were in there. She said we had to get the Peanut Bar, so we will be sampling that later. It's a cute little place! It has a few seats and I am sure during the season it's popular! We will be coming back!
Jessica Cowden
Service was poor. The older lady could care less. My husband had a monster cookie and I had a chocolate croissant. Both were stale and ended up being tossed. My husband got black coffee and I got a hazelnut latte which we tossed as well. Also, I felt like this place was way overpriced for everything getting tossed. I would recommend somewhere else for coffee and pastries
Maddie Schaafsma
Most awful experience ever. The cake was completely messed up - it was transported incredibly carefully back to the house and still was absolutely messed up on every side from their packaging job. How else do they expect to get the cake to where it’s supposed to be? The cake itself was off-centered, messy, and straight up ugly. When returning to ask them to fix the letters and messed up side the workers were incredibly rude and demeaning. DO NOT USE THIS PLACE.
Tonya Schultz
In Door County for a week and have been excited to have what this area is known for…. cherry pie! Our first choice of the Wood market and others were closed so we came to the Pink Bakery. What a disappointment! The cherry pie square I ordered and my son’s cookie sandwich were both stale! Not edible so it went in the garbage! Customer service also was ?, the girl working couldn’t even tell us what a couple items were! We definitely won’t be back! We’re looking forward to going to the Wood Market today! ?
Gina Marks
The Homemade Ho Ho's are the best (absolutely amazing), everything that my husband and I have had there is great but my favorite are the Ho Ho's, we go to Door County every other year and I have to go to Pinks for my dozen, yes dozen (12) Ho Ho's. :)
Shaelee Fischer
The cupcake that I bought had that frozen and then thawed taste which was not very enjoyable. When I asked the lady working the price of the cupcake, she said $2.50 twice and then rang me in for $3.50. No good customer service, not good dessert. Don’t recommend.
Elisabeth Wilson
Some of the items could've been packaged better, overall a good experience though ?
Susan Howerton
The carrot cake cupcakes are absolute perfection! We are so glad we stopped in for dessert. They were very friendly and the cupcakes were just wonderful.
Rebecca Luginbill
Happy to try out their GF brownie and cupcakes. Both were good! I had chocolate Oreo cupcake. Nice little bakery.
I needed a cake with 8 names on it for a party where we were all celebrating a milestone birthday. She was so creative, putting them around the side so all would fit. It was so cute and delicious! Chocolate and vanilla layers with raspberry filling and topped with buttercream frosting. Yum!
Jane L
Got a cake two years ago that was excellent. Bought one two days ago that did not measure up. Also got an apple fritter that was dry and hard. It seems that the quality has slipped alot. ?
Amara Schumacher
Delicious cookie sandwich, croissant, peanut square, basically everything we ordered! Super tasty and great service.
Amy L
The donuts were nothing special. They taste like ones I can get at a grocery store. My husband was not impressed by the frosted sugar cookies. He said the frosting was gross. The M&M cookie was good but I've had better. All the cookies lo9ked to be over baked in the case so I expected it to be crunchy but surprisingly it was soft.
My wife and I booked Pink Bakery to do our wedding cake in October of 2023. Kim was incredibly helpful in helping us make decisions and providing options for cakes and desserts. She was very accessible and always responded when we had questions, both via email and on the phone. We were also able to adjust our order according to the final guest list, she was very accommodating! We are very grateful that she was able to deliver the cake herself to Sturgeon Bay, and it was absolutely fantastic. We opted for a vanilla cake with raspberry compote and a chocolate ganache drizzle for our cutting cake, and then cookies & cream cakes for the other guests. These are, by far, the best cakes I’ve ever had. Our guests devoured the cakes, leaving very little left over! You will not be disappointed by Pink Bakery for your special occasion.
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
We have been in search of a bakery. We had eaten at another business owned by this owner so we wanted to give this a try! We walked in on a Saturday mid morning with lots of goodies available. We asked the person working what her favorite item was as we couldn't decide. She said the morning buns, we plan on getting one of these on our next visit. Our 1st trip resulted in us purchasing 3 peanut butter cookies, 1 sugar cookie with icing and sprinkles, and 2 of the caramel pecan rolls. I will dissect each of these: PB Cookie: They are thick and huge! It was the perfect crunchy edges and chewy inside. It was perfect. My husband had 2! Sugar Cookie: we have a bakery in our hometown that has the most amazing sugar cookies. I have to say that this one BEATS the ones from home. I will be taking some home for friends. Caramel Pecan Roll: this buttery, flakey, nutty, and caramel flavor meld together to make this amazing roll. My husband and I couldn't put it down it was so tasty. We will be taking these home too! We met the sweetest couple when we were in there. She said we had to get the Peanut Bar, so we will be sampling that later. It's a cute little place! It has a few seats and I am sure during the season it's popular! We will be coming back!
Service was poor. The older lady could care less. My husband had a monster cookie and I had a chocolate croissant. Both were stale and ended up being tossed. My husband got black coffee and I got a hazelnut latte which we tossed as well. Also, I felt like this place was way overpriced for everything getting tossed. I would recommend somewhere else for coffee and pastries
Most awful experience ever. The cake was completely messed up - it was transported incredibly carefully back to the house and still was absolutely messed up on every side from their packaging job. How else do they expect to get the cake to where it’s supposed to be? The cake itself was off-centered, messy, and straight up ugly. When returning to ask them to fix the letters and messed up side the workers were incredibly rude and demeaning. DO NOT USE THIS PLACE.
In Door County for a week and have been excited to have what this area is known for…. cherry pie! Our first choice of the Wood market and others were closed so we came to the Pink Bakery. What a disappointment! The cherry pie square I ordered and my son’s cookie sandwich were both stale! Not edible so it went in the garbage! Customer service also was ?, the girl working couldn’t even tell us what a couple items were! We definitely won’t be back! We’re looking forward to going to the Wood Market today! ?
The Homemade Ho Ho's are the best (absolutely amazing), everything that my husband and I have had there is great but my favorite are the Ho Ho's, we go to Door County every other year and I have to go to Pinks for my dozen, yes dozen (12) Ho Ho's. :)
The cupcake that I bought had that frozen and then thawed taste which was not very enjoyable. When I asked the lady working the price of the cupcake, she said $2.50 twice and then rang me in for $3.50. No good customer service, not good dessert. Don’t recommend.
Some of the items could've been packaged better, overall a good experience though ?
The carrot cake cupcakes are absolute perfection! We are so glad we stopped in for dessert. They were very friendly and the cupcakes were just wonderful.
Happy to try out their GF brownie and cupcakes. Both were good! I had chocolate Oreo cupcake. Nice little bakery.
Restaurantji Recommends
I needed a cake with 8 names on it for a party where we were all celebrating a milestone birthday. She was so creative, putting them around the side so all would fit. It was so cute and delicious! Chocolate and vanilla layers with raspberry filling and topped with buttercream frosting. Yum!
Got a cake two years ago that was excellent. Bought one two days ago that did not measure up. Also got an apple fritter that was dry and hard. It seems that the quality has slipped alot. ?
Delicious cookie sandwich, croissant, peanut square, basically everything we ordered! Super tasty and great service.
The donuts were nothing special. They taste like ones I can get at a grocery store. My husband was not impressed by the frosted sugar cookies. He said the frosting was gross. The M&M cookie was good but I've had better. All the cookies lo9ked to be over baked in the case so I expected it to be crunchy but surprisingly it was soft.
Delicious, unique and generous cupcakes