Sully's of Fond du Lac, Inc.

food has changed for the worse the last 2 months and all the bartenders sit at the far end of the bar talking with their friends

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 2

Tried their brunch today for the first time and it was fantastic! We always have fun at Sully’s and the drinks and food are always very good. This is one of our favorite places to go to Fond Du Lac.

They need to expand this place. The problem they keep having is AWESOME FOOD AWESOME WEEKLY PIZZAS GREAT BARTENDERS FANTASTIC OWNERSHIP. They get packed often because everything is too amazing. probably gonna need to invest in a parking garage and buy some extra land to expand the building. THIS IS THE #1 SPOT IN FOND DU LAC WI. hands down. 100% if youve never been here, well you should be now! I dont even go there for alcohol i go for the people, sports, food, and friendly atmosphere. its a hidden gem thats for sure. Shoutout to all the employees all around and management 🏆

Wonderful service, incredible food. Had the Reuben. Absolutely the best.!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Reuben Sandwich

Drove past this place thousands of times, finally decided to try it, kind of wish I didn't. Ordered a western burger for carryout and decided I'd have a pint while I waited, which was estimated to be 45 mins. No big deal, it was new years eve at noon, maybe a few extra people in the bar. Got there and bar had most seats occupied but place was not packed, yet it took a good 15 minutes just to get a beer, bartender was nice and checked in often but had a bad habit of asking questions and then just walking away. Beer was very good. Cold and fresh, tap domestic. Food showed up, by then I was ready to pay tab and that took another 10 minutes because bartender again disappeared, but before she took care of that she was ready to handle refills for some regulars that had been served numerous times already ignoring me standing there with my card in the process.

Food was lackluster. Large portions, but the bacon on the burger was undercooked, and unrendered. I picked it off and tried the burger that didn't come with any produce on the side or even a pickle. Not great, like a home cooked burger with some seasoning salt. Ordered medium, definitely rare rare. Whatever, that's not a big deal, and the fries were okay....but the whole experience kind of sucked having now taken an hour and a half to get a subpar burger from start to finish. Felt pushed to the side from the moment I walked in as well. There are definitely better burgers and beer in town.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 2

Wings very by each visit. Good quality and then not. Language by some customers a little over the top, bar tender should control.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Sausage Pepperoni Pizza, Chicken Wings, Fries

Updated in December: We got some food here and had drinks while watching the Bucks game. The food was awesome! Irish nachos are a MUST! Hubby liked the wings, too!
We didn't eat here but had bloody Mary's and really enjoyed our time here! The bartender Candace was super friendly!

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Irish Nachos

We picked up fish to go and it was the WORST fish I have ever had!! I ordered perch and my first bite had bones and was Very Fishy tasting!! It is not lake perch, as the fillets were large single pieces, and all pieces were fishy tasting. My husband had the cod which is beer battered and had more batter then fish, also very greasy. Over $30 for food that was thrown in the GARBAGE!!
UPDATE:
After talking with a manager about this meal, we will be trying the fish again.

Stopped in with a friend after a movie. Ordered the reuben pizza...and I love a good reuben but it doesn't translate as well as hoped to a pizza ... No fault on Sully's as it was hot and had crispy edges. Bartender was a one woman act and kept everything moving...was a bit slow to return to get our order and beverage refills but it wasn't because she was standing around or gabbing with "the regulars". It also was Bar bingo night and we caught just the tail end of that. The speaker system was right behind us and was too loud but the bar stools were the only 2 side by side available.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Absolute worst service. 1st and last time. 1.5 hours for food only for the bartender to tell us he was offended by our comment “it took so long”. Never coming back. Humiliating for the business and I’ve bartended for YEARS. The eye rolls and beyond were embarrassing.

First time visit & waited an incredibly long time for food & when it was delivered both our meals were cold. Tasted good if you like cold food. Worst part they weren't busy

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Burger

Just a nice local pub. Grabbed some lunch, a couple of pizzas and drinks. Went on Veterans Day and they gave me a free deluxe pizza for being a Vet. I wasn't expecting it but sure was happy!

Parking: Maybe 6 or 7 spots

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sausage and Mushrooms Pizza

Really good pizza. Nice relaxed place for lunch.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Small but cozy. Not cheap, but not expensive at all. Best in town- Brisket, homemade pizza, chicken wings (and their rubs and sauce), and service (especially if you're remotely considerate on the occasions that call for it). Home sweet home.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Irish nachos were really good!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Irish Nachos