Salamone's Italian Pizzeria

1245 Madison Ave, Fort Atkinson
(920) 563-9217

Recent Reviews

Sort by
LIKE AFOX

All tasty though spaghetti only came with 2 meatballs for the price was kind of skimpy, $100 for 4 people

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Linda L Picl

Have gone for pizza many times ,but this last time there was no flavor at all. Sausage was so bland it disappeared,. There were no spices at all and sauce was non-existant. Do not recommend the pizza at all anymore. Its a real shame,they must have lost the person who knew how to make thier pizzas.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 5

SSmith262 “Bars”

Italian beef was supreme 😋 best one in the area

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gregory Stahl

Wow! Amazing sauce on that cheese tortellini! Perfect alfredo too. Great atmosphere. Friendly staff. Wonderful all around! Thanks guys!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Alfredo Pasta

Lynn Tucker

Fantastic pizza and service, we enjoyed it very much.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jacob Zimmer

Very very friendly service and great food!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jamie Doyle

Pizza is always delicious. It can be counted on to be consistent with how it is made. Always a perfect amount of toppings and cheese!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sarah

We wanted something different, so got take out last night and definitely not impressed. The spaghetti was average, portion was great, but nothing special about it. The garlic bread appetizer we got was just okay, bread was pretty soggy and there was no dipping sauce like I had asked for when ordering. The calzone was decent, the size was smaller than expected. They didn't give any Mariana for dipping, which was a disappointment. It also was wrapped in foil, making it pretty soft and doughy not sure why it wasn't in a box or a to go container, might hold up better. The thin crust pizza wasn't crunchy at all. It was pretty soft on the bottom, thin but only some crunch on a few crust pieces. Also, anytime we grabbed the pizza from the box, all the toppings and cheese came right off :( The cheese was good, toppings were fresh, but just not executed properly. From the reviews, we were just expecting a lot more good out of this to go visit. The 2 garlic bread apps, spaghetti meal, calzone, large pizza and medium pizza $87.00. Just not worth it, for what we paid and what product we got. Maybe will try a dine in experience and that will be better. Just a big disappointment for a birthday dinner.

Dawn Adams, PHR

Fabulous pizza, caring service!

Sarah Phenia

Fun, local hangout. The pizza looked fantastic.

Carey Shea

Great pizza. Lot of people seemed to enjoy their calzones

Nenita Sprouse

I'm visiting from AZ. My brother had the wedding rehearsal dinner here for his daughter. One of the best vegetarian pizzas I've had! Worth trying even if you're not a vegetarian. It will make a convert out of you.

Mitchell Patterson

Best pizza in town! Highly recommend!

Donald Owens

The pizza was excellent. Service was good. Definitely felt like a Italian pizzeria

Kayra Eva Polak

Love it there. The pasta with vodka sauce is to die for

Loading...