Sally's Sweet Shoppe
S42 W31238, WI-83, Genesee Depot
(262) 968-1803
Customers' Favorites
Birthday Cake
Wedding Cake
Sheet Cake
Doughnut
Cupcake
Cakes
Menu
Photos
+58 photos
+57 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Sally’s Sweet Shop did a fantastic job on my Mother in Law’s 90th birthday cake and mini cupcakes. Her favorite cake is carrot cake, it was so beautiful and delicious, there were no leftovers! Sally’s Sweet Shop was easy to work with and definitely high quality cake!
Absolutely fantastic assortment of baked goods and confections, from cupcakes to candy bars. We tried a little of everything, cookies, crumb cake, and a hot cup of coffee. Laura, who was baking fresh cookies while we talked, was extremely friendly and informative. We drove 2 hours to get here and were not disappointed.
You May Also Like
Union House - S42 W31320 WI-83
![]()
Fine Dining, American, Vegan
In Cahoots & Co - S43W31325 WI-83
![]()
Bar, Bar & Grill
Cornerstone Restaurant - S43 W31343, WI-83
![]()
American, Gluten-Free, New American, Vegetarian
The cakes are absolutely delicious. They simply nail it on the custom orders. The devil is in the details, as long as you fill out their custom order form and provide as much detail as possible, they can accommodate most requests and designs. Give them a reasonable time frame and they gotchu!
Don't...