Joey Gerard's - A Bartolotta Supper Club

The salmon was perfectly cooked; the chicken picatta delicious! Out waiter was friendly and made some great suggestions!

Excellent food and excellent service, as always. Joey Gerards is one of the few places out there that is consistently fabulous!

Excellent food and excellent service! Great atmosphere! Everyone was friendly and accommodating. Very timely service. I understand this is a premiere dining experience and the cost of dining out but that being said the prices were still difficult to swallow.

Service was excellent. I did not think the brunch was worth $70 per person. The selection of food was minimal and poor selection of desserts. I expected a better meal from Joey Gerards. Coffee and tea and juice should have been complimentary as part of the brunch. Instead I paid 6$ per coffee.

We truly enjoyed our Easter Brunch!! The food was fabulous with an amazing selection, but our family favorite was the chef carved ribeye station! The deviled eggs with bacon and caviar were a close second. The staff was very attentive and courteous and we were all so full when we got home, that we weren't even hungry for dinner! My only recommendation would be that they have tags for the items on the buffet so you know what everything is. There were some different spreads next to the bagels that we thought was flavored cream cheese, but it turned out to be flavored butter.

We greeted warmly when we arrived and were immediately seated. We were well served by Sophie. My prime rib was perfect as was my wife's filet

The food was amazing, Layla our server was attentive, kind, courteous and took special care to make the dinner personable. I was with my husband celebrating my 1000th day of sobriety and she made it a very special dinner. Thank you so much for making tonight outstanding.

Julie and I thoroughly enjoyed our dinner at Joey Gerard's. We liked our table. Our server Kim was awesome! Very attentive but not bothersome. The food was great! I had the prime rib done to perfection and Julie really enjoyed the Salmon! Great value! Loved the surprise dessert as it was a birthday dinner!!

We always look forward to dining at Joey Gerard's. It's our favorite close to home fine dining restaurant.

We were expecting to be seated in a restaurant like you have photographed on your website and FB page. Instead we were seated in a party room. Very disappointed. I was told by the hostess that nothing was available in the main dinning area. Service was good. Food ok. Unimpressed with the Chicken Marsella. Food barely warm, small portion, hardly any sauce, spinach and potatoes kinda bland. We were also charged for a veggie listed as included with the steak dinner. Will not return.

Excellent food

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Relish Tray

Everything was on point, staff, very knowledgeable and talkative even though they were busy, waited for nothing. Food was really good, wife and I both had steak.
Desert was also exceptional. Went for our anniversary and didn't regret going.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Our waiter (I forget his name) was absolutely hilarious and had us laughing the entire time. The food.... My god it was delicious. My steak was perfectly cooked, the seafood platter was tasty, and the cheese curds were absolutely delicious. Just all around 10/10 taste with everything. It was definitely a pricey dinner but we knew that going in. Highly recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Curds

we were expecting a lot more from a renowned establishment. our service was great, but everything else was underwhelming. i can appreciate a supper club remaining traditional to wisconsin culture, but for those prices, we were expecting more decadent and robust flavors. everything fell flat and one-note. the sides were not prepared with much regard, they felt like an after-thought.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 5

Stopped here for wife’s birthday and ate at the bar (we liked the look and feel of the bar area). This place does high end supper club well. Service here impressive and is something you would get at every Bartolotta restaurant. Had happy hour at the bar with two brandy old fashions, raw beef and onions, steak bites and onion rings. All the food was delicious and the Friday seafood platter was a fun upscaled version of a Friday bar fish fry.

Really want to call out the mixologist who waited on us at the bar (Madelyn) she really made the entire night for us. I tried to quietly cheers my wife for her birthday and she is hyper aware of what’s going on around her. She brought out a surprise birthday dessert and Brandy Alexander shooter. She knew my wife wanted to try a Brandy Alexander but wouldn’t be able to with the extra dessert. This is far above and beyond excellent service.

Madelyn made a quiet quick birthday stop a fun and memorable night for us. I can see us stopping here for happy hour more often since the happy hour prices are so reasonable for the quality of food and drinks. Thanks Joey Gerard’s :)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Relish Tray, BBQ Ribs, Tavern Steak