Penny's Erin Restaurant & Motel

911 WI-83, Hartford
(262) 966-1050

Recent Reviews

Michael Krause

Came in by myself for an early breakfast, sat at the bar and ordered a coffee, two eggs, hashbrown and bacon along with a pancake on the side. Everything came out really fast, and the pancake with the crispy edges flapping over the side of the plate was amazing. The prices were very reasonable as well . Will be back again.

Service: 5

Scott Lopas

Always delicious with down home friendly flavor and service. Loved the pancake, hung over the edge of my plate! Barely needs syrup it's so flavorful. An iconic stop along that stretch of Hwy 83 south of Hartford.

Service: 5

scott gramling

Best breakfast in

Service: 5

Andrew Turek

Awesome

Linda Beckman

Burgers all ways good!

Gerald Witkowski

Food was great along with the service, we will be back.

Service: 5

Erik Rossing

Amazing food for an amazing price!

Emily Morrissette

The cutest, homiest, small town feel! The best food!

Service: 5

Sam

I would give zero stars if I would. We came in after church at 1:15 not knowing what time they close. My family and I walked in and right away the 3 lady's at the counter all looked at the clock and said "we close in 15 minutes" not in a nice way but just attacking us saying we are closing in 15 minutes. The ladys where making rude faces and rolling their eyes. Then the one lady said "Okay, I'll babysit them." Even customers in the restaurant heard and they looked in shock how they talked to us. So we just left. It was very disturbing how they just attacked us and where not kind at all. We will never go back and never recommend this business again and tell this story to people.

Julia J.

Went in for brunch after mass and was immediately berated the second we walked in. The three women at the front counter looked at the clock and said "we close in fifteen minutes," visibly rolled their eyes and one said "I'll babysit them" before we decided to leave. If someone's that rude, I don't care how good your food is. I'd give zero stars if I could.

Lori Goersch

Never stayed at motel but have been there many times for breakfast and it is absolutely delicious!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ken Kartman

If you're looking for a friendly, clean, country cafe, this is the place! Penny is great ...and so is her staff. Best pancakes ever!

Richard Jurewicz

If you're ever in the area and you want a great breakfast at very reasonable prices, stop at Penny's. Fridays are 1/2 price pancake day, they're huge, cooked perfectly and delicious. Like many have mentioned, the staff is very friendly, Penny stopped by our table and chatted for a few minutes, a very sweet lady. Keep your eyes open or you might drive right past it thinking it's just a Motel. Stop in, you won't be disappointed. Cash only.

Courtney Wiegmann

Well worth the scenic drive on an autumn Saturday morning. We both got a little of everything and it was delicious! We will be back.

Vincent DiCarlo

This is my all-time favorite breakfast and burger place. It is like something from the past emerging out of the mist of time. Wonderful informal atmosphere. Low prices. Friendly efficient and attentive service. A place where local people come to chat with each other and with the staff, which consists of the owner, her family, and one or two others who expertly work the grill behind the counter. The burgers are amazing. Just the right amount of fresh beef on a delicious grilled soft bun. When I ordered a burger with mushrooms, Swiss cheese, fried onions, and bacon, more of the extras fell out as I was eating it than the whole amount that comes with most burgers. When I came back a couple of days later for an egg burger, the sunny side up egg I asked for was perfectly done. The chicken noodle soup was also excellent. I only wish I didn't live 2,000 miles away from the place. I will miss it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Load More

Penny's Erin Restaurant & Motel

911 WI-83, Hartford, WI 53027
(262) 966-1050