EDDY'S ON THIRD

15882 3rd St, Hayward
(715) 934-4407

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Hayward Hot Sandwich Fresh Cut Fries and Turtle Cookie

Ruben Egg Rolls Fried Poutini & Cheese Curds

1 2 Popper Bomb Beef Steak Burger

1 2 lb Beef Steak Smashed Burger

Reuben Portabella on the Right

Chicken Sandwich

Olive Burger

Italian Beef

Photos

+16 photos

+15 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Eddysonthird

Recent Reviews

I recommend any item on the menu, because, every item I’ve tried has been filled with so much flavor and fullness that I keep returning to try a different item. Great fast service as well. Very friendly!

October 2025

I work in the industry, so I hate putting a place on blast, but jeez. it was awful. I always thought it was an old adage that the steak was tough as old shoe leather, but I finally experienced it. The tenderloin sandwich was inedible. The bourbon sauce was good, but couldn't make up for the fact that the meat could barely be cut with a sharp steak knife. How do you make tenderloin that tough? The chicken BLT tasted okay, but was sloppily thrown together. And the fries!!!!...

July 2025

I ate here 4 times in the past 5 days of my week long vacation to the beautiful Northwoods. I’ve had the schnitzel and the Italian beef previously during past vacations and they were just as delicious as I remembered them to be. The new to me menu items that I tried this time around were the weekly special German-inspired burger and the Nashville hot chicken sandwich. The burger was fantastic, but the Nashville chicken was hands down the best chicken sandwich that I’ve ever...

July 2025

More Reviews

Restaurants in Hayward, WI

EDDY'S ON THIRD

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Order Online

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

EDDY'S ON THIRD