5 Best Seafood Restaurants in Hayward

“We went for the first time last night for the fish fry. Everything was amazing! The fish was lightly breaded and had great taste, it, along with the steak cut fries were cooked to perfection. A tasty old fashioned. Fantastic service from Bonnie. My niece inhaled her burger, and we even shared a delectable dessert. Wonderful experience!“

“Usually this place is awesome, from sitting down, getting food, then leaving. I have been here for over an hour for breakfast and havent got my food yet. Took 20 minutes to even have a server bring coffee and a menu once we sat down.“

“Wife and I made a reservation (very important for popular long established Supper Clubs) and arrived early to experience the bar where we met owner Tom who was very busy before our dinner but after dinner drinks at the bar Tom couldn’t have been more engaging & informative. At dinner, server was friendly, engaging and very professional. Heather checked back with us several times during our meal to ensure we had everything we needed. Salads were mixed greens with mandarin orange side not just iceberg lettuce, thousand island dressing high quality. Wife ordered the filet and I ordered the ribeye and Snitzel, all cooked exactly as ordered(medium rare) with a noticeable crusty seasoning that did not overpower the taste of the meat, very delicious. The potato pancakes were some of the best I’ve ever had, not thin and greasy but thick, crisp edges with a depth of flavor rarely found. The Snitzel will give Austrian Snitzel a run for the money! The relish tray was diverse and delicious, very unique. Pricing of menus choices very different in that you can choose a low priced meal or a high priced meal. Tastefully decorated thru out, clearly a Bavarian theme that fits well in the Northwoods. Certainly would recommend and will revisit when in the area.“

“We have been coming to Hayward for 20 years and this was seriously the best chicken bowl that I’ve ever had and hands-down the best kids food. The fresh vegetables, including baked potato was magnificent and the mac & cheese was hands-down the best bar food mac & cheese ever. Service was also excellent. We will actually already be coming back here tomorrow again to eat ! Can’t get enough“

“Delicious meal, friendly service.“